I also live in Utah and it's strange to think that this man was likely already infected, but didn't know it, at the time I dealt with my bat.
It's related to the assertion that fewer than 1 in 100 programmers is unable to write "FizzBuz" in the programming language of their choice.
The rate may be statistically insignificant amongst all programmers, but what is the rate amongst programmers looking for a job?
Different question :-)
The scary thing is that's pretty much how you know that an animal is rabid: animals that would avoid people completely will now bite them.
The exception to this in my case was a little pup that was scared and confused due to a forest fire outside. The smoke drove it into the house and it only screeched a little bit when I picked it up. It's doing fine now.
A large number of stories I've heard involving people playing with small wild mammals end with rabies. When it comes to bats, raccoons, and possums, I was always taught to treat them as rabid because healthy ones won't ever get close to random humans if they can help it. That this guy was letting them lick his fingers is unimaginable to me.