News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRC.com outlines its roadmap by em-bee on Sunday December 09, 2018 @04:15AM (#18640052)
IRC is, and always was a walled garden. yes, IRC servers can be distributed, but they can't be federated. IRC hails from a time of the internet when it was so small that everyone pretty much could trust everyone else. someone who controls one IRC server is more or less able to control the entire network.

if there are IRC servers that can't be trusted, they can't join the network, and hence will form a network of their own. there are dozens of networks out there (hundreds if you include smaller ones), and each one is an island. if i am on a different IRC network than you, then we can not talk to each other.

the only worthwhile improvement of IRC would be to turn it into a federated protocol to rival XMPP or other alternatives. i am not sure that is even possible though, but i wish it is, and i wish that this is where irc.com will be going.

i do look forward to see IRC brought into the modern age.

Re:IRC.com outlines its roadmap by devwastaken on Sunday December 09, 2018 @06:19AM (#18640342)
I don't think it can be. Everything irc does is better done centralized. The big problem is leaking of user iP's. Ip's regardless of how they work technically are treated by police and courts as a unique identifier. As sad as it may be, Discord thrives far more than IRC ever did for that very good reason. All content has to be proxied, and that costs big bucks.

One way around it would be to stick to embedding of content only from a small number of known sites, but even then things like YouTube can still show geography of viewers iirc. Plus if those sites get tired of your bandwidth they can just block you, no negotiation of money if you don't have big bucks.

But regardless of how it's done, when you host your own actual server, you're now liable. You're identifiable, and In the U.S. identity is all that's required for any civil case, which could be thrown at you by anyone for any reason. When you host yourself you're taking on legal liability for your users, too, such as underage users that get access to pornography through it.

Re:IRC.com outlines its roadmap by wowaname on Sunday December 09, 2018 @04:29AM (#18640075)
I think the best approach to the issue of IRC not being federated is to create a separate protocol that can not only do that, but also learn from the mistakes of IRC. By design IRC is not very extensible, and because of the initial limitations of the protocol and the divided opinions on what IRC should be, we have each software vendor proposing different standards and clients that have to support all of these differences. While IRCv3 is making efforts to standardise everything, there are still very large networks that will never switch from the old-style IRC and we still have that backwards-compatibility kludge in our way when we try to build modern clients. Creating a new, modern protocol from scratch hopefully allows us not to repeat these issues and have some foresight about extensibility, elegance, and standardisation.

And before anyone proposes Matrix to fill in that blank, I do not believe that it is at all suitable for the goals it is trying to accomplish.