News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by ryanwaggoner on Saturday December 08, 2018 @09:46AM (#18635455)
To be fair, that's not all it leads to. I'm not saying that it was the best way to do it, but the energy industry over the last ~150 years has driven nearly unimaginable increases in human development, standard of living, poverty reduction, and technology.

That said, in 2018 we have little excuse for our current track. We couldn't have done solar or nuclear instead of oil 100 years ago, but we can today, and the fact that we're not is shameful.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by nicholas73 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:51AM (#18635770)
Solar or nuclear primarily generates electricity, which little oil is used for. They also have problems with supply/demand load balancing, and there isn't a good storage solution for that yet. Lastly, oil products have energy density that batteries are barely starting to be capable of. Tesla is just getting started, but the world will still need jet fuel.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by devcpp on Saturday December 08, 2018 @12:21PM (#18636274)
Solar and nuclear could serve to recharge car batteries so it's not completely inaccurate. As for the battery capacity problem, the combination of more recharge stations (say, next to the workplace) and more efficient car sharing/renting when you actually need to go far can solve that. So it's also a logistics problem.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by bunnycorn on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:34AM (#18635991)
> oil products have energy density that batteries are barely starting to be capable of

Not even close, diesel/gasoline stores 35 MJ/l, a good battery (lithium-metal, much better than lithium-ion), 4.32 MJ/l

Now, if only we could extract 90% of that diesel stored energy.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by sdenton4 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @12:46PM (#18636400)
Via Wikipedia: "Modern gasoline engines have a maximum thermal efficiency of about 25% to 50% when used to power a car."

Meanwhile, the average passenger car in 2000 created 11,000 pounds of co2 over the course of a year... I don't think I had seen that number before - no wonder there's a problem. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exhaust_gas

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by CydeWeys on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:39AM (#18636018)
If you can't actually extract it (because of limitations like Carnot efficiency, etc.), does it actually count? What's the real figure for usable energy in diesel?
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by leetcrew on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:04PM (#18636880)
diesel engines can exceed 45% efficiency [0], so lithium ion would have to more than triple in energy density to be competitive (using GP's numbers).

that said, diesel is mainly used in large trucks and shipping vessels, where I would imagine energy per unit volume would be more important than energy per unit mass. if electricity were much cheaper than diesel fuel, it could certainly become the economic choice for all but the longest routes.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_engine#Major_advantages

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by erikpukinskis on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:31PM (#18637037)
Regenerative breaking could theoretically get you 2x.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by CydeWeys on Saturday December 08, 2018 @03:56PM (#18637486)
Regenerative braking gets you basically nothing on long steady-speed routes. Energy leaves the system primarily through air resistance and to a lesser degree mechanical and rolling resistance. Trucks crossing the country can go 60mph on cruise control for hours on end.

Regenerative braking helps more for stop-and-go driving in cities but it's basically meaningless for long-haul trucking or shipping.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by erikpukinskis on Sunday December 09, 2018 @05:11PM (#18643621)
It also gets you something where there is altitude gain.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by dredmorbius on Saturday December 08, 2018 @03:35PM (#18637370)
In practice, a few percent, <10% AFAIR.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by maxerickson on Saturday December 08, 2018 @12:46PM (#18636406)
Depends on what you are doing.

An awful lot of energy consumption is just fine with waste heat, it doesn't need a heat engine. There you get 90% efficiency even with heating oil.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by CydeWeys on Saturday December 08, 2018 @03:53PM (#18637470)
If you need heating, the efficiency of an electricity-powered heat pump is around 300%, so batteries are actually competitive here.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by nathan_long on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:15AM (#18648450)
> oil products have energy density that batteries are barely starting to be capable of

"Grandpa, tell me again about combustion engines."

"Well, they burned gasoline in a series of tiny explosions, and they were set up so that the timing of those explosions would generate motion."

"Haha, that sounds like a Rube Goldberg machine."

"Yes, and the worst part is that fire is hot. So even though gasoline contains a lot of energy, the process of turning it into motion was fantastically inefficient. They turned so much of the energy into useless heat that they needed whole separate systems just to throw it all away so the darn things wouldn't melt."

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by bunderbunder on Saturday December 08, 2018 @09:55AM (#18635490)
It has, but I still can't help feeling like we can do better.

I was looking at concept drawings from Walt Disney's original conception of EPCOT, back when it was supposed to be a living community and not just a theme park. What struck me is, that sort of environment doesn't just seem to offer a more pleasant and human way of life; it's also probably way more efficient, both economically and environmentally, than typical communities in the USA.

So, yeah, development was fast, but it followed a greedy search and got trapped in a local optimum.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by ryanwaggoner on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:02AM (#18635519)
I think our algorithm is a lot more complicated than greedy search, if you just step back and look at it through a longer timescale. We're not "trapped" in a local optimum, we've just reached one, and the algorithm is just now realizing it and starting to explore alternatives.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by akiselev on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:51AM (#18635767)
It's not the fact that it's complex that's the problem, it's the fact that it is adversarial. Not in a "survival of the fittest" kind of way but in a "we have to exterminate this other group/ideology because it is a perceived long term threat to us" kind of way. Or, as a substitute in polite society, "it doesn't how much we have together, as long as I'm guaranteed to have more than you."
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by mobilefriendly on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:07AM (#18635848)
We are very much trapped. The entire U.S. political system is geared towards automobile-based structure at every level of government. Coal is embedded as well. Imagine if the federal government had never subsidized the interstate system, how different our cities would look.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by ryanwaggoner on Saturday December 08, 2018 @07:53PM (#18638500)
Again, too short a timeline. Our energy landscape will be totally different in 100 years.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by ppseafield on Saturday December 08, 2018 @12:00PM (#18636143)
> We couldn't have done solar or nuclear instead of oil 100 years ago

Well, as of the 70s we were doing both. Hell, Jimmy Carter even put solar panels up at the White House. (Reagan took them down.)

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by RobertoG on Saturday December 08, 2018 @12:31PM (#18636327)
Not only that, but:

"An electric vehicle held the vehicular land speed record until around 1900."

(from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_electric_vehicl...)

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by ars on Saturday December 08, 2018 @07:56PM (#18638527)
> even put solar panels up at the White House.

They were not solar panels (for electricity), they were solar water heaters, and they didn't work very well, which is why they were taken down.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by rubyfan on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:27AM (#18635651)
I have to agree it's been a great springboard and we should be doing more. I think the reality on the ground is that solar has only achieved attractive efficiency levels in most recent years. Similarly electric vehicle range and cost has only started to become achievable in recent years. Right or wrong nuclear has always had a perception of danger to it that the most people would say NIMBY. It's understandable there is still a thriving market in the developed world for petroleum fuels.

I think we've finally reached a point now were the market is offering both individual and larger scale commercial/public energy solutions. It takes time for new infrastructure investment - it's lots of small efforts. Given the reality on the ground in most of the developed world I have to imagine it takes another 50 years to get to majority renewables.

So what's a petroleum producing world power to do? Seems like ensuring a balance of power and energy production for the next 50 years of world development is a responsible thing to do.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by drb91 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:46AM (#18636050)
That’s not really “fair”, though, the positive aspects of oil will be severely tempered by the myriad effects of global warming.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by perfunctory on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:02AM (#18635515)
> but the energy industry over the last ~150 years has driven nearly unimaginable increases in human development, standard of living, poverty reduction, and technology.

Depends on what is understood by the standard of living. The situation where some people have to spend 6 hours a day trapped inside their vehicles just to get to work and back home, hardly can be seen as a high standard of living.

I tend to be quite sceptical about the claims that high energy consumption is imperative for higher standard of living.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by drak0n1c on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:20AM (#18635616)
Before fossil fuels instead of some people spending up to 6 extra hours a day sitting in motorized transport nearly all people in every society were spending those 6+ extra hours doing back-breaking work in the fields.
Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by perfunctory on Sunday December 09, 2018 @06:23AM (#18640358)
That’s a bit of a myth. In feodal european soscieties - maybe. But not in _every_ sosciety.

> The Kapauku people of Papua think it is bad luck to work two consecutive days. The !Kung Bushmen work just two-and-a-half days per week, rarely more than six hours per day.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Working_time

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by ryanwaggoner on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:07AM (#18635533)
I understand, believe me. There's still a lot of suffering and misery in the world. We have far to go.

But there has been a pretty clear increase in standard of living, even if you consider that some people have long commutes in climate-controlled vehicles with comfortable seats and media devices at their fingertips, on their way to jobs where they earn a PPP-adjusted income that's historically and globally very high.

Think of the global decreases over the past century in starvation, disease, infant mortality, maternal mortality, illiteracy, accidental death, etc.

Things aren't perfect because they'll never be perfect, but that doesn't mean we haven't made progress overall.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by arbitrary_name on Saturday December 08, 2018 @04:43PM (#18637705)
And what if all of the progress is undone by cripplying drought, flooding, intense storms, crop shortages?

There is no denying that fossil fuels have brought an unprecedented level of wealth and prosperity. But what we need to do is face up to the fact that we will lose all of those gains if we arent willing to sacrifice some if them to avoid disaster. Sharing renewable tech with developing countries, ending fossil fuel subsidies, taxing emissions, legislating with a healthy environment as a first priority - they will make many a little bit worse off, but are utterly crucial for any hope of a prosperous future.

Re:US Is Net Oil Exporter for First Time in 75 Years by ryanwaggoner on Saturday December 08, 2018 @07:55PM (#18638511)
I agree that we need to make those changes but I think we will, just too late. And yet I still don’t think we’ll “give up all the gains” of the past 150 years.