Suppose there was positive correlation between racial diversity and violent crime in the US. Would you support de jure segregation, because it reduces violence? Even if there seem to be good effects from segregation didn't necessarily mean the government should dictate living locations.
Even if there are good effects from legislated prices, that doesn't necessarily mean the government should dictate employment contacts.
"Social contract arguments typically posit that individuals have consented, either explicitly or tacitly, to surrender some of their freedoms and submit to the authority of the ruler (or to the decision of a majority) in exchange for protection of their remaining rights."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_contract
The only thing you're actually arguing against is applying it mindlessly regardless of any other concerns, as in, the reduction of violent crime is sufficient in and of itself to be a "better end" -- in actual fact, we've seen separate but equal doesn't work.
As an aside, look at people like Marcus Garvey. As an attempt to resolve the conflict in America between black and white, complete segregation has been seriously proposed; it was not (entirely) stopped or prevented due to ethical/moral arguments. As a slightly silly example, you have a family who has been living in a home for 100 years, but the neighborhood they live in has shifted. Perhaps you use eminent domain to remove them. Now multiply that by thousands -- will they all move peacefully? Where are you getting the money for this? etc. etc.
> Even if there are good effects from legislated prices, that doesn't necessarily mean the government should dictate employment contacts.
Doesn't necessarily mean it shouldn't either. I would argue the better solution would be mandatory union participation. Unions would equalize the power imbalance between the individual worker and, say, McDonald's, without the government dictating terms. But I'm guessing you, or people who also support your argument, would balk at that as well.
A more plausible approach is discouraging immigration of heterogeneous population.
Sound familiar?
> Even if there seem to be good effects from segregation didn't necessarily mean the government should dictate living locations.
To be clear, you're NOT saying there are good effects of segregation, right? That was just an example to illustrate a point? Because I see zero positives from segregation.
Possible reason being, the more likely you are able to socially connect with your potential victim and the less likely you are to see them as the "other," then the less likely you are to feel justified in causing them harm.
KKK feels justified because other races are inferior, the rich feel justified in exploiting the poor because poor people are lazy, e.g.
Like you say, it's not hard to believe that homogeneity (whether race, religion, culture, ethics, politics etc.) causes less conflict. Naturally, that's an awful justification for a terrible practice.
But you find many tunnel-visioned "the statistics justify the means" arguments: minimum wage, gun control, privacy, etc. Proper laws are not just about statistically good outcomes.
Employers may abuse employees in terms of wage, and this has been seen in the past.
Corporations have a stronger negotiating position than many (most?) potential employees, and one of the primary ways this is manifested is in the following manner:
When a person faces the choice of no-income (substituted for your use of "job") or income, the choice of income is near-universally better.
I think the conclusion "we need a minimum wage" is too strong. This is not the only way to provide bargaining power to potential employees. By way of proof I offer an alternative means to a minimum wage, namely some form of subsidy given to all humans. This type of arrangement is often termed a universal basic income and there are numerous specific implementations which have been proposed over time.
It seems that having identified a problem (employees may be faced with a raw deal when interacting with employers), we should look for multiple (though perhaps not all - exhaustive searches can be expensive (keep in mind time is a resource and that opportunity cost is always present)) approaches and weigh their positive and negative characteristics.
To do otherwise seems but a parody of rhetoric and reason, captured well in the "Yes, Minister" scene linked below[0].
I do not propose UBI as the only alternative to a minimum wage, or even as the best of all possible options, only to suggest that your obnoxious people may perceive both the problem you have posed and an alternative solution that they believe to be better than the one you propose.
The way you present your argument seems to me to assume that those who disagree with you must be ignorant or malicious. Starting a conversation with either assumption seems fruitless. To accuse (even obliquely) a person of ignorance and forcibly try to educate them is, in my experience, an exercise in insult and folly - even if a person is ignorant, an aggressive teacher is not likely to be listened to. To engage a malicious actor with reason and education seems simply folly - if they understand the problem you pose and enjoy the ill it brings to people, then you have nothing to gain by explaining that negative effect. It seems to me that such a rhetorical approach is geared to identify friends and foes, group these people together, and allow the speaker to dismiss the latter.
You have the unlucky position of being the first in this thread engaging in such a way. I see it equally among those that I imagine you would side with and those you would side against. I have the unfortunate disposition of occasionally ranting as I have above.
I hope that if you've stayed with me this far that you are, in fact, interested in reasoned discourse and willing to accept some unsolicited advice from an internet stranger who is ornery today. Perhaps you might do better at engaging those obnoxious people by finding common ground - it is usually simple to agree that you are both interested in improving the lot of those who are least well off and that you both agree that certain problems can and do exist. From there it is much easier to find a productive conversation about various means to address the specific problems, and the many positives and negatives of each.
Ultimately when any job is better than no job, people will take what they can get. Companies know this, and will pay people obscenely low amounts to take advantage of people without any other options. Therefore to protect them and ensure they can have a livable wage, we need to maintain a minimum wage.