News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by propman on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:04PM (#18296373)
Tesla could realistically hit 500,000 cars next year, almost 10% of total cars sold in America. The electric revolution is here and it’s finally profitable! Budget EVs with solid range are coming next year too with the 2019 leaf!

Convince congress to extend the federal tax rebate (no real increase in spending just keeping what’s already there) by like 2 years which is just maybe $1-2B more and electric will be the way to go for good!

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by kllrnohj on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:57PM (#18297196)
> Tesla could realistically hit 500,000 cars next year, almost 10% of total cars sold in America.

US consumer auto sales per year are in the 16-17 million range. I personally wouldn't consider 3% to be "almost 10%", do you?

But I don't think they realistically can hit 500,000 cars next year, either. They moved 70k cars in Q3. There's no reason to believe they can double that in 6 months or so particularly as the Model S & X sales have been fairly stable. So that means the Model 3 needs to somehow grow to around 400k/year in order to get to 500k cars next year.

They state production of Model 3 was up to 5,300 per week and that the production system had stabilized with gradual monthly improvements. So currently Tesla can only even build 275k Model 3's a year. I don't think doubling that in such a short time frame meshes with Tesla's comments of "gradual monthly improvements."

350,000 cars in 2019 seems much more likely assuming Model 3 demand holds strong.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by propman on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:58PM (#18297789)
I meant cars, not all autos. Cars are 6.2 million. Musk said he’s trying to get to 6000 a week by the end of August and 10,000 a week in 2019. The demand is clearly there as are the profit margins even sans ev credit. I know he overestimates things a lot but that tells me they are seriously considering ramping up production. As the production and now delivery processes streamline, they can definitely hit 6000 by end of year and realistically hit 8000 by mid 2019.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by swarnie_ on Thursday October 25, 2018 @04:54AM (#18299473)
While i'm totally behind this rocket ship you need to take any number Musk give you and add a random number of months between 6 and 18 to it.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by Reason077 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:48PM (#18297458)
Elon Musk has reiterated recently that Tesla's goal is to reach Model 3 production of 10,000 per week in 2019.

But not all of those sales will be in the US. According to the Q3 update document:

"The mid-sized premium sedan market in Europe is more than twice as big as the same segment in the US. This is why we are excited to bring Model 3 to Europe early next year. "

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by kllrnohj on Thursday October 25, 2018 @10:30AM (#18301149)
> But not all of those sales will be in the US. According to the Q3 update document:

Which would make it even less likely Tesla can hit 10% of US passenger car sales as they'll be sacrificing what little production they have to try and break into other markets.

Anyway just hitting 10k/week in 2019 isn't sufficient for the 500k number. They'd need to average 10k week for the entirety of 2019. Very different things.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by FireBeyond on Thursday October 25, 2018 @12:15AM (#18298514)
The number of auto sales in the US is determined by demand, not by how much auto makers can supply (within price adjustment constraints, of course).
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by Reason077 on Thursday October 25, 2018 @05:34AM (#18299606)
The Model 3 is currently production constrained. Tesla sell as many as they can produce.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by adventured on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:14PM (#18297289)
> US consumer auto sales per year are in the 16-17 million range. I personally wouldn't consider 3% to be "almost 10%", do you?

The parent comment said "cars." You switched that to consumer auto sales. 6.3 million passenger cars were sold in the US in 2017. With passenger car sales declining and generally losing popularity in the US (dropping from 7.9m in 2014), it's plausible that 500,000 will in fact be "almost" 10% of total cars sold in the US in 2019.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by SilasX on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:25PM (#18297347)
In common parlance, an SUV counts in "all cars sold", so it's misleading, even if technically correct.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by ProfessorLayton on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:25PM (#18297345)
I suppose if US passenger car sales, a segment the Model 3 & S belong to, decline by 1/3 in 2019 that statement could ring true.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by burger_moon on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:58PM (#18298288)
Ford killed off their entire car line up except the mustang so there will be a fairly significant drop from that alone.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by antisthenes on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:07PM (#18296409)
What's just as amazing is that this whole revolution is done off the back of the Li-Ion 18650/21700 battery cell.

Time will tell how good of a choice it is.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by aphextron on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:06PM (#18297563)
>What's just as amazing is that this whole revolution is done off the back of the Li-Ion 18650/21700 battery cell.

18650 is the cell form factor, not a specific anode/cathode/electrolyte combo. There have been leaps and bounds in cell chemistry over the last 10 years which have made it possible to build high-end expensive cars, but we still need about double the performance of current tech to achieve true low cost mass adoption. A $45,000 car with 300 miles range is just barely enough to convince well off people to buy a new toy. The first $20,000 EV with 300 miles range will change the world.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by greglindahl on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:13PM (#18296459)
I recall reading many HN posters commenting that this cylindrical form factor was a terrible choice for cars. Now several other carmakers have adopted it.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by ethbro on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:18PM (#18296494)
The Edison (E26/7, circa-1900) base isn't the best choice for light bulbs.

But it is good enough.

And now we're plugging high-powered LED bulbs into them. Technology finds a way. Be first!

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by gruturo on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:32PM (#18296623)
It's only a terrible choice if you do not think about cooling the batteries, and having some physical protection against runaway thermal effects.

If you do, suddenly that empty space becomes precious.

The fact that other carmakers started using it is a good sign.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by sliken on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:22PM (#18296523)
From an engineering perspective it's suboptimal since they have small surface area relative to volume. That's probably why Telsa went with the 2170 instead of the 26650, which has a larger diameter.

Despite this disadvantage the Telsa battery cost, power density, cost per kwh, peak power, and longevity are unmatched. Especially as measure by real people driving real cars on real roads.

So sure in theory batteries with more surface area would have greater package efficiencies. So far nobody has managed to.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by akira2501 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:36PM (#18296649)
> So sure in theory batteries with more surface area would have greater package efficiencies.

There's way more to a battery than just density; however, one of the things that needs to be managed is the heat generated during charging. There might be a case to be made for slightly suboptimal packaging strategies if it makes cooling all those cells that much easier.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by rconti on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:12PM (#18296924)
Yeah, this really strikes me as a forest for the trees kind of situation. Sometimes it pays to engineer things to death, other times you need to step back and see the whole picture; how important is packaging for efficiency vs cooling vs manufacturing speed, etc.

Automakers putting battery packs in the trunk of their cars are complaining about battery size.

Is anyone complaining the floor on a Tesla is too thick and compromises interior space? Of course not.

The packaging probably DOES add a not-insignificant amount to the total weight of the pack vs an ideal battery of some custom design. But again, you have to weigh (ha!) all of the factors.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by Gibbon1 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:41PM (#18297090)
I read an article that made the case that lithium of batteries are sensitive to the direction of the heat gradient. Tried looking, can't find it. But the upshot was you want the gradient parallel to the electrode layers not perpendicular. Which means you want to remove the heat from the ends of the cell.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by ecpottinger on Thursday October 25, 2018 @01:47AM (#18298762)
I can't find it either, but I remember reading it.

However, http://jes.ecsdl.org/content/163/9/A1846.full points out some of the details.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by Gibbon1 on Thursday October 25, 2018 @05:46AM (#18299665)
That actually I think is what I was looking for.

Money quote: For automotive applications where 80% capacity is considered end-of-life, using tab cooling rather than surface cooling would therefore be equivalent to extending the lifetime of a pack by 3 times, or reducing the lifetime cost by 66%.

Meaning battery packs that last not 150,000 miles, but 450,000 miles.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by mavhc on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:12PM (#18296918)
Don't most other EVs use flat pouch cell batteries?
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by greglindahl on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:28PM (#18297021)
I think GM switched from pouch cells to cylindrical cells between the Volt and Bolt. The Leaf still uses a flat pouch. In the US, the Bolt and Leaf are the only other BEVs with significant sales.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by simonebrunozzi on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:17PM (#18297303)
Right! Lots more details here (and good comparison of the two): https://www.dnkpower.com/teslas-mass-production-21700-batter...
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by marricks on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:16PM (#18296947)
Is that comment anything but FUD?

They are able to make the cheapest batteries for cars and have seemed to be pretty successful...

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by gamblor956 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:03PM (#18297228)
Panasonic makes the battery cells...Tesla just assembles them together and integrates the cooling system.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by dannyw on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:22PM (#18296993)
The comment is a precise and accurate definition of the technology, I don’t see why you jump to “FUD”? Not everyone is trying to influence the stock price.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by hikari-boulders on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:38AM (#18301732)
I don't understand how "just maybe $1-2B more" is "no real increase in spending".
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by bsder on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:55PM (#18297178)
> Tesla could realistically hit 500,000 cars next year, almost 10% of total cars sold in America.

Is that really feasible? That's roughly BMW and Mercedes combined in the US.

It's really easy to forget on the West Coast of the US that BWM, Mercedes and the like are actually rare in the rest of the country.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by xienze on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:16PM (#18297298)
What? Define “rare”. If you’re in any reasonably-sized metro I’d be quite shocked if a day goes by where the average person doesn’t see a BMW or Mercedes.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by smogcutter on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:12PM (#18296445)
If the electric revolution requires a federal subsidy to compete then it has not, in fact, arrived.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:17PM (#18296483)
By that logic the gasoline engine has not yet arrived either.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by morsma on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:24PM (#18296543)
Does gasoline engines receive subsidies? I just bought a brand new ICE vehicle, and I'd sure like to know when my check arrives...
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by bjelkeman-again on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:28PM (#18296589)
Not the cars, but the fuel. “America spends over $20bn per year on fossil fuel subsidies. Abolish them” https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97...
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by cobookman on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:49PM (#18297149)
US also spends money on electricity subsidies.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_subsidies#United_States

"""

Renewable energy: $7.3 billion (45 percent)

Energy efficiency: $4.8 billion (29 percent)

Fossil fuels: $3.2 billion (20 percent)

Nuclear energy: $1.1 billion (7 percent)

"""

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by ecpottinger on Thursday October 25, 2018 @01:50AM (#18298780)
Good, get rid of them ALL! Then see which is truly better. Musk has clearly said he would prefer if all energy subsidies were canceled.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by nightski on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:36PM (#18296643)
If EV wins and they can no longer collect all that juicy tax revenue from gas - how are they going to afford to maintain infrastructure? They collect far more than 20bn in revenue from fuel taxes.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by zie on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:03PM (#18296849)
They will just move the tax to the Tesla Superchargers and the other electric charging stations. Alternatively they could tax it at the DMV level, like they already do to some extent. i.e. instead of a $100 registration fee every year, it will be a $500 registration fee.

I'm going to guess it will be a mix of both, but the govt(s) will be slow to do either, until they realize, too late, that they didn't meet their income goals on fuel taxes last year and suddenly have a shortfall in the budget :)

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by Reason077 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:42PM (#18297428)
Applying a tax at EV charge points wouldn't work well because most charging happens at home. It's difficult to distinguish electricity used to charge an EV from that used elsewhere in the home.

I suspect most states/countries will eventually adopt a combination of higher annual registration fees and mileage-based road user charges.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by zie on Sunday October 28, 2018 @04:05PM (#18322811)
Ah good point, make it based on usage.. your mileage counter says you went 100k miles this year, here is your 500k registration bill!

As for the charging @ home vs a supercharger(and the like) I agree with you, but the government is not known for always being wise or letting facts get in the way of something they want to do :) They understand a "Gas tax", so including EV chargers as part of the gas tax is easy to understand and easy to approve.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by philipkglass on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:25PM (#18297341)
Check odometer readings as a requirement of renewing the vehicle's registration. Assess a fee as a function of vehicle weight per axle and distance traveled. Sure, at the state level there will be some missed edge cases (what if I am registered in Washington but do most of my driving in Idaho?), but it should be close enough. It's basically fair and way less invasive/expensive than GPS-based tracking for road use.
Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by romwell on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @09:53PM (#18297995)
>what if I am registered in Washington but do most of my driving in Idaho?

Also it's likely to be evened out by someone who's registered in Idaho, but is driving in Washington. And in any case, the taxes can be adjusted to account for a fraction of cases like that.

This is also more fair than fuel taxes because low-efficiency vehicles aren't necessarily doing more road damage.

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by romwell on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:32PM (#18296618)
Good news, the check has already arrived!

Perhaps not for you, but it sure did[1]

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_Chapter_11_reor...

Re:Tesla Third Quarter 2018 Update [pdf] by kazinator on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:19PM (#18296509)
Not to mention the pneumatic tire on asphalt road.