News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by freen on Friday December 07, 2018 @03:54PM (#18631524)
I wonder if I can append to every web request a header that has my personal terms of service and if companies don't want to comply to MY terms, they can simply refuse service.

Seems reasonable, right?

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by theamk on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:06AM (#18634252)
This looks very similar to P3P protocol. It required that that each website announces its privacy-related TOS in machine-readable format, and it is your browser which compares announced settings to your personal preferences, and refuses the service if they do not match.

> P3P will compare what personal information the user is willing to release, and what information the server wants to get – if the two do not match, P3P will inform the user and ask if he/she is willing to proceed to the site

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P3P

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by eslaught on Friday December 07, 2018 @04:11PM (#18631722)
Maybe this was intended as a joke, but if someone with legal experience can reply, I'd be interested to know how far this can actually fly.

After all, companies frequently have "drive-by" EULAs that you "agree" to by simply not leaving the site, so if that's legally binding, why is the reverse not true?

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by kanon on Friday December 07, 2018 @04:30PM (#18631863)
After all, you're the first one to send a request to the webserver, including your terms. By responding they are automatically agreeing to your terms.
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by seandougall on Friday December 07, 2018 @06:02PM (#18632505)
I certainly hope it was a joke. I don't personally want to see a Web where every HTTP request has to be manually reviewed by a human, let alone a whole legal department, before a response can be issued.
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by tagrun on Friday December 07, 2018 @06:19PM (#18632589)
And I certainly hope you're joking.

I also don't personally want to read a terms of service, let alone hire a lawyer to tell me it's consequences for every HTTP request, before it gets shoved down my throat one-sidedly in the form "if you're using this site you agree everything our legal department wrote which gives us the right to trample your rights however we like using all the legal loopholes out there, and sometimes even beyond, and hey we'll also be forcing US laws on you even if you're in a totally independent country while ignoring your hard-earned rights protected by your country's laws", but it's somehow the standard practice.

That kind attitude is a serious double standard going on for years, favoring corporations and companies over the rights of individuals. So forgive me when I find it very hard to sympathize with anything you said.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by comex on Friday December 07, 2018 @08:14PM (#18633188)
In the US, at least, so-called “browsewrap” agreements, those that are linked in a website footer and purpose to bind you simply for visiting a site, are legally unenforceable. However, “clickwrap” agreements, where you get a text box with the terms and have to click “agree”, are enforceable – despite the unlikelihood that even a single user read the terms before agreeing. I don’t like either type, but it’s important to distinguish them. You won’t be bound just for receiving an HTTP response, any more than you can bind someone else by sending an HTTP request; there has to be a human in the loop knowingly choosing to agree to something, even if they don’t know what it is they’re agreeing to.

That said, I don’t know much about how other countries’ legal systems treat such agreements, but from what I’ve heard, they tend to be equally or more restrictive of them, not less.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by danShumway on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:41AM (#18634713)
There's an interesting side effect to adblocking, which is that sometimes even the clickwrap agreements get blocked and the user never gets a chance to see them in the first place.

I wonder how many sites I've visited where blocking 3rd-party scripts broke their Javascript and prevented them from ever giving me a TOS popup. I have no way of knowing for certain, but given that I regularly find websites where the box does pop up but doesn't work properly, it's probably not zero.

IANAL, but if I was a site operator and I really needed absolutely every visitor to my website to be legally bound by a TOS, a Javascript-powered clickwrap agreement would not personally help me sleep any better at night.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by tagrun on Friday December 07, 2018 @08:24PM (#18633236)
> those that are linked in a website footer and purpose to bind you simply for visiting a site, are legally unenforceable.

Before going to other countries: are you referring to a very recent local Florida state law (after Vitacost.com, Inc. v. James McCants, found with a quick search), or is there an even newer federal US law?

> That said, I don’t know much about how other countries’ legal systems treat such agreements, but from what I’ve heard, they tend to be equally or more restrictive of them, not less.

Given no such law existed even in Florida until last year, I'd be more cautious before extrapolating this internationally.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by comex on Saturday December 08, 2018 @07:39AM (#18634956)
I'm a bit confused what you mean. There is no law, but quite a bit of precedent in various U.S. jurisdictions, including from the federal appeals courts of two different circuits, as listed on Wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Browse_wrap

The Vitacost case you mentioned is not listed there but, looking at the decision, seems to be a straightforward application of two of the precedents (Nguyen v. Barnes & Noble and Hubbert v. Dell); it doesn't disagree with them.

I did forget one complication when writing my previous post, which is, at least according to the aforementioned Hubbert v. Dell, there are some circumstances where a browse-wrap agreement may be enforceable:

> In 2005, the Illinois Appellate Court ruled in favor of a browse-wrap agreement in Hubbert v. Dell Corp. In this case consumers of Dell products were repeatedly shown the words "All sales are subject to Dell's Term[s] and Conditions of Sale", including a conspicuous hyperlink, over a series of pages. The court found that this repeated exposure and visual effect would put a reasonable person on notice of the "terms and conditions".

But that's fairly different from a typical browse-wrap agreement.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by danShumway on Friday December 07, 2018 @07:26PM (#18632920)
It's both stupid to attach an implicit TOS to an HTTP request and stupid to attach one to an HTTP response. I want to see us move away from implicit TOS. I don't want to see us go farther down that hole.

It's like claiming, "well, if my local factory can dump toxic waste in the river, why can't I?" You're right, it's a double standard that you're held to more accountability than your local factory. But the correct way to fix that double standard is to go after the factory, not to say, "well heck with it, everybody can dump now."

My ultimate goal is to keep the river clean, not to make things fair.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by tagrun on Friday December 07, 2018 @08:02PM (#18633138)
> well, if my local factory can dump toxic waste in the river, why can't I?

Yes, that can be one interpretation, but only with intended irony, not literally.

But suppose you're saying it literally; you wouldn't because you're living there. And also because regulations will never allow you to, because your local company has your politicians in their pockets and they effectively get a free pass in the form of bills thanks to ~~legitimized bribing~~ lobbying while you'll just be sent to prison. Which is a part of the irony I was trying to point out.

> My ultimate goal is to keep the river clean, not to make things fair.

It's very easy to say such things. Words are cheap. How exactly were you going to keep the river clean toward your ultimate goal, again? By offering your stashed billions on the moon as counter-lobby during next elections? Are you also going give us World Peace and unicorns while you're at it? Or assuming you also know how unrealistic you actually sound, would you just be content by opposing the dissent in favor of the status quo by pretending to take the moral high ground?

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by danShumway on Friday December 07, 2018 @08:44PM (#18633323)
I assume that most people here are trying to make a point with the suggestion, not actually to trying to suggest an action that normal people should take. The fact that it's ridiculous to imagine tying a TOS to an HTTP request is illustrative of the fact that it's ridiculous to tie a TOS to the response.

> It's very easy to say such things. How exactly were you going to keep the river toward your ultimate goal, again?

Again, I get that you're probably just trying to talk about how broken our current legal system is and how difficult it is to change that. I agree, and I'm probably preaching to the choir when I say this.

But if you mean it meant literally, I would say that a good starting point is trying not to one-up the factories with our own pollution. It is very hard to stop factories from dumping toxic waste into the river. It is harder to stop both factories and every one of my neighbors from dumping toxic waste into the river.

That's all that I'm getting at. TOS reform is already a very hard problem, and we should avoid making it harder than it already is.

I can imagine that it might feel good for someone to say, "if corporations don't want to play fair, then we'll make it so literally every action on the web will require a lawyer," in the same way that it might feel good to say, "if corporations don't care about the environment, we'll see how they feel once we've just burned all the trees."

But that would really be cutting off our own noses to spite our collective face.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by wilg on Saturday December 08, 2018 @12:31AM (#18634077)
Random idea: HTTP Basic TOS. Just like HTTP Basic Auth, but instead of presenting the user with a login form it presents you with legalese.
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by stordoff on Friday December 07, 2018 @07:23PM (#18632908)
That's almost exactly the situation we're in now (with the _slight_ difference that it's before I can use the response to a request).
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by Animats on Friday December 07, 2018 @04:52PM (#18632033)
Look up "Battle of the Forms".
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by freen on Friday December 07, 2018 @07:46PM (#18633052)
Fascinating!

If I understand correctly, the last provided contract is what holds for service transactions. So, unless tracking pixels also serve a tos back, my terms of service provided in the header determine the legal status of the transaction.

Websites, on the other hand, because the html includes the TOS, and the final contract.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by 13415 on Friday December 07, 2018 @04:13PM (#18631737)
Yes, that's perfectly possible, of course. Companies hate such ideas because they can have legal standing under certain circumstances and in certain legislations, or at least have a potential to create some problems.

You could also print out EULAs and ToS, modify them as you think is reasonable, and send the modified version back by snail mail as a contract suggestion with a short note stating that you find the original version unacceptable for various reasons and have made these suggestions for alterations. If enough people would do that - a few thousand might suffice - many currently ridiculous and frivolous EULAs would probably be changed very soon.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by seandougall on Friday December 07, 2018 @05:43PM (#18632385)
Depends on how badly the company needs your individual business, and/or how much you want their services, since they're under no obligation to accept or even review your proposed amendments. I suspect very few companies would have an incentive to take them seriously.

We get fairly routine requests from state universities and similar institutions who want us to fill out various forms, agree to supplemental terms, or alter our EULA for their special cases. Labor and legal costs would mean we'd lose money on lots of those sales, so we just respond with a blanket "sorry, we can't do that, good luck to ya" type message. The customer is then free to go about their lives without our software, or (more often) find some way to agree to the EULA as-is after all.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by freen on Friday December 07, 2018 @07:29PM (#18632938)
And websites are free to refuse to serve me if they don’t accept MY terms.

It goes both ways.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by hedora on Saturday December 08, 2018 @01:38AM (#18634213)
As I understand it, contract law says the last speaker wins, so this should work in theory. I’d love to see it tested.

By downvoting this comment you agree to send me 10% of your income for the next 10 years. ;-)

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by jakobdabo on Friday December 07, 2018 @04:04PM (#18631643)
No, your personal terms of service would be just another identifier to track your browsing.
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by freen on Friday December 07, 2018 @04:10PM (#18631706)
Perhaps that might be a violation of my copyright and intellectual property. My terms supersede theirs. Says so in the first paragraph.
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by bduerst on Friday December 07, 2018 @04:39PM (#18631944)
Broadcasting your terms isn't the same as the listener agreeing to it. You aren't guaranteed copyright just because you say so - i.e. you don't have a copyright on films made of you in public.
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by elicash on Friday December 07, 2018 @05:03PM (#18632116)
> Broadcasting your terms isn't the same as the listener agreeing to it.

This is the point OP seems to be making about online publishers.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by izzydata on Friday December 07, 2018 @05:37PM (#18632335)
But that is exactly what websites are doing.
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by stordoff on Friday December 07, 2018 @07:30PM (#18632944)
How is this different to including terms and conditions on a web page? If they can ignore the terms, why can't I?
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by NegativeK on Friday December 07, 2018 @07:01PM (#18632807)
> Seems reasonable, right?

Not to the legal system.

This Week in Law, on the TWiT network, covered this some years ago. The lawyers on the panel agreed that it wouldn't hold at all. I believe (this memory is hazier) that their reasoning was that it's clear that the website is presenting a take-it-or-leave-it contract, and it's easy for you to leave it.

Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by freen on Friday December 07, 2018 @07:36PM (#18632989)
I too am offering a take-it-or-leave-it contract, prior to any other contract with the website, delivered to an endpoint that is specifically empowered to enter into contractual relationships with clients.
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by cmorgan31 on Friday December 07, 2018 @08:37PM (#18633292)
Wouldn’t this dilemma ultimately end with server middleware rejecting requests for anyone savvy enough to us a custom TOS header contract?
Re:Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track? by NegativeK on Saturday December 08, 2018 @01:09PM (#18636539)
If you have any legal citation, I'd like to read more.