[edit] Thanks, that helps, but I still don't understand what you think is being correctly or incorrectly incentivized here.
When a majority of a countries people are not paying for the country or (worse) profiting off the government, then they have no incentive to keep government spending under control. This leads to the increase of tax money coming from fewer and fewer citizens until the whole thing collapses. Paying for something means that you pay more attention and be more critical of failures.
Of course people have little incentive to find out which policies will bring actual good results as opposed to those which superficially seem nice. Luckily politicians who hope to be reelected can't do anything that turns out to be too stupid in practice... some fraction of the time. And so we sort of muddle our way through things.
So while your post makes a lot of sense on an individual basis, it seems that self-interested groups are almost certainly a factor in the way people vote. It would be pretty easy to miss this looking at things like income or age; I'd be more interested in seeing studies based on union affiliation or some other sentient grouping (as opposed to a non-sentient group like "people over 60").
1) The history of the 2000 election actually makes a serious point about polling and the failure of a news organization (Fox) to realized polls hadn't actually closed in the panhandle of Florida (Central Time). That area of Florida is heavily Republican and lower voter turn out because of the pre-announced winner (Gore). A few more Democrats voting or a non-preannouncement could have prevented one of the stupidest episodes in US voting history. Vote like you've heard nothing.
If that was the case, then you would expect to see most of the rich as republicans, but in actuality a lot are democrats. Taxes are not the most important issue for a lot of people in the upper class.
Lets forget the social issues which can be drivers of that, and focus strictly on the numbers.
A rational person wants to maximize the amount of money they have in their pocket at the end of the day. If government policy had no influence on the economy then obviously the best way to do this is through lower taxes.
But what if government policy does have an influence on the economy? I would rather pay 35% taxes on $100,000 than 30% taxes on $80,000.
This effect gets magnified at the top, especially when bonuses are in play.
Believe it or not, history has shown the economy to be better under democrats than republicans in the post-war period, and this will only become further exacerbated because this data doesn't include what has happened in the last 2 years.
It's important to note this doesn't take into account national, state, and local taxes that everyone pays regardless of income including sales, gas, and property taxes, tariffs, filing fees, tolls, etc. The whole "who pays federal income tax" argument is somewhat of a red herring.
http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2009/02/news-flash-economists...
They call this tax Social Security but it is just a tax like any other.
SSI is collected like a tax, but, unlike almost every other tax, the money collected is mostly returned to the payer. (Folks who didn't pay much get much better return than folks who paid a lot.)
http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/2010-04-16-e...
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Nearly-half-of-US-households-a...
About 47 percent will pay no federal income taxes at all for 2009. Either their incomes were too low, or they qualified for enough credits, deductions and exemptions to eliminate their liability. That's according to projections by the Tax Policy Center, a Washington research organization.
Also, the irs.gov site has tons of data with various breakdowns.
http://www.heritage.org/budgetchartbook/top10-percent-income...
People become eligible for more federal benefits as they earn less so it may net out to less than 0%, but I don't have a citation for that.
Another way to escape federal tax liability (up to ~$90,000 income) is to live outside the US 11 months / year
I don't get why more Americans aren't enraged about the United States' treatment of emigrants. For citizens of most other countries, if you don't live there and you don't make money there, you don't pay taxes there.
I say this as someone about to start a job in Europe myself; it's somewhat of a sore point with many people ("America not good enough for you?"). The current economy being bad is really the only thing that makes it relatively easy to smooth over, because I can fall back on, "well nobody in the U.S. was hiring in my area and this opportunity in Europe came up", and people sorta understand because everyone's willing to believe that the U.S. job market is bad right now.
Mostly I can't think of the constituency that would support lowering taxes on emigrants. Republicans are usually the enthusiastic tax-cutters, but emigrants are even less popular among Republicans than among Democrats, partly due to heartland-patriotism type of culture, and partly because the expat vote is skewed Democratic.
Unfortunately I think they are in fact extremely adept at understanding incentive. Is it possible that you haven't carefully considered which incentives are driving their behaviour :).
Let's put aside the single-parent part. Last year I made about $25,000.
I enjoyed the protection of the US military, was treated at hospitals using techniques developed with federal funding, and benefited from the federal regulation of interstate commerce.
I also had a nice room in a shared house in Santa Barbara, CA. I had a car, ate healthy food, went out to bars, and lounged on the beach.
Why shouldn't I have had to pay taxes?
Well, we were talking about federal taxes. That's why I listed services of the federal government. Property and sales tax are state. Social security and gas axes are supposed to be a closed systems. None of those pay for the military, interstate commerce regulation, or medical research.
But the important thing is that I wasn't claiming I didn't pay taxes. (I did, although not much.) I was challenging the notion that I shouldn't be paying taxes just because I make less thank $30k.
You don't see a problem with that person voting to increase the amount of free-to-them stuff?
If enough stuff is free-to-me, I'm not going to do anything that other people will pay me to do.
How about you?
Don't forget we live in a representative democracy.
I'd expect half of US households to have an effect on the national agenda.
> Don't forget we live in a representative democracy.
So? The question is whether something is a good idea, not whether it can get popular support.
Consider Justin Bieber.
A good example of an incentive problem that's recently unfolded: now nearly 50% of US households have no federal income tax liability.
Edit: It's nearly 50%. It was 38% in 2007, 47% in 2009. Also, 40% of households "make a profit from the federal income tax system, meaning they get more money in tax credits than they would otherwise owe in taxes".
http://www.usatoday.com/money/perfi/taxes/2010-04-07-income-...