Re:The X10 Programming Language
by motters on Monday October 25, 2010 @06:49PM
(#1831975)
Bad choice of name. X10 is a system for modulating mains electricity supply in order to send signals, for example to switch lights on or off. A simple Google search would have told them this. It's probably not a good idea to name your new language in such a way that it can be easily confused with other kinds of technology.
Re:The X10 Programming Language
by Groxx on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:41PM
(#1831509)
It's also got to be one of the hardest language names to type. Shift+bottom row ring-finger, number-row far left, number-row far right.
(love the comment, btw. In part because I first thought the standard was going to try to make a comeback, from the title alone. Upon seeing it was a language, that was my exact reaction.)
Re:The X10 Programming Language
by Groxx on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:26PM
(#1831458)
omg, it gets worse than that. From their (incomplete!) online tutorial, which downloads an HTML file instead of displaying it:
>Xiom: The global/non-global distinction in X10 is intended to make you powerful, not miserable. This will not be obvious while you are getting used to X10.
(a (lame) play on "Axiom")
The tutorial documentation goes downhill even further after that. I'm having trouble deciding if this is real or an extraordinarily elaborate April Fool's day joke.
Re:The X10 Programming Language
by wmf on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:18PM
(#1831430)
Not really. Erlang is for reliable concurrent transactional computing while X10 is for parallel scientific computing. You might say that X10 aims to replace Fortan.
Re:The X10 Programming Language
by p4bl0 on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:33PM
(#1831485)
Then it's doomed IMO, since there's Fortress (http://projectfortress.sun.com/) out threre developed at the Sun Labs and which seems to be a better candidate to replace Fortran.
Re:The X10 Programming Language
by wmf on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:36PM
(#1831495)
DARPA funded X10 and Fortress at the same time to provide options for a future "high-productivity" HPC programming language; it's not clear that either one has gotten any traction yet.
Re:The X10 Programming Language
by hugh3 on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:28PM
(#1831465)
Excellent. It's about time that something did.
Well really, C++ is rapidly replacing Fortran for scientific computing, but it ain't all that much better for it. I'm excited about the idea that this replaces MPI.
Re:The X10 Programming Language
by p4bl0 on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:37PM
(#1831501)
Physicists at my school/uni (in France) use Python with appropriate libs, but I don't know if it's the general case here, since I know physicists from near university use C++ (badly from what I saw, but that's an other story).
Re:The X10 Programming Language
by hugh3 on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:53PM
(#1831544)
I'm a physicist, and I use Python (with scipy/numpy when appropriate) when I can get away with it (ie for small to medium-sized calculations).
For big calculations, though, where what you can do is limited by performance, there's no getting away from C++ or Fortran. Python has a huge performance overhead (I have learned this the hard way).
-----
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X10_(industry_standard)
Don't you know that X10 is the name of industry-standard communications protocol?
Oops. C'est la vie. Next question, please.
(love the comment, btw. In part because I first thought the standard was going to try to make a comeback, from the title alone. Upon seeing it was a language, that was my exact reaction.)
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1565788
...ayfkm? You've already failed.>Xiom: The global/non-global distinction in X10 is intended to make you powerful, not miserable. This will not be obvious while you are getting used to X10.
(a (lame) play on "Axiom")
The tutorial documentation goes downhill even further after that. I'm having trouble deciding if this is real or an extraordinarily elaborate April Fool's day joke.
Well really, C++ is rapidly replacing Fortran for scientific computing, but it ain't all that much better for it. I'm excited about the idea that this replaces MPI.
For big calculations, though, where what you can do is limited by performance, there's no getting away from C++ or Fortran. Python has a huge performance overhead (I have learned this the hard way).