Re:How Do You Stop Sea Captains From Killing Their Passengers?
by anamax on Friday October 29, 2010 @04:29PM
(#1848890)
> They call this tax Social Security but it is just a tax like any other.
SSI is collected like a tax, but, unlike almost every other tax, the money collected is mostly returned to the payer. (Folks who didn't pay much get much better return than folks who paid a lot.)
Re:How Do You Stop Sea Captains From Killing Their Passengers?
by _delirium on Friday October 29, 2010 @04:43PM
(#1848946)
This will only be true if, as seems increasingly unlikely, the social-security surpluses accumulated over the past few decades are actually used to fund social security (the mythical "lockbox"). My bet is on the money never being returned to the social-security system. In that case, the surplus portion of the payroll taxes from the past few decades should be historically reclassified as (regressive) general income taxes.
Re:How Do You Stop Sea Captains From Killing Their Passengers?
by krschultz on Friday October 29, 2010 @04:53PM
(#1848986)
But it is also the only regressive tax we have, as all income over a certain amount is untaxed. So it ends up being a really complicated curve of who gets what return on their money, so the super rich and the super poor get the best deal, while the middle class gets hosed.
They call this tax Social Security but it is just a tax like any other.