News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by the_unknown on Sunday November 25, 2018 @09:00PM (#18530459)
Millions in gov't subsidies, a major bailout in 2009 that saved their company, non-stop threats of closure and ongoing clawbacks of manufacturing. And in the end... up and out.

Obviously it is GM's prerogative and can do as they please but it is time for politicians to stop falling for the folly. Just like your stocks and mutual funds - diversify your industries and don't rely on one big player.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by sonnyblarney on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:53PM (#18530929)
"diversify your industries and don't rely on one big player."

Not only easier said than done, it's basically I think the hardest thing to do in governance in business.

The reason subsidies exist is because everything flows from these 'tentpole' industries, it's hard to underestimate.

Canada overall has become less diversified in the last 30 years, and less able to build more sophisticated products, which is not good. There are a host of reasons.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by i_feel_great on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:26PM (#18530815)
This happened in Australia with Toyota, Ford, Holden (GM), and I think before all that, Nissan and Mitsubishi. Also in New Zealand with Mazda/Ford, (edit: Toyota in Thames) at least in my lifetime.

Subsidies have never worked. It seems in the end these companies never paid net taxes and the workers lost their jobs anyway. Subsidies are a scam.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by Judgmentality on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:02AM (#18531441)
> Subsidies have never worked.

I'm skeptical of this, but I don't know that it's wrong. I'm only making this comment in hopes of somebody else more knowledgeable responding to it (either for or against - really I am just curious if subsidies work).

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by sheepmullet on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:59AM (#18532015)
> I'm skeptical of this, but I don't know that it's wrong.

It depends on what you mean by “worked”.

1) Have they allowed a slower and more humane shift of workers to other more competitive industries?

Yes. The GM bailout is a great example.

2) Have they helped keep certain skill sets in a country?

Yes. Undoubtably.

Is this important? I think so but there are opposing arguments.

It can take decades to build up an industry from scratch vs a few years to pivot into a related industry.

Think of how long it would take Germany to swap its automotive engineers and factories to producing tanks vs how long it would take a services based country to start producing tanks.

3) Have they lead to the revitalization of an industry?

This ones a lot more murky and it all depends on what time frame you are looking at and what you think the future will hold.

There are certainly examples of it working between first world countries for limited time periods (a decade or two).

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by nopinsight on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:47PM (#18530900)
It should have long been clear that mass manufacturing in high-wage countries cannot sustainably support as many jobs as it used to be, given low international shipping costs and increasing domestic automation.

The subsidies should be spent to retrain the workers for hard-to-export and costly-to-automate jobs like electricians, plumbers, etc instead. Part of the funds should support their cost of living during the reskilling period as well.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by rpiguy on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:09AM (#18533800)
Politicians aren't falling for anything. They are buying political points to help their next election and keep money in their donors' pockets. It is a shell game. They will bail out another group in the future, rinse and repeat.

It is easy to throw shade at politicians, I am sure there were some that genuinely wanted to preserve jobs for the long haul, but sadly they are a minority.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by chongli on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:11PM (#18530760)
Government's justification for bailing out companies like GM is to ostensibly save jobs. Diversification is great for your economic portfolio but it's not so easy for workers. Telling a laid-off auto worker to switch industries is not a very fair thing to do.

It's far easier to move capital around to different industries. Not so easy to transfer your skills between them.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by 3pt14159 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:30PM (#18530831)
I bitched about it at the time, but the bailouts worked. They saved jobs for ten years, stabilized economies in free fall, and made the governments involved a profit. Ten years of employment is nothing to sneeze at. Plenty of baby boomers hit retirement in that time.

Frankly I'm glad GM is moving out now while the recession still hasn't hit.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by mymythisisthis on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:13AM (#18534326)
I think we should have a four day work week, with one day of free training as the fifth day. Still keeping Saturday and Sunday. With automation it's the only fair thing to do.
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by thoughtexplorer on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:48PM (#18530903)
> Telling a laid-off auto worker to switch industries is not a very fair thing to do.

But we do that all the time and with good reason. Blockbuster employees and coal miners for example. At some point the jobs no longer make sense.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by raverbashing on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:36AM (#18531333)
You're right, except then they support destructive politicians that says the reason they don't have a job in coal anymore is because of "scapegoat of the day" (global warming lies? the EU? Immigrants? not killing puppies?)
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by jammygit on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:59AM (#18534204)
"At some point the jobs no longer make sense."

Blockbuster disappeared because the technology it was built upon became obsolete. It also didn't require specialized labour skills - the employees just took their retail experience across the street.

This just seems like a different kind of situation to me. Automotive isn't going anywhere, GM just couldn't perform.

edit: I'm reading some other comments about drive trains and EVs & reduced manufacturing requirements due to it. That's interesting. Maybe I should read about this more

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by BurningFrog on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:14PM (#18531025)
I'm as opposed to subsidizing individual industries or companies as anyone.

Then again, nothing is forever, and the fact that a single factory closes after a decade doesn't exactly disprove the whole model. That is bound to happen in any industry, subsidized or bailed out or not.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by walrus01 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @09:58PM (#18530711)
The North American auto industry essentially held the Canadian and US governments for ransom in the 2008-2009 financial crisis, "bail us out or we'll go belly up completely, and look how many people will be unemployed!".
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by WrtCdEvrydy on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:00PM (#18530717)
We should have let it happen.

That money could have been funneled into social services instead of propping up industries.

You played and lost, you don't get my tax dollars.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by sonnyblarney on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:17PM (#18531039)
"have been funneled into social services"

Thos jobs pay for the social services of many, and if GM and Ford went kaput, it would wipe out the governments ability to pay for those services.

Now - I'm not saying it's the right thing to subsidize, but in a 'subsidize or collapse' situation, that is the reality.

A corporation has many stakeholders: execs, staff, buyers, suppliers, investors, debtors, and then all the ancillary people who benefit independently - they're all in a power struggle to share in the surpluses.

If a company is facing legit collapse, and the investors are truly willing to bite the bullet, it's because they don't think their is incentive there for them. The surpluses generated may actually be going into the other entities in the power equation: just because investors own the profits does not mean that profits represent the big chunk of surpluses.

My ex-neighbour was a long-tim plant worker, he earned quite a lot, granted he was senior - those are in fact plumb jobs that often pay way above others when you factor healthcare, retirement etc.. Also consider low turnover - most people change jobs every few years and lose a few months pay. When you work in an auto plant, for a bank, for the government etc. the stability factor is a real economic benefit you can calculate.

It's hard to tell if companies are bluffing or not, but in many cases they are not - and it illustrates really where the surpluses are and it's not with them.

There's a big Boeing 777 business case that's used in B-School for accounting, and it basically demonstrates that the project is kind of a loser for them, and they should not invest. But the government came along with incentives, making it worthwhile. It's not a paradox, it's just a lesson in who profits from what and how.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by amanaplanacanal on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:39PM (#18535148)
Err... I believe Ford didn't want the bailout money. Not sure why you tossed them in here.

I am totally in favor of letting bankruptcy courts do the job they are best at. All those assets don't just go away, they are put to better use.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by sonnyblarney on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:32PM (#18536530)
Ford is just an example of a 'big company' that might go bankrupt.

A bailout/subsidy for a company is different than a bankruptcy situation.

You can be assured that in a bankruptcy, the factory will probably close, and it's workers laid off. It doesn't matter i some assets are sold off, significant economic activity will dissapear in almost all cases. It's usually better for the economy for a company to survive than not.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by AngryData on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:44PM (#18531142)
I agree, likely we would have had a few smaller splinter companies from it but I don't see that as a bad thing in anyway except for those handful of people who were at the very top of the managerial/administrative pyramid.
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by walrus01 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:02PM (#18530728)
Yes, agreed. They should have gone chapter 7 and the canadian equivalent in bankruptcy law. Some foreign buyer would have bought up the assets worth buying, and made better cars. Maybe 1/3 to 1/2 of the workforce could have been re-hired, the government bailout money could be spent on retraining and supporting the remaining 2/3 to 1/2 of the workforce.
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by sonnyblarney on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:19PM (#18531045)
"They should have gone chapter 7 and the canadian equivalent in bankruptcy law. Some foreign buyer would have bought up the assets worth buying, and made better cars. "

It's very unlikely.

A) Plants are tooled for a specific car, often to platforms that are company specific.

B) There is a reason GM is shutting it down, and other companies are probably in the same set of circumstances.

C) Do you think company A wants to buy company B's powerful Union? Uhhh, no! It's not entirely rocket science to train people to make cars.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by amyjess on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:56AM (#18533718)
I'll point you to what happened to MG Rover. Company went bankrupt, a Chinese company bought the assets, and now they make and sell cars in the UK.
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by fredoralive on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:46AM (#18534612)
The current MG ceased assembly in the UK a couple of years ago. As it involved laying off 25 people, it seems like it was a rather token effort in he first place.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-birmingham-37449289

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by amyjess on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:50AM (#18534636)
Ack, I didn't know they closed the Longbridge plant. That's pretty sad.

Thanks for letting me know.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by sonnyblarney on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:29PM (#18536510)
They bought the car company, not a factory.

A car company, like 'Jaguar' (similar story) has assets.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by masonic on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:02PM (#18530725)
... so a Ford made in Mexico could better compete against a Hyundai made in Alabama.
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by thoughtexplorer on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:05PM (#18530736)
Too bad we didn't call their bluff, and especially that of the banks, and put the bailouts into infrastructure or new industry to replace those jobs and put us in a better position for the long term.
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by s4vi0r on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:01PM (#18530723)
And instead of taking the opportunity to nationalize them, our useless neoliberal leaders instead went "uhh okay lol heres some money pls don't do that thing we all know you'll do".
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by linksnapzz on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:07PM (#18530747)
Setting aside the complexities of two nations trying to nationalize the same company...the most recent example of an anglophone government taking over its carmakers (UK) isn’t exactly an encouraging precedent...
Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by notatoad on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:47AM (#18531379)
>diversify your industries and don't rely on one big player.

Isn't this what the subsidies are all about? If you want diverse industries to move to your region, you need some incentive to attract them.

Re:GM closing all operations in Oshawa, Ontario: sources by stickfigure on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:53PM (#18531173)
What does this have to do with subsidies? Did Canada pay GM to locate this plant? It doesn't seem like it, it dates back to the 80s.