News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by maxxxxx on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @05:25PM (#18506602)
I remember after the 2008 crisis I knew people who defaulted on a $300000 mortgage. The house sold for $130000 at an auction. Back then I wondered if they could have bought the house back.This would have been a pretty sweet deal.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by ChuckMcM on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @07:06PM (#18507048)
In Las Vegas at that time there was a law on the books that specifically forbade the person on the note, or anyone related to that person, to buy the note in a short sale or at auction. It was written to prevent scams where people could pump up their house value and get refinanced, default, and then buy the house back at a discount and pocket the difference.

It was amended in 2016 I believe to allow some purchases if they met specific criteria.

The "usual" way to getting around these things has been to create a company and have the company buy it. Companies are nominally 'new' people and don't have family or relatives.

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by uiri on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @10:25PM (#18507680)
There are typically laws that deem a company to be related to a person if that person and their (natural) relatives own some threshold percentage of that company.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by kmonsen on Thursday November 22, 2018 @06:52AM (#18509443)
I don't see how you call this a scam. The bank should do due diligence before handing out the loan. It's not like the bank is forced to hand out money for bad deals.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by ChuckMcM on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:31PM (#18511262)
I don't disagree, it is always a question of degree. One party sees a 'scam', the other a failure of the first party to do more diligence. Some see separating poorly informed people from their money as a business, other see it as an injustice that needs to be corrected.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by Dylan16807 on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:52AM (#18515481)
The scam part is taking out a loan with the intent of not repaying it.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by brian-armstrong on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @07:38PM (#18507183)
It sounds like companies might get very lonely at Christmas.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by dmurray on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @05:40PM (#18506681)
If this was in the US then almost certainly yes, if they had 130k cash or someone willing to lend it to them despite their recent default. You can generally "mail the keys to the bank" and have no further liability. In other jurisdictions, you might have to declare bankruptcy if you default on your mortgage.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by will_brown on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @06:36PM (#18506919)
>You can generally "mail the keys to the bank" and have no further liability.

No. There is Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure, which sounds like what you are talking about, but that is not a unilateral option you exercise by mailing keys...you need the banks permission, which they usually don’t give, especially when the property is underwater.

If people could unilaterally turn in keys and escape the debt you can be sure the banks would have gone under during the Great Recession. As it was the Federal Bailout essentially covered the legal fees for banks to foreclose on these toxic assets and recover what they could.

Still even then (like parents hypothetical) if a bank foreclosed and $300k was owed and they sold the property for $130k the next step was a separate filing for deficiency judgement (the difference or $170k in this case).

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by alasdair_ on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @07:20PM (#18507109)
>No. There is Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure, which sounds like what you are talking about, but that is not a unilateral option you exercise by mailing keys...you need the banks permission, which they usually don’t give, especially when the property is underwater.

Like many other things, it depends on the state.

In Washington, for example, the lender can use a simplified process (that gets used over 99% of the time) for a foreclosure that makes it non-recourse.

The other option is to go to court, something that banks will only bother doing if they are fairly certain you have especially large assets that they can seize to make it worthwhile.

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by will_brown on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @07:50PM (#18507223)
>In Washington, for example, the lender can use a simplified process (that gets used over 99% of the time) for a foreclosure that makes it non-recourse.

Yes it’s the difference between judicial and nonjudicial foreclosure.

But reworded: In Washington 100% of Banks can go for deficiency judgements after judicial foreclosure, but the banks have so much data they make the strategic choice of waiving that right in 99% of cases by going the nonjudicial route and foregoing the potential of the deficiency judgement. Further, in 1% of cases the bank has data that suggests the borrower has assets, income or even potential future income/assets that make the added time/cost of judicial foreclosure worthwhile.

In general it makes sense a defiency judgement isn’t worth the paper it’s written on...or he borrower wouldn’t have been foreclosed but in that 1% of (Washington cases) banks see people with income/assets who can pay trying to get out from an underwater property.

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by dmurray on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @06:41PM (#18506935)
I am not a lawyer. I was going to reply to rhizome (sibling post of yours) saying this really differs from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, but in my understanding, in most US jurisdictions the lender has no recourse (either none at all, legally speaking, or tends to get nowhere in practice). Is my understanding really untrue and the banks can go after your other assets in all US states?

Edit: A quick google told me that there are 12 "non-recourse states" for "most residential mortgages": Alaska, Arizona, California, Iowa, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, North Carolina, North Dakota, Oregon, Washington and Wisconsin. https://www.arklawgroup.com/blog/how-do-i-know-whether-my-mo...

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by will_brown on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @07:42PM (#18507197)
Foreclosure procedures do depend a little on jurisdiction (ie judicial vs nonjudicial foreclosure states or both), but even within those non-recourse states you link to, lenders can in fact come for deficiency judgements between the balance of the loan and the fair market value of the property.

You can find many articles about California, for example, where they will say someththing like “in California, in most foreclosures banks can’t go after borrowers for deficiency judgement”, but it’s misleading. California has both judicial and nonjudicial foreclosure, and judicial foreclosures allow deficiency judgments and nonjudicial foreclosure generally don’t. So why don’t all lenders go for the judicial foreclosure and for the deficiency judgement? Time and Money! It simply takes longer and costs more to go the judicial route and why do that if you ultimately can’t collect from the borrower?

The thing is the banks/borrowers have so much data, their automated systems are pretty good at knowing if they will likely be able to collect enough to cover the extra cost of the judicial foreclosure in which case they go that route and then for the deficiency judgement. Once they have that they can garnish wages, attach accounts, etc...

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @09:22PM (#18507517)
> You can find many articles about California, for example, where they will say someththing like “in California, in most foreclosures banks can’t go after borrowers for deficiency judgement”, but it’s misleading. California has both judicial and nonjudicial foreclosure, and judicial foreclosures allow deficiency judgments and nonjudicial foreclosure generally don’t.

This is more misleading than what it “corrects”, which is actually entirely correct for the case usually of interest (and which the articles are almost always specifically addressing), owner-occupied residential properties. Its true that California allows deficiency judgements for judicial foreclosures except as barred by the State anti-deficiency statute. But that statute prohibits all deficiency judgements for purchase-money or refinance loans for residential property with up to four units when the owner/borrower resides on the property (and, unlike most anti-deficiency statutes, covers second and subsequent mortgages for that purpose, not just first mortgages.)

https://www.weltman.com/?t=40&an=40108&format=xml&p=7735

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by will_brown on Thursday November 22, 2018 @12:33AM (#18508079)
In light of the question I was answering:

>Is my understanding really untrue and the banks can go after your other assets in all US states?

My response is not misleading by any means.

Especially when that question came as a direct response to the same person who originally broadly stated you can just mail your house keys to the bank and walk away.

My point is simple and fairly obvious...don’t mail your keys to the bank and think you can walk away, even if you are in a non recourse state.

I used California as a perfect example of a non recourse State that has both judicial/nonjudicial foreclosures and in judicial foreclosures allows...recourse (deficiency judgments).

Yes you included a few rules outlining where deficiencies would not be available, but the fact defiency judgments are available at all - especially in California, which is ultra stringent even amoung non recourse states - is the much bigger point being discussed.

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by dragonwriter on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:36AM (#18508294)
> My point is simple and fairly obvious...don’t mail your keys to the bank and think you can walk away, even if you are in a non recourse state.

Yeah, that's generally a fair point and there are lots of good examples you could have pointed to; California, however, isn't one of them.

> Yes you included a few rules outlining where deficiencies would not be available

A few rules, which happen to encompass the entire category usually discussed with the “mail your keys” thing: any single-family house you own, with one or more purchase or refinance mortgages, and live in.

(And, well, more than that category usually at issue, because it also includes small multifamily units with the same other conditions.)

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by will_brown on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:36AM (#18510950)
>A few rules, which happen to encompass the entire category usually discussed with the “mail your keys” thing

No it doesn’t encompass “the entire category”. Even in California deed in lieu of foreclosure cases (eg the bank agrees you can mail your keys in) banks can and do obtain defiency judgments in 5% of such cases.

It reminds me of student loans, where lawyers and layman constantly say student loans are not dischargeable in bankruptcy. But they are. Student loans have a higher standard to discharge than most other debts. I guess people can say it’s misleading to say student loans are discharable -but they are- even if it’s a low percentage. The important part of the discussion is again it’s possible.

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by dragonwriter on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:20PM (#18511552)
> No it doesn’t encompass “the entire category”. Even in California deed in lieu of foreclosure cases (eg the bank agrees you can mail your keys in) banks can and do obtain defiency judgments in 5% of such cases

A deed-in-lieu is an agreement—a contract supplementing the mortgage contract and agreeing it's terms—not a foreclosure, and whether or not a deficiency judgement is available is determined beitherms of the agreement (or the mortgage itself), not the foreclosure rules.

OTOH, the prohibition on foreclosure deficiencies on the whole class of mortgages at issue in California gives borrowers considerable leverage on getting a deed-in-lieu without deficiency permitted (or a short-sale without that), since in a foreclosure the bank won't get a deficiency and will bear additional costs that they don't have with the deed-in-lieu. But, yes, if you agree to give the bank privileges they wouldn't have in foreclosure because you are desperate to avoid foreclosure, you will need to fulfill that agreement.

Also, note that stats that aren't extremely new can be misleading, because the extension of the anti-deficiency statute to refinance mortgages as well as purchase money mortgages only happened in 2012, and cases take time to make it through the legal system. This affects both actual foreclosures and deeds-in-lieu, because without the foreclosure protection, the leverage for deed-in-lieu agreements wasn't there, either.

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by will_brown on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:10PM (#18511873)
>A deed-in-lieu is an agreement—a contract supplementing the mortgage contract and agreeing it's terms—not a foreclosure...

A deed in lieu can occur without a foreclosure taking place, but it can also occur during the foreclosure proceeding (ie it’s a type of settlement within the active foreclosure case). But it’s not like the defiency judgment is memorialized in these agreements, the 5% I cite are statistics from the courts, this the 5% are court ordered defiency judgments...not part of the original settlement (deed in lieu).

You are not wrong a savvy borrower who may have potential liability for a defiency can include in the deed in lieu a waiver of the lenders right to pursue the diffidence, if any. But lenders don’t need to agree, and won’t if they believe they could collect. But again these deeds in lieu are negotiated instruments and not triggered by mailing keys to the bank.

>Also, note that stats that aren't extremely new can be misleading, because the extension of the anti-deficiency statute to refinance mortgages as well as purchase money mortgages only happened in 2012

Agreed, and I was actually going to bring this up before, because despite the additional protections against defiency judgments in the Code for 2nd mortgages/HELOCS courts in California are still upholding the lenders right to get a defiency after judicial foreclosure cases where the homeowner took cash out from refinancing 2nd mortgage/HELOC (and to pedantic - still subject to those limitations you added). Eventually this will be clarified through appeals and those protections will either be upheld or those laws won’t have as much teeth as a blanket protection for all such class of notes. I believe the 5% stats are for 2007-2016 for deed in lieu.

All this is so far beyond the pale of the actual discussion. And I think for the benefit of non lawyers, should be left to:

California is a non recourse state. Even amoung non recourse states California is known for having very protective laws for the borrower. Yet, even being a non recourse state and having some of the best protections for borrowers, mailing your keys/deed in lieu (whether during actictive foreclosure litigation or before the filing of any cases) carries risks of a deficiency. Nevertheless the idea of mailing keys wasn’t specific to California, and California was only used to highlight the possibility of a deficiency judgment in non recourse state. More generally the majority of states (38) are recourse states where the banks can come after you for the defiency as a general rule and amoung the 12 non recourse states, defiency judgments are allowed in at least some cases.

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by masonic on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:49AM (#18508743)
Any "forgiven" principal also becones taxable as regular income that year (in the USA).
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by joecool1029 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:59AM (#18508783)
It would seem that is not always the case: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/home-foreclosure-and-debt-cance...
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by masonic on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:20AM (#18515335)
That expired in 2016.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @07:25PM (#18507123)
> If this was in the US then almost certainly yes, if they had 130k cash or someone willing to lend it to them despite their recent default. You can generally "mail the keys to the bank" and have no further liability.

No, only 15 states generally prohibit mortgage deficiency judgements (and those prohibitions mostly apply only to first mortgages, and some are limited even there), in the rest the creditor can come after you for the unrecovered balance after a foreclosure sale.

https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/anti-deficien...

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by rhizome on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @06:08PM (#18506811)
Is jinglemail uncontestable if the bank finds out the borrower has money to pay?
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by Something1234 on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @06:30PM (#18506889)
jinglemail is a very interesting term. Where did you come across that?
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by techsupporter on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @07:35PM (#18507170)
I've heard it for a long time. It refers to the sound that keys make and that you're "mailing the keys" (sometimes literally) to the bank.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by rhizome on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @07:37PM (#18507178)
I forget, some blog during the 2008 US real estate shitshow.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by paxys on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @05:59PM (#18506768)
If they had $130000 cash the house wouldn't be under in the first place though.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by lozaning on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @06:32PM (#18506904)
I thought your house being under is only defined by you owing more than it's worth, not by your ability to pay the mortgage or not.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by chiph on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @07:12PM (#18507081)
Technically yes. But if you are underwater far enough, the bank could lose confidence in your willingness to repay the loan and could demand immediate repayment. So if your house is worth $15k less than the outstanding balance and you've got a history of paying on time, they're probably going to let things ride. But if your house is worth $50k less than the balance and they think you might walk away from the debt, they might demand you pay in full, immediately.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by URSpider94 on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @11:00PM (#18507780)
In most cases, a mortgage lender can’t ask for accelerated repayment no matter how far underwater you are, unless you fall behind on payments or otherwise violate the terms of your loan. If you’re making monthly payments, they can’t ask for a balloon repayment.

Additionally, a borrower who is paying on an underwater mortgage is much better than a foreclosure where the bank gets an asset worth less than you owe. Every month that you make a payment improves the bank’s position, since your payment is going to reduce the deficit between loan amount and home value.

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by jldugger on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @11:43PM (#18507911)
> But if your house is worth $50k less than the balance and they think you might walk away from the debt, they might demand you pay in full, immediately.

Sorry, US banks can't issue margin calls on conforming home loans.

Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by joeriel on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @06:44PM (#18506950)
That is absolutely not true. Being underwater is having a Loan to Value ratio > 100%.
Re:I Can Be the Bank: Individual Investors Buy Busted Mortgages by maxxxxx on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @06:16PM (#18506836)
In theory I could have done it for them or some other front. It feels scammy but I am just curious.