News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by bdittmer on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:29PM (#1861664)
What constitutes an established account? I rarely comment on posts but have had an account for 2.5+ years and regularly upvote posts and comments. Is my account "established"?
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by jakestein on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:40PM (#1861721)
I have no first hand knowledge, but I would be surprised if a 2.5 year old account with 250 of karma (like you do) is not considered established enough for this purpose.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by AgentConundrum on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @04:34PM (#1862222)
I wouldn't, actually. I've got comparable karma (221) after about two years, and I can't even consistently downvote items. I noticed down arrows a while ago for comments, but recently I've noticed that they only appear on certain comments, and others are upvote only. My assumption has been that there is some sort of inflation at play.

Not that I'm complaining of course. I think I've only used my downvote powers once normally. The only other time I've used such powers was when I noticed some spam comments, and chose instead to flag them on the noobcomments list.

I honestly think that something like my level of karma is too high a limit for posting things like an RMS. This place isn't reddit, so I take my comments on here a lot more seriously. As such, I don't comment nearly as often since I don't usually feel I have a comment of sufficient intelligence to contribute.

Really, I'm quite amazed anytime I see my karma increase here. I have a definite inferiority complex when reading some of the great comments here.

With experience like that, building any measure of karma could be a slow and arduous process for the typical new user. Unfortunately, I'd imagine a lot of people working on their first project would have the same sort of inferiority complex, yet they would be exactly the sort to benefit the most from an RMS sort of post.

In fact, I'm building (very slowly, thanks to inexperience and a bit of RSI) my first "major" project, and I had hoped to show it off here first, but now that same "I'm not worthy" feeling is making me feel like it wouldn't be welcome.

Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by Revisor on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @05:37PM (#1862477)
You cannot downvote comments older than 24 hours. Submissions can't be downvoted at all.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by hristov on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @05:47PM (#1862511)
Also I believe you cannot down-vote comments you reply to or that reply to you or something of the sort. That is to avoid flame wars.

I think the grandparent (xatax) is being far too timid, I am sure 221 karma is enough to do anything on here that any other non-moderator is allowed to do.

Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by epochwolf on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @08:32PM (#1863054)
Except that PG increased the karma required to downvote from 201 to 501
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by AgentConundrum on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @10:41PM (#1863384)
Well that explains it. Thanks for the update.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by AgentConundrum on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @06:54PM (#1862773)
Odd, I didn't think the post I referred to was that old.

I guess it also makes sense not to have submission downvotes, since the really bad posts will just get killed, and the iffy posts just won't get enough points to get very visible.

Thanks for the explanation.

Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by andre3k1 on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:44PM (#1861742)
What about a 2.5 year old account with no karma? You'd be surprised at how many lurkers there are. I know quite a few (and was one myself up until a short while ago).

EDIT: added emphasis

Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by andymism on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @03:10PM (#1861856)
Karma's really a proxy for community participation, albeit kind of one-sided since you don't get increased karma for up-voting someone else (and rightfully so). I don't think it would be unreasonable to say that if you don't participate, then you don't get to solicit the help of others.

But the bar is much lower than that. For the purpose of just keeping spam accounts out, I think the combination of a karma threshold with average non-karma accruing activity over time (such as upvoting others, clicking through on articles, etc) could be an effective filter.

Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by scottnyc on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @06:00PM (#1862568)
I as well. I've been 'lurking' on hacker news for almost two years. It doesn't mean I don't want to participate, it's just that whenever I do have something to say it's typically been addressed already by another user (the topics I'd probably post on are the hot-topics that draw more eyes.) And I'd rather not add redundancy to comments. To me the natural game mechanics that arise from 'gunning for karma' by being first to post (relevantly) takes a lot of effort.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by David on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @01:48AM (#1863824)
That's basically where I'm at (speaking of redundancy).

I'm usually afraid to say something wrong, since I know that there are always experts on the topic of the post. It makes more sense to me to let said experts explain a particular topic than to possibly disseminate wrong information, even though I might have a useful perspective to add.

Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by patd on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @07:01AM (#1864403)
People shouldn't be afraid to say something wrong. If you say something wrong, people should correct you and everyone will learn (including readers that don't know anything about the subject).

The issue is if people that see that you're wrong, instead of correcting you, just downvote you. In my opinion, a wrong statement should not be buried with downvotes, it should stay at 1 point with a reply that corrects it and that get a lot of upvotes.

Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by boredguy8 on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @06:12PM (#1862614)
I started posting less when the karma ratio became a big deal. But you can still pick up a point or two here and there by making encouraging comments to people far down a thread. This does add value to the community, but it's not a big shot-in-the-arm like a popular submission or a relevant "first post". They do, however, add up.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by davidwparker on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @05:34PM (#1862469)
Agreed. I lurked here for about one year before I made an account. Even after I made an account, I still rarely comment.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by handrake on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @03:46PM (#1862003)
Like myself. Been around for a couple of months now and this is my second comment!
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by pg on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:44PM (#1861744)
The easiest threshold is karma, as for polls.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by WingForward on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:52PM (#1861781)
Just wondering, I've been able to down vote for a few months, but recently, my karma hasn't gone down, but I can no longer down vote comments.

Why would that be?

Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by simonk on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:56PM (#1861802)
The karma needed to downvote moved from 200 to 500.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by tptacek on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:56PM (#1861800)
There's an enforced ratio of downvotes to upvotes that you may have hit. Also: comment more.
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by madd_o on Thursday November 04, 2010 @11:49PM (#1871953)
Hmm, encouraging commenting as a means, not as an end, is engendering a culture of under valued contributions...

I've been a member since late 2009, but I've made 2 or 3 comments so far. My case is not atypical. Maybe there's a better way?

Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by trustfundbaby on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:41PM (#1861731)
I'm sure number of votes and length of membership could be incorporated into some sort of algorithm to determine that?
Re:"Rate My Startup" Post Policy by techbio on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @04:54PM (#1862300)
How about a simple Bayesian classifier for legitimacy? Parameters: account open date, date of first comment, date of last comment, karma, std dev of time between comments.

Good for drawing crooked lines between accounts of a similar age, eg. there is a signature for legitimacy that appears on short (two day) and long (two year) time scales. Talk about specific thresholds seems misplaced when it can be computed from a small training sample.