I'm obviously simplifying. Luxury apartments downtown are different to the sort of monstrosities you see in suburbs.
Moving from a family home in a suburb into the city =/= moving from a family home into a block of flats on the same street. The latter is what I am calling a 'strict downgrade'.
Schools are the #1 example of this.
Badly maintained rental apartments and higher crime rates are some other examples of the same.
Not just badly maintained but badly designed as well.
I've live in flats (apartments) since 2003 and off the two I actually liked there was a single distinguishing characteristic - They where quiet.
One was a department store that was converted so the floors where thick rebar concrete and the current one was just well designed in terms of noise.
Noise is an absolute determining factor on where I choose to live (as a life long insomniac it makes the difference between half decent sleep when I'm really tired and not).
Modern mid rises are usually a single concrete story, then wood.
A low floor on a high rise is often higher quality and competitively priced with a mid rise.
In my area older folks are leaving 30-40 year old suburban tract homes that needs roofs, hvac, etc and moving to condos in or near the city.
Likewise, don't assume that preferences are equally distributed among options.
In most demographics, and especially after having a family, the "apartment lifestyle" thing is in the minority.
I don’t either. That’s what lawn service is for.
And that's not to mention the many benefits of living in a higher-density neighborhood, which would be impossible in a place full of semi-/fully-detached houses.
I moved from house to apartment for 3 years and hated every minute of it. Noisy neighbors, no garage, bad WiFi with everyone having the same apartment mandated internet and cable package, and a gym with unmaintained equipment.
Not to mention rent that went up from $1200 to $1600 within three years. Now the same place is $2000 just 3 years later.
In London you have share of freehold apartments in the outer boroughs, but in Central London it's almost all leasehold. You have a long lease, but ultimately you have a superior landlord, pay a service charge which can vary, the exterior of the building isn't yours, etc.
A huge benefit of buying a house over an apartment here is that you can actually meaningfully own it. Repairs are up to you, the postbox is up to you, if you want a thing done you just do it (no negotiation or cost sharing), the land is yours forever and the superior landlord can't change to one who's less amenable, etc.
I suppose this could fall under your: > happen to have a decent choice of apartments for sale
comment, but it's really more that the legal structures in the UK hugely favour owning a house. (I'm not really sure it could ever be different, an apartment is always going to be "closer to renting" because it's communal to a degree).
We moved into a townhouse a year ago, and the number of people (including our neighbors) that think we live in a condo association is startling. I'm pretty sure part of it is that the realtors here don't understand the difference.
I also know that my comparative insurance is less because I live off the ground floor in an apartment block with restricted/limited access and hard concrete construction.
Any desire to tax non-dense/dense properties at similar or different rates is a particular policy choice, and on a cost ratio basis the denser living choice often ends up being cheaper because resources can be pooled and shared.
I appreciate that this is probably true for the majority of people (at least in the west?) but it certainly doesn't apply to me, nor some of my friends.
I like not having a front/back yard to maintain (I don't enjoy gardening). I like the views that you can only get from higher floors, especially city views. I've even come to rely on some of the conveniences, like having a mail room with someone that'll sign for packages while I'm away.
And that's not to mention the many benefits of living in a higher-density neighborhood, which would be impossible in a place full of semi-/fully-detached houses.
> No-one wants to live in a block of flats unless they're too poor to afford a house.
I almost have the opposite view to you, which is that I wouldn't give up my apartment lifestyle unless I was priced out of the city, and could only afford a house in the suburbs.
In the end it's up to personal preference, and you're certainly welcome to prefer a house. But don't assume that everyone has the same preference as you.