What should be illegal are programs that silently add a root certificate without the user's informed consent. I very much doubt you disagree with that.
This seems like an OS problem to me. I wish Apple and MS would clamp down on allowing apps to even ask for root to install. I don't think the OS should be as locked as iOS, as a user I still want control, but the fact that so many apps ask for root to install needs to be stopped. 99.9% of all apps need to be sandboxed
I agree, modifying certificates shouldn't be technically impossible but perhaps we could have regulations where companies that do this are penalized. If companies are expected to safeguard customer then facilitating MITM is a huge breach that should result in fines.
A lot of root CAs are backed by national governments anyway, shouldn't they object to being impersonated?
It's also extremely common for companies to install root certificates on work computers that employees use to check their personal email. Why is nobody objecting to this?
A question: if I'm on a work PC that has a root certificate installed, can you tell if they're using it to MITM? When I go to a site on my work PC with the padlock (eg my bank) and click to get more info, it does show the bank's certificate. Can they still be MITMing that connection?
Also,
It's also extremely common for companies to install root certificates on work computers that employees use to check their personal email. Why is nobody objecting to this?
Because you do not own those computers, and they should not be used for non-work-related activity. The company policy will explicitly mention this, something like "all communications on company property are subjected to monitoring at all times."
Just as a thought experiment, lets say I set up a "free computer booth" on a street, but made people tick a box when they started that expressed the same conditions.
Would I then be entitled to MITM and read all communications that passed through that machine?
Why or why not?
No. By this logic your ISP owns the cables and has the right to MITM as well.
On paper all the major browser vendors / operating system vendors (Microsoft, Apple, Google, Mozilla) have independent root trust programmes. But after several years working on this stuff I would say that all real public oversight is done by Mozilla, which AFAICT suits everybody else just fine.
So you can and should help Mozilla "dictate" what is trustworthy. You might be surprised how much difference you can make.
The libertarian dream solution (everybody makes their own trust decisions somehow) is unrealistic in the face of the reality that most people just vaguely assume that "someone" is keeping them safe and lack both the technical knowledge and the spare time to make useful decisions.
Why the scare quotes on “corporation”? Mozilla Foundation is a corporation. Here are he articles of incorporation: https://www-archive.mozilla.org/foundation/documents/mf-arti...
It's a slippery slope towards a world in which the computers we use are completely locked down and we have no control over what they trust, being dictated by the corporations and their interests. The freedom to modify your roots of trust is extremely important and situations like this should not scare us into depriving ourselves out of that. I say this as someone who runs an adblocking/filtering proxy and MITM my own traffic continuously. What's scarier than being MITM'd? Being force-fed by those who want to control your life.
These certificates are used by the software to communicate with the headset using a TLS encrypted web socket.
Why does a headset even need TLS...