It was hammering my server, so I changed up the script to return random inflammatory and/or inappropriate images if the referer was this forum site.
I was using the source IP as the rand() seed, so everyone on the forum had a different view of the images, but consistent in that it remained constant for any single user.
The resulting chaos and infighting was pretty funny until they figured it out.
Reminds me of the endless fun with [you] tag on phpBB forums. That particular tag's function was to be replaced during rendering of a forum post with the username of the user viewing it. AFAIR it was retained in tag form in quotes, too. You'd post something like, "I think [you] is dumb in believing $something", and watch the hilarity ensue.
Picture this:
You've got a story which is seemingly very controversial, and will rile up one side of the political spectrum.
However, this story is only shown for say, 10-20% of your readers/viewers, and the rest get an innoculous story, or one that says the complete opposite.
Now the ones affected by it will post it on social media sites and forums, saying that this is proof of how 'evil' the other side is.
But the others there can't see the same story, and will think said users are trolling them. After seeing them keep posting comments about how some minority group is evil with links to innocent stories about kittens and puppies, said users get banned.
This causes said users to think they're being targeted by the other side, and then every story they see on the site is designed to build off that. Make the forum/social media/news site owners out to be illuminati pawns or what not and their banning policies a way to stifle dissent.
Voila, the site has now basically weaponised A/B testing, and created a localised echo chamber to gaslight its readers into more and more extreme mindsets.
That's basically the nightmare scenario. Imagine an enemy state like Russia or China using it against the alt-right/antifa/whatever. Or activists using it to recruit followers.
Worse still, imagine it with compromised browser extensions as well. Imagine if a foreign government managed to do this in a way that could let them edit the text on fact checking sites like Snopes or major media outlets like the BBC or CNN or what not. Now that could have some worrying consequences.
Still, it wouldn't be impossible to fix/detect. Set up sites like Reddit/Hacker News to automatically archive pages linked to, and send users to the archive rather than the original unless they choose to click through. Avoid using any browser extensions at all, with hosts file blocking for things like ads rather than Adblock/uBlock/whatever. Ask others to double check what every page you see says to make sure it hasn't been compromised/doesn't show different things.
Do that and you can at least minimise this style of dissent sowing.
That's not the “next step”, it's an established practice. Notably, the recent Russian propaganda effort directed at destabilizing the US via false flag social media accounts and other channels was noted for doing exactly this. (They didn't invent the general concepts either, it's much older.)
The actual mechanism in your example would be a bit novel, but it's also fairly easily accidentally penetrated, because real humans aren't 1:1 to online personalities.
Cambridge Analytica used personal profiles scraped from FB and (allegedly) from insurance company customer details to run ads that were precisely tailored - almost down to specific users.
It only took a small swing to push the vote over the line.
With modern elections results often come down to a tiny tipping point.
In the UK 2017 election, tipping the right 400 voters one way or another changes the makeup of government from a DUP backed coalition to a Tory majority[0]. Tipping the other way, and denying a DUP/Conservative coalition, would have taken the right 750 to flip.
Turnout was 32.2 million, and the entire election came down to 1200 voters, 1 in 27,000.
In 2016 if Clinton had flipped about 60,000 votes (the right ones), or about 1 in 2,300, she'd be president.
By comparrison, brexit required a massive swing - 1 in 26 voters.
[0] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/06/12/theresa-may-just...
Further more, why can't it be both, because of AND in spite of those ads? Successful propaganda often uses false images from another perspective to generate scorn, e.g. obviously idiotic comments from tumblr SJWs (r/tumblrinaction, for example) who are likely sockpuppets.
Regardless, marketing is about numbers on the whole, not whether Bob or Sheela specifically voted -- and on the whole it worked for Brexit.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Identifying_reliable...
> BuzzFeed may use A/B testing for new articles, which may cause article content to change
This is actually one of the reasons that make things like git repos (given a certain commit hash), torrents, and ipfs (except IPNS/MFS) extremely attractive - nobody will be able to silently change things afterwards.
The game play is different depending on the machine it's being played on. Some folks get stuck on an unwinnable screen right away, some later, some play to the end, etc. Also, the screen/level names vary.
The packet flow ASICs and fabric on an example router like an MX960 or an ASR9006 are quite separated from the control plane routing engine. Just passing packets with the "zero day" through the router wouldn't do it, somebody would have to compromise the engineering/admin interface to the routing engine(s). If you have the equivalent of root, configure or enable on a Cisco IOS-XR or modern JunOS system you could run a script to brick it anyways, by overwriting the boot OS image and then reloading the router.
I personally would be much more worried about a "brick yourself" magic packet that is hidden, hardcoded into the ASICs of Huawei or ZTE routers sold into the networks of major carriers in NATO countries.
But if I was the well resourced attacker I would use multiple teams and target a diverse variety of important services and infrastructure and coordinate an phased long term(weeks) attack. I would not cripple the internet as a whole,especially social media. In battle,hiding your location and intent is crucial to victory.
Social media would play a critical role in sowing confusion amidst the chaos. Isolate part of the country and spread a message that some internal political group (antifa or alt-right for example) launched a physical WMD attack,use access to fortune 500 company networks to send emails and other communication indicating internal collapse of the companies,one corp is going bankrupt,another has been lying about profits is under SEC investigation. Chaos after chaos. The goal of a "cyber 9/11" would not be to cripple the internet but (imho)rather to exploit it to acheive three independent goals:
1) Long term (multi?)National and Economical instability and possibly collapse.
2) Make the internet as it stands today a mortal threat to society.
3) As a precursor to a physical invasion. The kinetic attack would be only of the many rumors and reports being circulated. Any and all damage to your enemy's communications brings you one step closer to victory with minimal effort.
More on goal #2: The goal of 9/11 was not to kill some americans. The goal was to destabilize the west by attacking important symbols of economic and political prosperity. It worked,economy was only momentarily destabilized but 17 years later america and the west are grappling to keep their democracies and basic freedoms. The goal of terrorism is to terrorize not to merely kill(which is why mass shooters are not labeled terrorists,their intent is murder not change through terror). A Cyber 9/11 would have similar goals where the intent is to change and cause long term weakening of the adversary.
What makes the internet strong is not BGP,DNS and secure operating systems. It's the fact that people trust it for reliable and resilient communication and governments view it as a strength to their political and economical stability as opposed to a dangerous liability. The goal of terrorism is to change your beliefs so that fear resulting from the attack changes your policy and principles.