Just a minor nitpick about this, forgive me. Overall this post is perfectly agreeable.
Police primarily serve private property owners, with private property being different from personal property.
Private property refers to property which earns their owners accumulated wealth: think landlords, business owners and such. Personal property, such as your smartphone or house are intuitively different from this even though things like this are called private property in vernacular.
I think it's a distinction worth posting about since policing as an institution got its start in union busting and slave catching.
Do you happen to have a good citation for this, I've heard it several times but am not familiar with any scholarship documenting that connection.
The second source seem to support the connection, but doesn't document any actual institutional connections. It relies on similarity, and bald assertion. The existence of overlap between the KKK and local law enforcement is evidence that policing in the US is racist. It isn't actually evidence that the institutions of policing were descended from slave patrols.
I'm not a huge expert on criminal justice, but my degree is history, and these kinds of assertions seem to ignore the parallel developments in NYC, Boston, and other Yankee cities in policing and crime solving that established our idea of a municipal police department. That such departments may have been racist isn't a surprise, virtually every institution in 1880 was, but they were in states that did not practice slavery(abolished in 1799 in NY) and as a result had no institutional history of enforcing it.
Consider that Federal Marshals were so reluctant to enforce laws on the return of escaped slaves that it took an act of congress, with severe financial penalties, to get them to actually enforce the "property claims" of southerners.
1 - http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/ancient/romans/slavery_01.shtml
http://libgen.io/book/index.php?md5=9D2D33DF1F3616A04B72F4D4...
What I find striking is that GP doesn't have facts at hand.
David Friedman has a great summary of how a variety of societies pursue justice and the origins of our own system and comparisons of the systems.
http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Course_Pages/legal_sy...
I think you meant that he got off without conviction, not without charge. He was charged with manslaughter and a couple of felony gun charges, and was tried by a jury on those charges [1].
[1] http://live.mprnews.org/Event/The_trial_of_officer_Jeronimo_...
If you ask someone if they think a large collection of individuals behaves lawfully, the answer should always be "no" because with a large enough group there will always be criminals in that group.
If you're instead thinking about whether police break the law in an organized and collectively deliberate fashion, that's an entirely different question.
Edit: which is to overlook the most glaring examples of NYPD corruption: parking placards and get-out-of-jail-free cards for friends and family (recently reduced from 30 to 20 per officer!). It is not a great exaggeration to claim that the NYPD is America's largest criminal gang.
Why do police act this way?
Have they always acted this way or did something change?
Are police different from other people, that is do they have an innate propensity to act the way they do, or are they conditioned to act this way by their experiences?
What sort of job experiences do police have? Have the experiences of policing changed in recent times, and why?
What systemic factors contribute to the problem? What social factors contribute to the problem?
Thanks to the miracle of the internet, there are many great resources to see the kind of situations real police must routinely navigate. This youtube channel is one of my favorites: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXMYxKMh3prxnM_4kYZuB3g (NSFW, violent content)
In discussion on the subject I've had multiple people who do not know each other say things like "everyone I knew who was a bully growing up became a cop" (and that's a near direct quote). The current state of policing where they can use force to get people to do anything they want and get off scot free even if they're in the wrong definitely attracts a certain personality type.
Granted there's room for alternate interpretations, I think history speaks pretty clearly to the fact that the primary function is maintaining control of populations at scale, and that necessarily implies certain things about the outcome of any law enforcement system.
https://www.cnn.com/videos/us/2016/07/07/graphic-video-minne...
This officer shot into a car seven times with a little girl on board, murdering a man who was cooperating.
And then he gets off without charge, despite there being video evidence. Where is the justice in that? People aren't that dumb, they aren't being treated fairly and they know it.
According to this study, less than 30% of people believe that police behave lawfully.