News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by eldavido on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:51AM (#18511041)
I love how there are these two parallel threads going in HNville: (1) COLLEGE SUCKS BURN IT DOWN and (2) "I'd like to learn complex things like machine learning and math that take more than reading 5 blog posts to master, how do I do it"?

Sometimes this place just cracks me up.

I honestly think the answer is pretty simple: go to college. It doesn't have to be expensive. Take a community college course in calculus or undergraduate-level probability. Skip the gen eds and don't worry about the degree if you want to learn something narrow like this.

In any case, just find a mentor. On-the-job if you can, otherwise pay for a class.

What you shouldn't do is try to self-study by reading a book. You can perhaps do this but only if you're smarter than average and more motivated than most. Since you probably aren't, just take a class. Night school, maybe a MOOC. Preferably something heavy on analysis or proofs.

But you should do it with others. Math is a very social discipline, it's good to be able to discuss and have partners to work through things when you get stuck. And if you're like me, you WILL get stuck on things. This stuff is hard.

Another thought: this whole "college is great"/"college is terrible" dichotomy seems to occur people people don't think enough about quality. I think bad colleges are terrible and great ones are fantastic. I don't know any way I'd have learned all the complex topics in math, stats, probability, etc., I did without attending a big 10 engineering school (UIUC in my case)

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by MaxBarraclough on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:14PM (#18511176)
> I don't know any way I'd have learned all the complex topics in math, stats, probability, etc., I did without attending a big 10 engineering school

This is something the MOOC crowd often overlook. It's based on a misunderstanding of what a university gives you: university entry doesn't grant you access to some members-only club where they hide away the knowledge to keep it from the plebs (ignoring the open access movement, at least). Instead it grants you access to an environment in which you can learn effectively.

The idea that MOOCs will threaten the existence of universities is absurd. It's already possible to get access to the sum of human knowledge without being enrolled at a university. It's always been possible. They're called books.

But this stuff is hard, and attending a high-quality institution gives you a huge advantage in learning the material, compared to being self-taught. MOOCs may grant everyone access to lectures, but just as important is learning with high-quality peers. A MOOC is not the equivalent of being in a class with other smart and well-motivated students.

Again, it's always been possible to learn this stuff independently, but your odds of succeeding are far lower that way. It's great that we have lots of freely available learning material online, but I really don't see that MOOCs are going to turn the world on its head the way some people seem to think.

I'm ignoring accreditation here, of course. If you want to be a surgeon, you obviously do not have the option of teaching yourself, but in terms of learning maths/technology (and assuming knowledge - and not a certificate - is your goal), books have always been there. MOOCs are books++, not universities--. (With apologies to the pedants who might prefer the pre-positional operators.)

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by nvarsj on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:22PM (#18511566)
You ignore the possibility that MOOCs can have peer interaction. In OMSCS at least, there is loads of peer interaction (via slack, email, forums) - more in fact than I ever had at my undergrad (which was a top 10 engineering school).
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by MaxBarraclough on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:55AM (#18515907)
That's a fair point, but I put a lot of stock in physical interaction. I suspect that being physically part of a class greatly reduces odds of drop-out, and improves group study.

(Of course, this is an empirical claim, and I can't say I'm basing my opinion on a published study.)

More cynically: some undergrads struggle to get out of bed for their midday lectures. They would not thrive in a MOOC, where there is less immediate pressure to drive their studies. I can see it working far better in the context of a masters degree, as you allude to.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by nvarsj on Friday November 30, 2018 @04:22AM (#18567817)
Yeah, I can see your point. I also think the type of degree matters - you can be fairly autonomous in a C.S. masters.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by someguydave on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:42PM (#18535195)
What if most of the purpose of attending university was to signal to future employers that you are the kind of person who attends university?
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by elhudy on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:26PM (#18511589)
>What you shouldn't do is try to self-study by reading a book.

My experience has been that this is exactly how college math works; you pay for self-study. The professor reads directly out of a book (in poor English), or off of pre-made slides provided with the book, for 2-4 hours per week, and then you are left to do the problems from the book on your own time.

Class populations are so large that if everyone had asked clarifying questions, we wouldn't have completed the readings.

If your college experience was different I'm envious of that.

Edit: as a fun side-note, our calc professor was well known for taking up the entire class to draw out a single proof on the chalkboard. As the chalkboard got full, he would incidentally erase his previous writing with his giant belly as he putzed across the room.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by admax88q on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:33PM (#18511636)
There are other benefits beyond being able to ask questions.

Tests and deadlines provide motivation to do the actual work.

Having a curriculum means that the content is laid out in a logical order that the professor believes should be achievable.

There is a stupid amount of information out there. Breaking it down into a progression that students can follow in order to learn and understand it is incredibly important.

If you're motivated enough then sure maybe you can just buy and read the textbook, although sometimes professors deviate from that when it's wrong.

> Class populations are so large that if everyone had asked clarifying questions, we wouldn't have completed the readings.

Good thing not everybody asks, and those that do ask are generally asking questions shared by a good chunk of the class.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by ChuckMcM on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:43PM (#18511711)
> Tests and deadlines provide motivation to do the actual work.

This is so true in my experience. As a young man I could listen to the lecture and say "Yeah, yeah, I got this." and then try to work the homework problems and realize that no, I didn't really understand it. It is hard to force yourself to do the work if you don't have a negative externality for not doing it.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by greenyoda on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:16PM (#18511916)
> Having a curriculum means that the content is laid out in a logical order that the professor believes should be achievable.

> There is a stupid amount of information out there. Breaking it down into a progression that students can follow in order to learn and understand it is incredibly important.

You can get all this from a textbook. The curricula of most undergraduate math classes are based textbooks anyway. Many math textbooks even have a roadmap in the preface that tells you which chapters can be skipped for shorter versions of a course, which ones discuss advanced topics, etc.

> Tests and deadlines provide motivation to do the actual work.

The person who asked the original question already seems to have the motivation to learn math for a specific purpose. They're not a random undergrad who has to complete a math course just because it's a requirement for graduation and never expects to use the knowledge.

Also, the downside of studying based on arbitrary deadlines is that if it takes you even slightly longer than average to understand the material, you fall progressively further behind the class. If you learn at your own pace, you can study a topic until you really understand it.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by lvncelot on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:48PM (#18512103)
I'm from Germany and so the cost of being enrolled amounts to ~600 euros a year (and I get free public transport), so in cases like mine you'd be absolutely right - I'm mostly working freelance jobs and doing the odd course here when I feel like it, and it's pretty great. I get access to the curriculum, social contacts, a motivation kick and a general sense of immersion.

Though I don't think I'd be still doing that if I have to pay a substantial amount of money, so maybe other people just aren't as lucky? I don't know the exact situation in the US, apart from the ridiculous twenty-grand-a-semester colleges I know of, are there cheaper options?

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by elhudy on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:43PM (#18511714)
What you're saying is agreeable: taking a class provides a certain level of motivation that self-study doesn't provide, for most people. That doesn't conflict with the idea that typical college courses have little tangible value added. If you're ok paying a couple of grand for extra motivation, then I hope you truly have a good reason to be doing so, and that it pays off. This type of system doesn't really support people who just want to learn for the sake of it though.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by andrepd on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:48PM (#18511750)
The best class I've ever been to in 5 years of university was a pure maths class (topology and linear analysis) that I took as an elective (I think this is the word). If I'm ever in charge of teaching a class, of mathematics at least, this is how I will do it.

The format was like this: the classes were 2h long, and the professor would begin with an exposition: first a short recap of the previous class, then introducing the new material for the day, new concepts, definitions, the starting point for the day's class. This could take anywhere from 5 minutes to up to 30 or 40.

After that, we were handed a work-sheet. It contained the definitions/summary of the concepts that were just introduced, then a series of exercises. Now this is the core of it: the main part of the class was working through these in order. The exercises were structured so that the rest of the material was learned by doing, by working out through the exercises. They would e.g. ask to prove interesting consequences, or important theorems that followed from the definitions at the start. The professor would point out an exercise, read it aloud, comment on the "meaning" of the problem or what it's meant to demonstrate or similar remarks, then give us some time to figure it out. After a bit, he would ask someone that completed it to present his/her reasoning. Now note that this part required real effort from the part of the professor. I tremendously admire him for this because it required him to listen carefully and think through the proof presented by the student, something which is more difficult than, say, presenting and explaining his own proof on the blackboard. Anyway, he would listen to it, comment ("you could have simplified here", "you didn't consider this case there", etc.), perhaps ask some other students for alternative approaches, or maybe give an alternative approach himself if necessary. By doing this we would learn the rest of the material by working it out from those principles; in a way in a sort of "narrative" that had a thematic "chapter" in each class and an overarching "story" for the whole class.

In summary, only about 10 minutes at the start would be real exposition. This usually amounted to stating definitions or axioms to work with for the rest of the class. The rest of the material -- any theorems, conclusions, etc. -- were worked out.

I have some difficulty concentrating even on 1h or 1h30 lectures. These were 2h and I would be effortlessly engaged for the whole duration. It kind of pains me that maybe the best class I've taken in university wasn't even one in my degree :^)

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by chapium on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:02PM (#18511825)
Smaller colleges are not like this.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by crawfordcomeaux on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:06PM (#18511123)
Just because you choose to believe you need to be fed your information doesn't mean others do. I've tutored people carrying the thoughts you're expressing ("I need someone to teach me this because I'm not smart enough to learn it on my own"). The quickest way to success with them was shattering that myth. I did it by talking to them about their feelings/beliefs and helping them figure out practices for changing their minds about themselves. Here's a great paper called The Debugging Mindset on cultivating a growth oriented perspective an why it's important: https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=3068754

I hope you can develop a more empowered perspective of yourself and others though reading it.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by eldavido on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:14PM (#18511174)
It's not about being "fed information". It's the reality that being around a motivated group of peers confers real advantage.

I look at the history of art (e.g. Impressionists), YC, winning athletics programs, Silicon Valley, or just about any well-regarded academic department as evidence. These places don't do well just because they select the best, they also MAKE the best by creating an environment that fosters it.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by mindcrime on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:41PM (#18512069)
Maybe your reality. Anecdotally, my peers never did anything of note to help me learn anything in any math classes.

These days I am working on relearning the math I've forgotten, and going beyond where I stopped in college. I have found that a combination of books, YouTube videos of lectures, Kahn Academy, Math Overflow / math.se, and subreddits like /r/learnmath, etc. have been sufficient.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by crawfordcomeaux on Thursday November 22, 2018 @05:05PM (#18512866)
"The best" is purely subjective.

I look at indigenous cultures who were able to resolve conflicts and share resources without hierarchical governments. They developed approaches to doing things western culture is only now relearning.

Also, your "best people" developed systems to addict us with little concern for their systemic impacts. If that's your version of best, I want better.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by eldavido on Thursday November 22, 2018 @06:31PM (#18513278)
> "The best" is purely subjective

Bullshit.

Find me one "indigenous culture" as advanced as a modern developed western country (or China) and I'll believe you. I don't care whether your metric is life expectancy, scientific progress, quantity and quality of art produced, fairness of our legal system, political/religious freedom, lack of food scarcity, or corruption. You pick.

We in the West have it as good as anyone ever did in the history of the world. Tell me one thing "western culture is only new relearning", I'd be interested to hear?

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by crawfordcomeaux on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:24PM (#18514338)
We don't have a fair legal system, so I'd say that's a place where we could learn from them. Also, being connected to the land. Consent practices, as well. How to learn principles of life from observing nature.

Oh, and we totally have food scarcity, too.

There's stuff there to learn, if you're willing to accept the idea that perhaps your culture has room to grow.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by faceplanted on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:55AM (#18511060)
OP says in the comment that he _went_ to university and didn't pick it up.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by HiroshiSan on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:53PM (#18511378)
There's not enough information in that comment. What kind of Math courses did he take? Did he ever take an intro to proofs course? Did any of his Math courses emphasize proofs?

All the proof heavy courses I've taken, whenever new notation was introduced the professor would explain how to interpret it. And if they didn't someone would raise their hand and ask what it meant. Which brings me to another point, was OP an active learner? Did he ask questions when he didn't understand?

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by metalsteady on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:56PM (#18511790)
There's no reason to go to college for these so called lower div courses. They are often taught by TAs. The latter are not synonymous with great teaching. It's the 21st century, we have a wealth of textbooks now that are often better than all TAs and profs put together. These days one can easily put aside 1600 page doorstops (such Calc books often teach applied algorithms that were last relevant in 19th century) and opt for much more nimble, well-designed and actually relevant/rigorous books like those of Jay Cummings or Lara Alcock or Richard Hammack or the Dos Reis or Gary Chartrand or ...
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by natalyarostova on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:05PM (#18511117)
Fwiw I've self taught myself multivar calc and (so far) some phd stats. It's not glamorous though. It's thousands of hours working through textbooks, and requires some really intense levels of motivation.

Also I wish I studied it in college, but didn't want to go back.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by geitir on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:38PM (#18512040)
This is completely wrong. I am a recent graduate who is in stem and took up to calc 3. It is true you do learn notation but only what is necessary for the concepts and math of the calculus classes. I've run into the same problem as the op and most of the notation that acts as a barrier isn't matrix operators or integrals but rather symbols used in proof or niche cases that might be prevalent in a specific field but not in general University math courses.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by cuspycode on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:40PM (#18512057)
> What you shouldn't do is try to self-study by reading a book.

I say do try self-study first and see if it works. You have absolutely nothing to lose by trying. It doesn't work for everyone, but you will quickly figure out if it works for you. Some people can absorb knowledge from books much more easily than from oral instruction, and for others it's the other way around.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by UncleEntity on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:26PM (#18511971)
I went to college and took a sum total of two math classes but have learned enough to reason out the many papers that don't have (pseudo) code but 'complex mathematical notation' -- which seems like almost all of them.

https://github.com/Jam3/math-as-code was helpful...

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by akhilcacharya on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:40PM (#18512063)
>I don't know any way I'd have learned all the complex topics in math, stats, probability, etc., I did without attending a big 10 engineering school (UIUC in my case)

I feel so behind because I absolutely did not.

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by dang on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:44PM (#18512090)
The paradox disappears when you stop anthropomorphizing HN and remember that a community of millions of people has a lot of different subgroups.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by eldavido on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:57PM (#18512503)
That is true. But you also have to acknowledge that this community isn't in any sense, "normal" (representative, average, etc)

Most days I appreciate its uniqueness, but I find myself rolling my eyes at least once/week at some of the comments here.

Here are some of what I'd call the "HN tropes":

"Oh that hard thing? It's not that hard. I have never worked on that problem before, but can surely replicate that entire system in a week, because everyone working on it is an idiot and doesn't know what they're doing."

"That traditional human behavior (e.g. marriage, buying a house, going to college)? I can squeeze 5% more efficiency out of life by completely ignoring the reality of human behavior, because my superhuman, almost robotic levels of conscientiousness and diligence that make it a horrible idea for 99% of the population, somehow don't apply to me. I beat the averages in everything I do." (I see that a bit in this thread. See also: playing games with credit card balance transfers, renting vs. buying "because I'll save the difference", trading options and thinking you won't fall into well-known behavioral traps)

"Hard problem from another discipline (finance, accounting, medical science)? I can reinvent a clever algorithm ten times smarter than that, despite my complete lack of domain knowledge. No problem."

"Incumbents are stupid. Anyone can beat them if they're clever."

"I don't need to read history. Humans are irrelevant, if we just apply the right combination of game theory, economics, and some clever code, we can fix any problem. Politics and governance are stupid, avoidable problems if we just used the right system." (I see this a lot in Bitcoin discussions)

I see these with alarming frequency here. You can certainly say I'm painting with too broad a brush but I've been here since 2009 and it comes up over and over. More than anything, I just laugh at it these days (not get mad).

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by tomhoward on Thursday November 22, 2018 @04:32PM (#18512710)
For a site that attracts millions of visits and tens of thousands of comments a month, just once/week seems pretty good!

Seriously: do you routinely see eye-rolling comments that don’t get downvoted or rebutted? I don’t. That’s what I like/appreciate about this place; yes you’ll get the tropes you mention, but you’ll invariably get an articulate response that points out the weakness or conceit.

[dead]
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by ukulele on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:16PM (#18511914)
This would be more convincing without the first sentence.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by eldavido on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:14PM (#18511896)
Happy Thanksgiving to you, too.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by stillbourne on Thursday November 22, 2018 @04:03PM (#18512547)
As a high school dropout that is self educated, I don't appreciate people dogging those who take the effort to forge their own path. You can learn complex topics outside a formal education system and your comment offered no specific assistance. So in the spirit of the holiday, thanks for nothing.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by eldavido on Thursday November 22, 2018 @05:59PM (#18513108)
So here's the thing: apart from you and maybe a few friends, nobody really cares about your "forging your own path". It may give your life meaning, which is important. But in any sort of professional / market context, people just emphatically. Do. Not. Care.

Speaking from experience, I have often taken the hard path. I've always regretted it and often, if I'm being honest, it's out of a misguided sense of stubbornness.

That's why I recommend trying college, to the OP. Maybe he can learn advanced mathematics by himself, in isolation. But that isn't the maximum-likelihood path. And when you're doing something hard, I've learned it pays to do everything you can to stack the deck in your favor.

I think the main thing is to realize you only live one. I have friends who are more successful than me in every way. One earns literally 10x what I do, others work at more famous companies, still others receive absurd amounts of money from their parents for sitting on their ass. You can't choose your hand in life, but you can choose how you play it. So it's really up to you, whether you want to play the game on easy mode, or hard mode. Or whether you want to feel sorry for yourself or just make something of the hand you're dealt, though it may not be "fair".

Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by stillbourne on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:15PM (#18513906)
I have no idea what point you are trying to make, my point is simple, a poorly taught college course is worse for comprehension than reading the source material and coming to your own understanding. As a Sr. Dev, I have mentored many people that are still in college. I have seen the struggle that they have endured in classes such as Discrete Math. I have held their hands through poorly constructed math courses that have bad or misleading information, and not from the same school. Maybe you were privileged enough to go to a good school where they had their shit together but not all colleges are made equal. I learned most of what I know from reading the material myself. I'm not bragging. This is not coming from a position of, look at me, I am so fucking cool because I did it on my own. No, this is a statement that not all educational systems are built the same, that there are faults in our general education system and some people are better off picking it up and running with it, forging their own path, than to have is spoon fed to them by an idiot that doesn't know what he is talking about or by a broken online courseware spewing bad information. So spare me the bullshit of feeling sorry for yourself, or about life not dealing you the fair hand. Because I don't believe that for a fucking moment.
Re:Ask HN: How can I learn to read mathematical notation? by lucb1e on Thursday November 22, 2018 @05:16PM (#18512927)
Not sure this has anything to do with American holidays or traditions or whatever Thanksgiving is. It's not a thing here and idk if it's a thing in the country GP comes from. I wouldn't have known it was this month if you hadn't mentioned it.