News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by colordrops on Friday November 16, 2018 @03:56AM (#18467502)
why?
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by orbifold on Friday November 16, 2018 @04:34AM (#18467630)
CERN is a international cooperation of many countries on neutral (Swiss) territory. While maybe not emphasized in recent years one real danger of high energy particle physics is the discovery of an effect that can be weaponized. Right now that seems highly unlikely, but it was a motivation for setting the CERN up in the way it is.

Then there is the obvious problem of technology transfer. A lot of detector technology can also be used for high resolution surveillance and missile guidance, I’ve met at least one person who did his doctorate in physics at our institute, worked for Raytheon and now owns a company in the defense sector that contributes parts to the successor of the Hubble telescope.

In case you didn’t know there exist 7 nearly identical copies of the Hubble space telescope with different sensors (he worked on those), https://arstechnica.com/science/2012/06/nasa-gets-two-unneed.... The same will be true for the next generation version of the telescope and is also one of the reasons for the “cost overruns”.

Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by T-A on Friday November 16, 2018 @04:59AM (#18467715)
> one real danger of high energy particle physics is the discovery of an effect that can be weaponized

In Dan Brown novels, maybe. The fact that you need an LHC-sized machine to just barely manage to prove the existence of the Higgs boson, and that it has failed to see anything at all beyond the Standard Model, should tell you something.

In short, the requirements for a physical phenomenon to be technologically useful are stronger than the requirements for it to be at all observable. Basic conditions like "needs to interact with ordinary matter and have a decent half-life" are sufficient to rule out the existence of still undiscovered particles with technological potential. If they existed, we would already have found them.

Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by orbifold on Friday November 16, 2018 @05:08AM (#18467743)
I agree that it is highly unlikely but it was deemed far more likely when CERN was founded.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by scottlocklin on Friday November 16, 2018 @11:55AM (#18469921)
People totally forget about this: if you simply look at where the accelerator physics funding comes from in the US, that ought to tell the story. Dept of Energy used to be the atomic energy commission, and is still in charge of bomb research. Heck it wasn't that long ago that plain old particle accelerators were contenders for directed energy systems.

Yeah, it looks like there is no new physics there which could make devilish new weapons, and frankly the state of modern physics is such I don't know as anyone would notice if there was, but nobody knew this in, say, the 1960s. Serious people thought, for example, one might be able to build a weak field ray gun which causes matter to decay into subatomic particles (source 'towards the year 2018' by the Foreign Policy Association).

Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by orbifold on Friday November 16, 2018 @03:45PM (#18471812)
Funnily enough even a lot of string theorists such as Edward Witten were funded by the department of energy.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by Loic on Friday November 16, 2018 @10:01AM (#18469162)
CERN is at the border between France and Switzerland. As such it has two official addresses, one in France and one in Switzerland. Most of the loops are in France. This is important for the European part of the funding. Practically, scientists do not care.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by adrianN on Friday November 16, 2018 @04:59AM (#18467716)
Things can't be a "real danger" and "highly unlikely". What would be, even theoretically, a discovery in a particle accelerator that can be weaponized? Imho improvements in weapons technology won't be coming out of basic physics anytime soon. The real dangers are currently the development of cheap weapons that can be deployed without putting your own soldiers in danger as well as electronic warfare.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by vkou on Friday November 16, 2018 @05:39AM (#18467855)
Actually, the real danger is two countries pointing three thousand nuclear weapons at eachother, on hair-trigger alert, while the rest of the world watches, and shakes its head.

I'd worry about that, long before I'll worry about some magical unicorn particle gun being discovered.

Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by dogma1138 on Friday November 16, 2018 @05:55AM (#18467917)
Hubble was built on an existing EOS bus, JWST on the other hand wasn’t.

Kepler was a dedicated design also while Swift was built on top of a generic LEO sattlite bus.

Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by vixen99 on Friday November 16, 2018 @04:10AM (#18467545)
CERN is run by 22 member states. Is it not likely that the Chinese center would be run and major decisions entirely made, by the Chinese. Many might suspect that is the case. No problems with that?
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday November 16, 2018 @04:48AM (#18467676)
Not really. If they want to build something in their own country and run it how they choose then that's up to them. Why is it a problem? Even if they refuse the share any science with the rest of the world we're no worse off than we were before.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by lpellis on Friday November 16, 2018 @06:22AM (#18468003)
Hopefully they do share though, we might be slightly worse off if they lure away scientists that otherwise would have working in a more open system. But it seems unlikely to be an issue, I'm sure the people working on the cutting edge would like to publish and get the results known everywhere.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by moccachino on Friday November 16, 2018 @06:53AM (#18468123)
When the world went from no country having nuclear weapons to one country having nuclear weapons, was the rest of the world not worse off than before?
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by craftyguy on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:57PM (#18471506)
Are you implying that a particle accelerator can be weaponized?
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by moccachino on Monday November 19, 2018 @04:59AM (#18485242)
Who knows what it could lead to. But no I'm not implying that there is any great danger from this project, but I'm objecting to the idea that one party gaining exclusive information somehow leaves the other parties in an unchanged situation.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by stevenjohns on Friday November 16, 2018 @07:23AM (#18468245)
Probably not. We're doing a lot better than we were 100 years ago, and nuclear weapons have been a great deterrent to stop many countries from engaging in wars that they might have been more tempted to if at least one of the parties didn't have nuclear weapons.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by TheOtherHobbes on Friday November 16, 2018 @09:14AM (#18468831)
We've had almost constant small-scale proxy wars instead, and the arms industry isn't exactly going through hard times.

More realistically, we got lucky and barely dodged the armageddon bullet on a number of occasions.

Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by justapassenger on Friday November 16, 2018 @11:38AM (#18469793)
Yes no problems with that. Each country can choose to invest in science as much as they want and no one has authority to stop them. If member states of cern (I’m a citizen of one) are concerned they should also make those investments.
Re:Plans Revealed for Enormous Particle Collider in China by T-A on Friday November 16, 2018 @04:20AM (#18467586)