News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by cortesoft on Monday December 03, 2018 @06:43PM (#18594360)
I think the big issue that most people have with them is the large externality of having scooters littered around the sidewalk.

In a lot of places in West Los Angeles, you are having to step around them constantly if you walk down the street. People literally just drop them in the middle of the sidewalk, because there is no incentive for them to not do that.

This means that everyone who doesn't use the service has to suffer.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by L_Rahman on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:02PM (#18594484)
Functionally this is the easiest problem in the world to solve. It's the same solution for scooters and dockless bikeshare.

Take two parking spots in each block. Put beacons on the corners or some kind of signaling tape around the whole thing. Only let users drop off rides inside that spot. Bonus points for having non-locking racks to help organize.

People get to litter their car on the side of my road, often in the bike lane for free and everyone walks around like it's okay. It's not. Neither are the scooters on the sidewalk. We know how to solve both problems. Parking spots for dockless transit and banning cars from transit and pedestrian rich neighborhoods.

[edit] I removed a line saying I was annoyed that people kept complaining the scooter parking situation. Those complaints point out a very real problem with scooter deployments and that we have a solution for it that is difficult to get passed doesn't make the complaint less valid.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by jakevn on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:35PM (#18594707)
People keep bringing up this problem because it's still a problem. If it's so easy to solve, why is it not solved?

Cities should simply impound any scooter not properly parked and charge $200 to get it back. Since solving the parking problem is so easy, this will push Bird/Lime into finally solving it.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by necubi on Monday December 03, 2018 @08:06PM (#18594878)
It's not easy to solve because people go ballistic if you suggest removing even a single parking space. See for example the 30+ year struggle to develop bus rapid transit on Geary in SF [0], or the effort Bay Area Bikeshare has to go through to get each and every dock approved by the city [1].

Fundamentally the problem is that car-owners currently receive an enormous subsidy in the form of cheap or free street parking and they jealously guard that privilege, even in supposedly progressive cities like San Francisco.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geary_Bus_Rapid_Transit [1] https://www.thebaycitybeacon.com/politics/dude-where-s-my-bi...

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by L_Rahman on Monday December 03, 2018 @08:48PM (#18595162)
I think the other responses summarize the problem quite accurately. In fact, I alluded to it when I mentioned the littering of cars.

People who park cars believe in an inherent first claim to all roadside space above other users and they are extremely aggressive in their resistance to even the slightest loss.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by cortesoft on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:52PM (#18596054)
I think you are being a little unfair to say ALL car parkers feel they own all space next to roads. I am sure some do, but I am a car driver who is happy to give up some space for other forms of transportation. I think there is a happy balance to be found.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by asdff on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:16AM (#18596508)
You are totally right to say this, but local government is the rule of the vocal NIMBY that actually shows up to council meetings, and makes headaches for government officials not working to their beck and call. Local government exists to appease these ignorant few because no one else votes in the elections.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by masonic on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:56AM (#18597636)
"local government is the rule of the vocal NIMBY that actually shows up to council meetings, and makes headaches for government officials not working to their beck and call. "

Would you care to list any city and meeting date in which you have observed this? I'd like to pull the tape and see.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by prawn on Monday December 03, 2018 @08:08PM (#18594891)
Because people on the whole are incredibly resistant to even a tiny loss in street parking. Swapping out a carpark for a parklet that incorporates scooter parking can generate uproar. And action would need to come from the city/council side.

Whenever there is talk of changes to street parking, businesses are outraged at the removal of convenience for their customers. (In most cases, I think they're actually upset at the loss of convenience for their own parking.)

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by ravenstine on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:07PM (#18595341)
> Cities should simply impound any scooter not properly parked and charge $200 to get it back. Since solving the parking problem is so easy, this will push Bird/Lime into finally solving it.

That's true, but then said cities would lose the prestige of being a part of Silicon Valley innovation.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by cortesoft on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:13PM (#18594574)
Right, this is all part of the process, and I am not saying it is insurmountable. When cars first came around, we had no parking laws. Now we do.

We need the parking laws for scooters.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by L_Rahman on Monday December 03, 2018 @08:50PM (#18595173)
This is a very fair response and I completely agree with you.

In fact, I would argue that part of the negotiation that cities ought to do with Bird and Lime and others like it is to make any deploy conditional on the passage of and adherence to scooter parking laws.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by jseliger on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:10PM (#18594542)
the large externality of having scooters littered around the sidewalk.

You and I have very different definitions of "large." I'd call this "very minor."

It also depends on the comparison group. I mean, look at these astounding photos of mammoth, abandoned dockless vehicles: https://slate.com/business/2018/04/astounding-photos-capture....

Cities will, over time, reallocate a small amount of the space currently devoted to very large dockless vehicles to small dockless vehicles and thus solve the problem.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by kerng on Monday December 03, 2018 @06:53PM (#18594425)
Maybe some parking areas for cars can be replaced in favor of scooters and bikes in certain places. Its interesting how we accept that cars are allowed to park nearly everywhere in cities. It's just normal - scooter and bikes will be a new normal also. But hopefully not in addition but instead of cars in some areas.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by cortesoft on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:16PM (#18594589)
Santa Monica has a TON of parking laws. You certainly can NOT just park your car anywhere you want. Pretty much every parking spot available in the city has rules - how long you can park there, how much you have to pay to park there, who is allowed to park there, what permits you need, etc.

We have NONE of this for scooters.

We need these same rules for scooters that we have for cars.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by skybrian on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:29PM (#18594667)
Yes, rules, but probably not the same rules. Allocating space for scooter parking should be a lot easier than for cars, so fewer rules should be needed.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by cortesoft on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:39PM (#18594726)
Sure, but that is kinda beside the point. My point is that we DON'T accept cars just parking everywhere, we decided on rules for where they need to park, and we need to do the same for scooters.

Obviously the rules are going to be different because the vehicles are different and are used differently, but the rules will still have the same basic form: you are allowed to park in these areas, for this amount of time, for this much money.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by skybrian on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:50PM (#18594792)
Well, hopefully for free. There isn't usually a charge for using a bike rack.

Instead the scooter companies should charge for not leaving the scooter in a proper parking spot.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by e40 on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:00PM (#18594475)
I don't so much mind them littering the sidewalk as them being ridden on the sidewalk. They are extremely dangerous for pedestrians. Should I step around that dog poop, I might be hit by a scooter coming up from behind me. I have had close a dozen close calls when I was walking in a straight line. I walk 4 miles/day on sidewalks with these things.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by i_am_nomad on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:35PM (#18594705)
I’ve owned one of them for a couple years, and have stopped riding it because it’s fundamentally dangerous. I felt like on the streets (San Francisco), I was going to get squashed sooner or later. And riding on the Embarcadero (a wide shore-side walkway that’s bicycle friendly), I was sure I was going to eventually hit someone.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by scarejunba on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:55AM (#18596718)
Extremely dangerous? Just so I can calibrate my understanding, what are a couple of other things you consider extremely dangerous?

For me, extremely dangerous means high risk of death or grievous body harm. Something like 100 micromorts per exposure. I want to ensure I'm not underrating this.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by e40 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @10:07AM (#18600007)
I have had 10+ people whiz past me at 20 MPH, within inches of my body. Had I taken a step to the side they were riding, I would have been hit and been pushed to the ground. Had I hit my head, I could have died. People die from head injuries all the time. In the shower, falling down, etc.

Yes, I call this extremely dangerous, because death could result.

Is it likely? No. Is it possible? Yes.

A few years ago a 20 something year old girl was walking in SF and was hit by a bicycle, knocked to the ground and hit her head. She died at the scene. (She was in the crosswalk and the rider was charged with something, I forget.) So, it does happen.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by scarejunba on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @11:52AM (#18601122)
So if you had the following reference points: crossing the road normally as you do (A), skydiving (B), BASE jumping (C) where we know that A < B < C (empirically), does this fall below A, above C, or between two of {A, B, C}, and if so, which two?
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by e40 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:39PM (#18602303)
When I cross the road in a crosswalk, I'm in control. I step off the curb when it's clear.

If I don't want the risk for skydiving, I won't do it. I won't, btw.

Base jumping? No thanks.

Walking 1+ hour/day on sidewalks: I've told you I've had 10+ close calls. There is nothing I can do to mitigate this risk.

I see what you're trying to do, but you're coming off a little dickish.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by scarejunba on Thursday December 06, 2018 @11:53AM (#18619692)
I'm actually not Socratic-methoding this. I'm actually just curious where you estimate your risk at. I do things that some of my friends would consider dangerous (like skiing freestyle) but not things which some of my other friends consider safe (outdoor climbing, scuba diving). In this case, it's actually literally a calibration exercise.

More unsafe than walking. Is walking down the street with these vehicles around you less safe than running a marathon? Or around taking a road-trip across America? Or back-country camping?

Any meeting point here will do.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by e40 on Friday December 07, 2018 @09:33AM (#18627948)
How about is walking down the street with these vehicles around me less safe than walking down the street with these vehicles on the street and not sidewalk?

My risk of harm while walking to/from work increased orders of magnitude, through no change in my own behavior.

I'm starting to feel like I'm being trolled, because I think you know exactly what I just said.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by foob on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:05PM (#18594503)
Yeah, I think this is a fair assessment. Companies like Citibike and Zipcar provide similar benefits, but they do so by isolating their pickups to designated areas where they presumably have approval to operate. These scooter companies use the sidewalk like they own it, and that's pretty obnoxious if you want to use a sidewalk for walking. The big complaint that most people have isn't that scooters are displacing driving, it's that they're using the sidewalks as free scooter storage and externalizing the cost of that to everyone else.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by ravenstine on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:06PM (#18595327)
I feel bad for people in wheelchairs that have to come to a dead stop for these scooters. I live in Santa Monica and regularly see scooters left flat in the middle of the sidewalk. I mean, what the actual fuck? The fact that so many people that use these services lack any respect makes me hesitate to ride the scooters(and thereby join them).
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by scarejunba on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:59AM (#18596737)
There are people who dislike these things so they'll kick them over when they see them. It's not usually the users.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by asdff on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:17AM (#18596510)
A big problem with these is how unsteady they are. I've seen them topple like cards in barely a gust.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by beambot on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:33PM (#18594687)
Curious thought: Disincentivize bad behavior. Scooter companies know who the last user was, so they could develop techniques to apply "parking violations." Whether that means GPS-enabled (sufficient resolution?) or crowdsourced (next rider taking picture) doesn't really matter. But this is like the automobile equivalent of a parking ticket.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by asdff on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:19AM (#18596523)
The first company to do this is the first one that's dead in the water. Right now many users have both apps on their phones since they are functionally identical. Add a con to one, and the userbase will jump ship.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by ravenstine on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:42PM (#18595608)
What incentive would Lime and Bird have to do this? I think that'd have to come about through policy being passed in enough cities.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by cortesoft on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:21PM (#18595869)
Right, this is what makes it an externality... Lime and Bird don't care about it, because the cost is born by people who are not customers. They have no incentive to fix the problem unless forced to.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by beambot on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:54PM (#18596066)
I assume they care about it massively, lest cities drop the hammer a la SF.

Also: it's a fun exercise to go back in time and look at all the laws sponsored by automotive & oil companies to create today's car culture (case in point: streetcars). I assure you: there was a lot of protectionism & it wasn't always about the consumer.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by beambot on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:51PM (#18596047)
Fine the offending user on their next ride? Offer discounts that promote good behavior (to avoid unnecessary regulatory over reach)? Experiment in various locations to figure out what method works best?

It's an entirely new mode of transportation; there are lots of fun things to try as we refactor our world. That's what startups do.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by stingrae on Monday December 03, 2018 @08:51PM (#18595192)
Skip in SF is sort of doing that. The app makes you take a picture of the scooter in its parking spot when you leave it.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by masonic on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:01AM (#18597670)
But they don't verify that a neatly parked scooter in a photo is the specific one you used.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by maxk42 on Monday December 03, 2018 @06:56PM (#18594440)
Especially hurtful to people who have limited mobility and get around with a wheelchair, walker, crutches, or have trouble bending down to move them out of the way. On top of that I've seen them left in bushes, in the street taking up parking space, or blocking doors or gates.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by scarejunba on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:01AM (#18596745)
I don't see what's wrong with them taking up parking space. Considering mean occupancy of cars in America, the street parked scooter is doing just as well in serving one individual as a street parked car. In fact, I'd argue we should remove more parking spots and switch them to scooter spots.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by maxk42 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:40AM (#18597878)
In Hollywood if you take up a parking space with a scooter instead of turning it sideways so a car can still fit you are a massive dick. Parking is a very limited resource here.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by esotericn on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @07:16AM (#18607578)
Can't you just like, get out of the car, move it, then park?

If it's a shared resource like a Bird scooter then there's no moral quandary about "touching other people's stuff" that would make sense for an actual person's property.

The company doesn't care, there's no-one that even can care.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by scarejunba on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:38AM (#18598844)
Which is why you don’t use it for one person’s car instead of five people’s scooters. Enough subsidies for cars.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by SamReidHughes on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:15PM (#18594585)
What about all the cars littered on the sides of the street? Don't you have to walk around those too?
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by cortesoft on Monday December 03, 2018 @07:21PM (#18594620)
No? If you tried to park a car on the sidewalk you will get towed. I mean, in Santa Monica if you are 1 minute late past the time on the sign you will get towed.

The cars are parked in designated spots on the road, with all sorts of rules about how long and how much you have to pay for the spot. In Santa Monica, pretty much every available parking spot has a meter that means you have to pay to park there, and are limited in how long you can park there.

Now, we can have all sorts of public policy debates about how much of a city's public space should be dedicated to parking spots, but at least the public had a say in the policy and at least there IS a policy.

We just need rules around where you can park the scooters and for how long, and how much you have to pay to use the public space to park your scooter.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by SamReidHughes on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:08PM (#18595348)
If the argument for parking is that it's democratically decided, then being able to leave scooters around wherever is also democratically decided. Santa Monica could pass a scooter law whenever it wants to. They don't have a policy on nose-picking or walking without looking where you're going either.

The actual basis of your complaint is that you like parking, but you don't like scooters being put wherever.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by cortesoft on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:26PM (#18595890)
No, my entire point has been that we need laws about where scooters are parked.

I think it is a bit unfair to say we have democratically decided to let scooters park everywhere simply by the fact that we haven't yet passed any laws about where they can park; the law is slow to move, and the scooter parking issue is pretty new. Before Bird and Lime, there were not enough scooters around to be a big enough problem where we needed a law. Now we do, but the law is slow to change.

In the mean time, it is pretty annoying.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by scarejunba on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:02AM (#18596752)
We've democratically decided to allow people to use the new iPhone X. Scooters are the same.
Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by crankylinuxuser on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:44AM (#18599779)
Your use of a phone does not fundamentally devalue the public commons.

Dumping private property on public lands, and expecting the citizens to respect what amounts to abandoned property is absurd.

This is a level 100 class of "Tragedy of the commons". And with enough scooters, the very act of going somewhere on a scooter will be blocked by corporate trash.... Err, limes and birds.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by scarejunba on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @10:05AM (#18599991)
Sure it does. Spectrum is a common resource. That's why it's hard to take a call in a stadium. And we let people bring their phones there.

Besides, dumping private property on public land is what parking cars is. I'm comfortable outlawing this if we outlaw all street parking as well.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by landryraccoon on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:03AM (#18596756)
> No? If you tried to park a car on the sidewalk you will get towed.

This is disingenuous. It ignores all the externalities of car friendly cities that you're taking for granted. Busy streets are wider with more lanes, crosswalks are more inconvenient and take longer to cross. Half of the width of narrow streets is dominated by parking, not to mention all of the unsightly lots and parking garages.

Scooters don't cost millions/billions in real estate for parking. They can't use and don't require expensive freeway onramps. They don't cause massive congestion and the corresponding drop in local air quality. All in all I think if you want to compare externalities, scooters win by far over cars, and it's not even close.

Re:Lime and Bird are growing rapidly by torgian on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:29AM (#18597121)
You must have lived in China. Cars always on the sidewalk