I wonder how many sites I've visited where blocking 3rd-party scripts broke their Javascript and prevented them from ever giving me a TOS popup. I have no way of knowing for certain, but given that I regularly find websites where the box does pop up but doesn't work properly, it's probably not zero.
IANAL, but if I was a site operator and I really needed absolutely every visitor to my website to be legally bound by a TOS, a Javascript-powered clickwrap agreement would not personally help me sleep any better at night.
Before going to other countries: are you referring to a very recent local Florida state law (after Vitacost.com, Inc. v. James McCants, found with a quick search), or is there an even newer federal US law?
> That said, I don’t know much about how other countries’ legal systems treat such agreements, but from what I’ve heard, they tend to be equally or more restrictive of them, not less.
Given no such law existed even in Florida until last year, I'd be more cautious before extrapolating this internationally.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Browse_wrap
The Vitacost case you mentioned is not listed there but, looking at the decision, seems to be a straightforward application of two of the precedents (Nguyen v. Barnes & Noble and Hubbert v. Dell); it doesn't disagree with them.
I did forget one complication when writing my previous post, which is, at least according to the aforementioned Hubbert v. Dell, there are some circumstances where a browse-wrap agreement may be enforceable:
> In 2005, the Illinois Appellate Court ruled in favor of a browse-wrap agreement in Hubbert v. Dell Corp. In this case consumers of Dell products were repeatedly shown the words "All sales are subject to Dell's Term[s] and Conditions of Sale", including a conspicuous hyperlink, over a series of pages. The court found that this repeated exposure and visual effect would put a reasonable person on notice of the "terms and conditions".
But that's fairly different from a typical browse-wrap agreement.
That said, I don’t know much about how other countries’ legal systems treat such agreements, but from what I’ve heard, they tend to be equally or more restrictive of them, not less.