News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by cavisne on Friday November 30, 2018 @10:16PM (#18574860)
Google should leave the EU. Drop an IP block and be done with it.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by thefounder on Friday November 30, 2018 @11:33PM (#18575182)
And then what? Loose almost 50% of its value?
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by ehsankia on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:18AM (#18575871)
These fines are quickly adding up to more than their profit in Europe anyways. Once they reach the point of running profit negative in Europe, wouldn't it actually a better business move to pull out?
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by simion314 on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:44AM (#18576092)
>Once they reach the point of running profit negative in Europe, wouldn't it actually a better business move to pull out?

They can respect the EU regulation, stop the crap in the search and Android and continue making money from the products they sell to enterprises. They will lose some profits but the products that are respecting the laws will continue making money.

Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by ehsankia on Sunday December 02, 2018 @03:54AM (#18581494)
Except you know that won't make them happy. Take the shopping example. They had a product that benefited consumers and businesses, but in the middle, a very tiny slice of the population (which who were in the business of making product comparison sites) were losing, and they cost Googling billions. The EU didn't even tell Google /what/ the solution was, because there isn't any, they just blindly asked them to change things.

That shows you that it's not about "respecting" regulation. It's about shoving it in their face and forcing them to comply.

Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by simion314 on Sunday December 02, 2018 @04:58PM (#18584838)
Google has a monopoly on search, this means if I do a search say "best programming language/framework for X" and if Google hijacks this and put Google products on top then they are abusing the monopoly. It sucks for them they can't abuse it and they can't push their products and make more money.

I think the idea is simple, do web search, don't promote your video,maps, lanugages,services , don't add special code for Google products/services , and stop prompting people to install Chrome if they search with other browsers.

Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by repsilat on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:40AM (#18575931)
They make changes to address each of the issues as they crop up, so the question they need to ask is whether the EU will keep finding reasons to hand out record fines. I guess that boils down to the degree to which they attribute the fines to their own behaviour, and the degree to which they attribute them to European/Vestagerian animus.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by thomasz on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:45AM (#18575944)
The best move would be to start following the laws and regulations governing that market.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by dazc on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:08AM (#18575992)
Until it becomes clear those laws and regulations are nothing more than a vehicle for extracting revenue?
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by thomasz on Saturday December 01, 2018 @05:26AM (#18576168)
There is zero evidence for this accusation. The regulations against monopolies are neither new, nor are they enforced in a discriminatory manner against foreign companies. The EU administration is just doing a better job than it’s American counterpart. Which is a shame because historically, the US was pretty good at reigning into anticompetitive monopolies.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by ehsankia on Sunday December 02, 2018 @03:56AM (#18581502)
And what regulation exactly did they break with the shop comparison issue?

It made consumers lives better, as well as business' lives. The only one losing in there were other shopping comparison sites, but no regulations were broken, yet they still had to pay billions, and the EU /didn't even/ bother telling them what they could change to fix the issue, just that they should do something about it.

The whole "follow regulations" excuse is complete bullshit.

Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by thefounder on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:40AM (#18576073)
Or rather a tool to break up monopolies? I think they should have acted long time ago. I particulary like the changes they are compelled to make on Android.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by anoncake on Saturday December 01, 2018 @10:57AM (#18577252)
We have taxes for that.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by thefounder on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:16PM (#18578983)
Yeah but these companies are not paying the taxes, though it's a separate.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by adventured on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:47AM (#18575598)
All of Europe is about 1/3 of Google's sales. The US is close to 50%. The EU minus the UK is probably more like 25%.

They could certainly rationally abandon the EU market if the fines continue to outpace what the entire EU search market is worth in profit. If you're Google and you can stay somewhere close to break-even on the fines, it's worth staying in the market just to suppress potential competition.

The ideal solution however is the for the US to respond by targeting EU companies, for example Volkswagen and Deutsche Bank (soon to be nationalized as it's collapsing) as two they've already very clearly gone after.

Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by cuban-frisbee on Saturday December 01, 2018 @07:59AM (#18576585)
You really think a company like google could see a 33% drop in revenue and not experience a free fall in the stockmarket? The mere notion of losing that much revenue indefinetly due to their own fault no less would not shake up the market significantly is laughable.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by xanipher on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:19AM (#18576014)
Deutsche Bank and especially VW are already targeted by the US. Just compare the fines for VW in Europe and the US.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by pgeorgi on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:54AM (#18576113)
> Just compare the fines for VW in Europe and the US.

The fines for VW were at the country level, and besides the usual protectionism going on (one of the German states holds a blocking minority in VW by law, go figure) Germany also has a different approach to fines than the US, with much less emphasis on punitive damages.

Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by xanipher on Saturday December 01, 2018 @06:08AM (#18576278)
I'm aware, but "has a different approach to fines" is not really relevant, otherwise this just boils down to "The EU has a different approach to Anti-Trust-Law".
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by thefounder on Saturday December 01, 2018 @02:58AM (#18575819)
I wouldn't mind having some competition even if it's at the expense of VW or D-bank, albeit not on merit.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by AnaniasAnanas on Saturday December 01, 2018 @06:05AM (#18576271)
> Drop an IP block

Why? They can leave the EU without IP blocks.

Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by ekianjo on Friday November 30, 2018 @11:17PM (#18575121)
They would probably still find a way to fine Google even if they did that. The WHY is just an excuse.
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by zlynx on Sunday December 02, 2018 @02:16AM (#18581237)
If Google had no physical presence in the EU then Google can just ignore the fines. The US won't force them to pay fines levied by a different country. They'd have to win a US court case.

Just like China can be upset with Wikipedia. Wikipedia can tell them to pound sand.

Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by chillacy on Sunday December 02, 2018 @07:19AM (#18582023)
And then China blocks Wikipedia’s IP addresses?
Re:Does Google harm local search rivals? EU antitrust regula... by rtomanek on Saturday December 01, 2018 @02:03AM (#18575652)
Why, pray tell?