Now here's the crazy part: no one is selling a device with stock Android. If your phone was straight Android 2.2, it wouldn't look like any other phone on the market. The minute Motorola or LG realize this, they get 100% of the nerd phone market.
We also have the more budget oriented virgin mobile who have generally little to no customization depending on the phone.
EDIT: Clarification, I'm referring to the carriers. The manufacturers need differentiation, but would be better served doing so through hardware.
The iPhone 4 hasn't been around that long. My guess is you will always find something that could be better and hence you'll never buy an Android phone.
I don't know how true the rumours of a Samsung-made Nexus are, but I wouldn't be surprised given the quality of the Galaxy's hardware.
With that it's been fine for me - I still haven't bothered to install Froyo.
(TL;DR: Use the google service instead of whatever they replaced it with. Who could have guessed..)
It's thinner than an iPhone 3GS, about the same as an iPhone4
No keyboard, touchscreen is the best I've used.
The camera is good. Only downside is it doesn't have a flash - but the low light mode is surprisingly good.
The GPS is accurate (some people have had to change some settings to get quicker startup for it though)
It's not stock Android, but it's easily rootable (as in "install an app from the market and press one button)
Official firmware upgrade is just too much of hassle on this phone.
http://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/dscb6/samsung_galax...
Basically: Downgrade to a specific version of Kies not containing the buggy FW updater. Upgrade your phone. The upgrade to 2.2 is definitely worth it.
Here's what I've been waiting for in an Android phone since they started pumping them out: thin, no keyboard, responsive touchscreen, iPhone4-quality camera, accurate GPS and stock Android or easily rootable. Pretty much, I don't want any compromises, and no one seems to want to do it. Every single model skimps somewhere. If it's got a nice camera, the GPS doesn't work. Otherwise, the camera is crap or it's 3/4 of an inch thick with a keyboard I won't use. The Nexus One is so close, but the touchscreen sucks and the camera is beyond terrible.