News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by AllegedAlec on Friday October 26, 2018 @04:13AM (#18307566)
This is why castle doctrines and stand-your-ground laws exist and should exist, imho.
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by pjc50 on Friday October 26, 2018 @04:28AM (#18307615)
So you can get shot by the police? Neither of those is ever going to give you the right to overrule a court order with a gun, and doing this in a country where people are routinely shot for mere suspicion of having a gun is extremely risky.
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by dsfyu404ed on Friday October 26, 2018 @08:58AM (#18308747)
It's not that simple.

Castle laws and a high likelihood of any particular household being armed tends to result in the sort of shenanigans like described in TFA not happening at all because it becomes an unnecessary risk from the point of the people who are approving it.

The (IMO) best example of this is abuse of no-knock search/arrest warrants. When you kick down someone's door in the middle of the night they're likely to shoot at you if they can. Yelling "police" won't be enough to prevent someone from shooting back a lot of the time because people don't generally have the best situational awareness after being woken up at 3AM by a bang. The police are well aware of that any no-knock warrant has a chance of killing on of their own which would result in a lot of questions being asked and a need to justify to the public their actions that lead to the death of the officer. Getting officers killed because you wanted to play cowboy when it wasn't strictly necessary is not something the police unions and professional associations take kindly to. No chief wants that on their record. This is why sloppy/unjustifiable use of no-knock warrants is rarer places where a large chunk of the population (particularly the lower classes) are armed.

It's not about you personally being able to shoot back. It's about having the ability to and how that affects the risk/reward equation for the people calling the shots who have to think at the statistical level.

Back to the article, a judge is much less likely to give the ok for some corporate lawyers, a locksmith and a bailiff (i.e. not a bunch of uniformed police officers) to go poke around someone's property if there's a chance that it could provoke an armed confrontation (which could end in a way that could come back to bite him/her).

If Mr. Lackman resided in a "rough" trailer park in a state with castle doctrine and constitutional carry (which as an aside tend to actually be almost free of violent crime) I guarantee at least one employee in the courtroom would have giggled a little when the corporate lawyers described where they wanted to go and what they want to do. It would be like someone asking to release some tiny bug fix on prod on Black Friday, sure it would probably work fine and nothing would go wrong but you'd get laughed at for asking because it's just not worth the risk.

Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by gambiting on Friday October 26, 2018 @04:45AM (#18307671)
On the other hand - if the court orders a search of someone's property, I want it to be carried out. We can sit here and argue that the court should have never ever issued such order in the first place, but the law has to be followed.
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by AllegedAlec on Friday October 26, 2018 @04:49AM (#18307688)
If the court orders a search of someone's property, it should be done by law enforcement, not be the accusing party.
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by palunon on Friday October 26, 2018 @05:17AM (#18307796)
In a criminal case, sure. In a civil case, law enforcement isn't involved at all (at least in old English common law based countries)

I guess that why a bailiff was present - as an officer of the court authorized to oversee such matters.

Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by AllegedAlec on Friday October 26, 2018 @05:37AM (#18307876)
So now we're giving companies with an axe to grind the judicial power to enforce the laws themselves? That seems like a really good idea.
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by gambiting on Friday October 26, 2018 @05:58AM (#18307946)
The what now? They are not enforcing anything - the court is. They took the matter to court and essentially said "look, we have all reason to believe that person X has our property on their premises, we ask for permission to enter those premises to recover our property". And the court says "ok, but in order to make sure there is no funny business, I'm sending an independent lawyer and technical experts appointed by this court to accompany you". That sounds absolutely fine to me, no?

It's like if someone rented your car and didn't return it at the end of the rental period - that's not theft, or at least it would be hard to prove it as such, so at least right off the bat, it's not a criminal case. It's against the contract you two had though, and you would have to sue the rentee in civil court - and yes, the court would absolutely allow you to go to the yard where the car was kept, and recover it yourself - they would maybe send a bailiff with you, but not an actual police officer.

Is that "allowing private citizens/companies power to enforce laws"? Of course not.

Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by jstanley on Friday October 26, 2018 @06:14AM (#18308005)
1.) Running a website that allows other people to upload their own software for others to download is hardly comparable to stealing a rental car. He can hardly be said to have "had the claimant's property on his premises".

For comparison, Github takes an equally "laissez-faire approach to policing content on its site". Should the creators of Github be raided, questioned for 9 hours, passwords handed over, and the website taken offline, just because a user uploads something that a megacorp doesn't like?

2.) "I'm sending an independent lawyer and technical experts appointed by this court to accompany you" - they are actually appointed by the claimant, not the court.

Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by gambiting on Friday October 26, 2018 @06:32AM (#18308073)
1) and this brings us back to my original point - we can sit here and argue that the court should have never issued such order in the first place. But because it did, I want to see it carried out(or maybe let me put it this way - I don't want to see the power of search warrants neutered, just because courts sometimes misuse them. They are hugely helpful tool for law enforcement, and we should definitely work against courts issuing them frivolously or under pressure from corporations).

2) Quoting from the article: "One of the lawyers represented some of Canada’s most powerful telecommunications and media companies: Bell, Rogers, Vidéotron, and TVA. The other was there to be an independent observer on behalf of the court."

Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by AllegedAlec on Friday October 26, 2018 @06:48AM (#18308120)
> I don't want to see the power of search warrants neutered, just because courts sometimes misuse them.

This isn't a search warrant though.

Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by jstanley on Friday October 26, 2018 @08:04AM (#18308453)
He was there to be an independent observer, but he is appointed by the claimant, see the link posted elsewhere in this thread: https://www.inbrief.co.uk/civil-court/search-orders/
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by AllegedAlec on Friday October 26, 2018 @06:48AM (#18308118)
Even if the car example was valid, which I'd argue against, and even if the company itself would be allowed to go onto your property to obtain that car, which I'm not sure that actually can, the comparison would still be invalid.

The search isn't limited to just the data which that say you have stolen, but are allowed to basically get copies of anything digital you own, even things which have nothing to do with the matter at hand. Medical documents? Well, the hard drive they are on could contain stolen data, so they can copy the entire harddrive. Confidential data of clients you have? Same thing.

Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by Lio on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:27PM (#18310731)
This is the big problem as I see it. Not normally would pictures of your family be taken in evidence for an unrelated crime, to be gone over later by some unseen third party.

Here they just hoover up everything and once it's out the door you don't know what happens to it or who's looking at it.

It seems to me like these companies were able to use a legal form of intimidation to shut down someone offering a competing technology platform.

Not a pirate but a competitor.

Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by vezycash on Friday October 26, 2018 @09:35AM (#18309030)
A non neutral party can plant "proof of piracy."
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by AllegedAlec on Friday October 26, 2018 @09:49AM (#18309163)
Even if they didn't do that, what happens when you share your house with one or more room mates? Are all of you electronics and your social media accounts, or even worse, bank accounts, in danger, because, well 'someone in this house is suspect of doing a boo boo, so we're confiscating everything'?
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by gambiting on Friday October 26, 2018 @05:17AM (#18307798)
While I agree that it should be done by law enforcement, the court order already requires that a lawyer with no connection to the case should be present, as well as court appointed technical experts. I think that's a pretty strong protection.
Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by breakingcups on Friday October 26, 2018 @05:24AM (#18307831)
Who pays for that independent lawyer?

If the accusing party, is there not a conflict of interest?

Re:When Telecom Companies Search Your Home for Piracy by tomjen3 on Friday October 26, 2018 @04:55PM (#18312642)
Unjust laws should result in a bullet to head of anyone who tries to carry them out.

It is the only way to justify tyranny.