News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by protomyth on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:24PM (#18306532)
The article talks about two points of resentment. The more serious is people moving to red states not understanding why they are moving and voting for the same type of politicians that they fled from. If you move, at least try to understand your neighbors.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by nostrademons on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:01AM (#18306700)
Eh, the California Conveyor Belt has been operating for decades. It's already turned Portland, Boulder, and RTP blue. Next up seem to be Asheville, Reno, Boise, Austin, and possibly even Arizona and Houston.

I have a theory that people's political beliefs are largely manifestations of the behaviors that make sense within their economic system. So Blue America cares a lot about women's rights and abortion access because women are an integral part of the knowledge-worker economy, without which it couldn't function. They care about identity politics and political correctness because the information economy requires close creative work in teams, and you can't do that kind of work unless everybody has a certain psychological sense of safety. They care about redistributive policies because cities are big enough, dense enough, and diverse enough that you can't rely on social pressure to make sure everyone contributes. They care about diversity and immigration because you can't run highly-specialized knowledge-based businesses without bringing in talent from elsewhere.

Meanwhile, Red America cares about gun rights because you basically need them to live in a rural area where wild animals may surprise you at any time. They care about taxation because the businesses are usually self-reliant, independent firms (often in commodity markets) rather than deeply-networked, interconnected systems which often depend upon government R&D. They care about cultural homogeneity and upholding sacred traditions because that's a large part of the social fabric in smaller towns & cities where everybody knows everybody else. They care about liberty because they don't want Blue Staters lording their foreign values over them.

The California Conveyor is basically a manifestation of one socio-economic system growing and eating the other. As the world's population gets bigger and more interconnected, the relative size of the information economy gets bigger compared to the manufacturing, resource-extraction, and agricultural economies. That sucks up young people who are looking for jobs in industries that are growing, and deposits them in big cities. When they've made their fortunes and want to settle down, they move elsewhere, where land values are lower. But they're still embedded in the economic system (many keep the same professions, but work remotely or for different employers) and they keep the values that make sense with that economic system.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by dkhenry on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:42AM (#18307035)
Thats an interesting theory, but I don't think it would pass muster of a statistical analysis. Political affiliations track much closer with gender, faith, and economic standing then with Occupation. I would classify any pockets of political concentration as a result of subtle bias in selecting people rather then a natural result of the occupation. ( kinda like what they found here [1] with houses)

Also people in rural area's generally don't carry around guns to protect themselves from wild animals with a few exceptions like the deep wilderness of Alaska.

1. http://www.bgu.ac.il/BIDR/research/staff/meron/papers/epa.pd...

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by nostrademons on Friday October 26, 2018 @02:15PM (#18311582)
I was thinking more in terms of economic system than occupation. The Mexican housecleaner for a Silicon Valley hotel, the American supply-chain executive at Apple, and the Shenzhen electrical engineer are all part of the same economic system, even though they're of wildly different races, social classes, occupations, geographies, and nationalities. Similarly, the Koch Brothers and the West Virginian coal miners are part of the same economic system (and disparate from the previous one), despite being of vastly different wealth levels and occupations. The casinos in downtown Las Vegas (which serve an older, whiter, and more American clientele) are part of a different economic system than many of the mega-resorts on The Strip, even though they're in the same industry, same occupation, and same geographical location.

My definition of "economic system" is a constellation of related businesses that are all adapted to a particular level of technology. Certain technologies - particularly ones related to communication, transportation, energy, and finance - dictate an optimum arrangement of firms within the economy, because they directly affect transaction costs, and transaction costs are the reason we have firms instead of independent producers. When a major new technology - like the Internet - becomes widely adopted, that optimum changes, and many firms just no longer make economic sense anymore: even if the firm remains economically competitive within its market, its market no longer exists anymore, because the boundaries of how it makes sense to divide the economy into firms have shifted, as have what the economy actually produces. But it takes a long time - generations - for this to actually filter through all of the economy, because existing business relationships don't die until the companies involved run out of cash, which doesn't happen until a critical mass of their own customers run out of cash, and so on. So for a period of 30ish years, the two economies exist side-by-side, but often with a lot of friction between the two of them, along with a growing wealth disparity. People can feel that there's a new, alien way of life that threatens to destroy everything about what they know of the world, but because few people have visibility into the whole economy, they often can't place exactly why they're mad and end up seizing on surface manifestations of the problem.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by crwalker on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:28AM (#18306785)
That’s a great description of the challenge.

To me, some California norms seem a bit like margin trading: loved for their high rewards when times are good, but eschewed by many with a broader historical view due to the potential for ruin.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by tofof on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:29PM (#18306559)
People should vote for whomever they feel best represents their concerns and interests, or whom they think will govern best for their society at large.

If you move, try and understand your neighbors, certainly, but that doesn't mean voting for the candidate that best represents them instead of best representing you.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by ip26 on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:42PM (#18306622)
Speaking as a transplant, it's not wrong to ask that transplants at least take a moment to consider why they left home and moved here, when making voting decisions. If you left because of high taxes, voting for tax increases in your new home at least appears misguided.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by khuey on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:17AM (#18306754)
Most people aren't leaving because of high taxes, they're leaving because of high housing costs.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by ip26 on Friday October 26, 2018 @10:35AM (#18309559)
Sure, so then stop for a minute and think before voting for, e.g., low density zoning.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by alexanderwept on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:42PM (#18306626)
Fair point.

Let me try to steel man the parent comment and maybe you can respond:

These people are fleeing the very predictable consequences of progressive governance, they should make an attempt to understand what made their origin so bad they wanted to leave and what made their destination so good that they decided to move there. If they vote for the policies that led them to flee, they might start the cycle over again.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by untog on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:06AM (#18306717)
I'd question using terms like "progressive" there. For instance, the reason SF is so expensive is that it's impossible to build more housing. That's not in any way a progressive policy.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by dkhenry on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:47AM (#18307048)
I don't want to say its _only_ because of "progressive" policies, but specifically affordability is hurt by lack of construction, and construction is hurt by things like low income housing units, high fee's for new construction, and rent control. Those are all marketed as progressive and they are choking supply.

The entire reason why Senate Bill 827 failed was because progressives said it didn't protect the low income from gentrification.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by jeffbax on Saturday October 27, 2018 @08:39AM (#18315469)
"Progressive" generally goes along with the mentality there's no problem that is not solvable by government, which is usually the least efficient and cost effective mechanism for most problems.

This undoubtedly causes a ripple effect through the economy as all costs proceed to rise over time if not in check. Never mind how many preferred policies like rent control and micromanaged environmental laws that accumulate like technical debt and paralyze development have wrecked the housing market and soak the tech industry like a huge transfer tax that benefits those who got in the right place at the right time in the 80s/90s and shut everything down.

"Affordable housing" is another misnomered policy that is shooting oneself in the foot. Instead of just having market pricing and allowing the city to grow as demanded you let a few poor people stay because they win a lottery and still drive the bulk of people far out.

The syringe, shit laden road to hell is paved with good intentions still holds true today, and why I call myself a liberal but not a progressive in the political sense. There's a definite distinction, and certainly not unreasonable to hope that voters driven out by those policies take a moment to think of how things got there.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by paleotrope on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:16AM (#18306753)
It's really not "impossible".
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by aplummer on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:11AM (#18306738)
“Progressive” isn’t why people flee. Nobody is fleeing Australia which has higher taxes than SF.

I think people would be more inclined to stay if the money went further, I’m yet to understand why the taxes are so high without free hospitals, university, super clean streets etc.

legitimate Q: where does it all disappear in San Francisco that doesn’t occur in progressive Europe / Aus / NZ?

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by stonith on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:21AM (#18306955)
I don't want to be rude but are you Australian or are you just guessing? All of the top graduates from my Software Engineering class in Aus either went to the US or did a PhD and then went to the US, and people are absolutely fleeing Sydney because the cost of living is too high.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by aplummer on Friday October 26, 2018 @02:14AM (#18307130)
Yes I’m Australian -

I don’t think people are fleeing given the net emigration from the US, and the high cost of living in Sydney is actually my point exactly -

It’s not Sydney’s “progressiveness” that makes it expensive, you could live in Melbourne or Hobart where the tax is the same and it’s much less expensive, both more progressive. Three identical sets of benefits and taxes, wildly different cost of living.

My point was that it’s not progressiveness that makes places too expensive, it’s other factors.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:49PM (#18306647)
California isn't that expensive if you own a home outright. It's mostly expensive because of Prop 13.

Prop 13 was championed by two Republicans and passed under Reagan.

Yes, California has a 13.3% income tax and a 10% sales tax. That really has little to do with party lines. It has everything to do with Prop 13. If you can't tax old money in real estate, you have to tax something else...

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by masonic on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:51AM (#18307065)

  Prop 13 was championed by two Republicans and passed under Reagan.
Wrong. Proposition 13 passed when Jerry Brown was governor and Democrats controlled both the Assembly and Senate.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday October 26, 2018 @09:05AM (#18308786)
Interesting. Reagan was governor from 67-75, but the Wikipedia page seemed (to me) to imply it was passed under Reagan (it wasn't):

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_(1...

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by sjg007 on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:51AM (#18307062)
Jerry Brown was governor when prop 13 was passed.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by anonuser123456 on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:17AM (#18306755)
Prop 13 has nothing to do with lack of supply. More supply == lower prices.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by gpapilion on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:35AM (#18306805)
Prop 13 restricts supply. For example I have a modest home I bought for what’s now half the market value. I won’t sell to move to a slightly better home because my taxes would double.

Additionally my mother-in-law bought her home in the 70s for 1/20 of its current value. There are exemptions that allow to move within her county, but to downsize would likely 5x her taxes or more.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by michaelmrose on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:45AM (#18306845)
Isn't it great how the poor to middle class can fund the wealth of the more monied class.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by masonic on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:57AM (#18307082)

  my taxes would double
Not if Proposition 5 passes.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by dragonwriter on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:46AM (#18307046)
> Prop 13 has nothing to do with lack of supply.

Prop 13 has everything to do with lack of supply; localities not being able to pay operational costs of additional infrastructure without negotiating new state aid plays a big role in localities not being inclined to support growth in any way that they are able to resist unless it's tied to something that directly produces ongoing local revenue.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by masonic on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:54AM (#18307075)

  localities not being able to pay operational costs of additional infrastructure without negotiating new state aid 
I have no idea what you're talking about here. There's no negotiable "state aid" that does that. Generally, development fees are charged to developers for impact on schools and such.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by tomcam on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:11AM (#18306737)
Or you can try living within your means like the rest of us
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by michaelmrose on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:42AM (#18306832)
Maybe you should take your own advice about being attentive to your neighbors.

Perhaps the universe is simpler than you imagine. Having put aside a pile of money they want to invest it where it will buy more.

Alternatively perhaps they disagree with some aspects of life in CA but would be happy to import other aspects.

Perhaps they intelligently believe in increased taxation because they believe what their tax money will buy is worth the sacrifice.

In flatland this is a contradiction but if Florida with x% more taxes is still substantially cheaper than the bay area now it might well not be. Give your neighbors more credit.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by smadge on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:41PM (#18306620)
Can you document the link you claim between liberal policies and high cost of living?
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by protomyth on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:47PM (#18306644)
I guess I would read the article that points out the high taxes to support liberal policies is one reason people are moving.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by smadge on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:31AM (#18306797)
I gathered from the article that the main reason people were moving was because of the high cost of living. Higher taxes certainly are a part of the high cost of living. However, clearly the high cost of housing is the largest contributor to the high cost of living, not taxes.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by davidgay on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:31AM (#18306798)
One could easily think that taxes in California are too high, but that in the place one moved to they are too low (assuming they are substantially lower than California of course). So I'm not convinced there's an inconsistency.

Personally, I think US+California taxes are too low, especially for high incomes. But I'm undoubtably biased from having grown up in that well-known-haven of high tax rates called Switzerland.

Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by BurningFrog on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:54PM (#18306676)
My impression, if you excuse the broad strokes, is that it's mostly that liberals live in big cities where they have banned housing construction, with resulting exploding housing costs.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by smadge on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:33AM (#18306800)
I think “NIMBY”ism is bipartisan among affluent homeowners, whose have both an economic and social incentive to prevent new low cost housing in their neighborhoods.
Re:Boise and Reno capitalize on the California real estate e... by BurningFrog on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:19AM (#18306947)
Probably true.

It's still the heavily liberal big cities that are the most unaffordable. By far. It's not a subtle effect.