News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by jsonne on Monday October 22, 2018 @11:53AM (#18275700)
I gave a talk at Denver startup week last year about the underlying profit incentives tied to fake news and how industry reforms in the way media companies do business could not only benefit the advertisers but also stop Fake news. At the end of the talk I had 3 people ask how they could make fake news to promote their startups. That this has turned into a booming industry surprises me 0%, though it is depressing.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by kradroy on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:23PM (#18278138)
8 years ago I used NLP to generate fake user profile bios for a social media company (not one you've heard of). The SEO/marketing guys went nuts over it and started using it for everything. It was super effective and they had the money to scale it. Eventually Panda came out and hosed the rankings on the blogs/domains they used it for.

Around the same time I discovered https://narrativescience.com/ and read about how they accomplished the same task. It was essentially similar to what I had done - write tons of templates, like Mad Libs, and then algorithmically fill in the blanks. Mine sometimes generated nonsense (e.g. "I love Mozart! I saw him in concert last year."). But for our purposes, or rather the purposes the marketing people came up with, it didn't matter much.

I saw the list of Narrative Science's investors and noted that In-Q-Tel was on there. Then I asked myself why the CIA's R&D funding arm would want that. The answer was obvious - to generate misinformation to spread to adversary orgs/states. Drown the real message in a sea of lies and your foes will waste more resources trying to find the truth.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by tomjakubowski on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:45PM (#18278326)
This is a stab in the dark but the pattern fits: did the social media company no one has heard of happen to be TuneWiki?
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by acct1771 on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @04:18PM (#18287059)
Hate to be the one to tell you this...they're doing it domestically (in their own country) as well.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by duxup on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:55PM (#18277255)
I went to a local tech event. A few folks gave talks about their products / services and their marketing. A few included people straight up talking about paying "influencers" or pod casters, or youtubers, to mention their product or service and so forth. Nobody seemed to note anything about disclosing that it was an advertisement or not.

I liked to think that maybe they just assumed the influencer was going to mention it was paid or everyone understood that was the case but me .... but it never was actually spoken about.

I couldn't help but wonder if the people paying for these services think that they are ever exposed to other companies doing the same? Do they care?

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by TomMarius on Monday October 22, 2018 @03:16PM (#18277445)
> I liked to think that maybe they just assumed the influencer was going to mention it was paid or everyone understood that was the case but me .... but it never was actually spoken about.

All major social media (Instagram, Youtube, ...) require you to disclose any promotions. It's absolutely normal in "old" media. I think that it's assumed if the audience was composed of actual business people.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by FireBeyond on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:46PM (#18278340)
A lot of "influencers" (I hate that phrase so much) like to play the vague game.

"Thanks, Club Med, for a great week!"

and consider that "disclosing the paid nature of the item".

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by freehunter on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:43PM (#18278312)
I'm a local "influencer" [1] and am part of a local group of other influencers for the city I live in and marking a promotion as such just goes without saying. The FTC even has rules on influencer promotions [2]. I see a lot of sponsored posts from other bloggers and influencers I'm friends with and they're all marked as "#ad" or "#sponsored" or something along those lines.

No one is saying "I'm running an AdSense campaign but forgot to tell Google that they need to mark it as an advertisement!" It goes without saying. These people are professionals same as anyone else and know the rules of their trade same as anyone else.

[1] "influencer" meaning someone with a significant presence on social media, blogs, podcasts, YouTube, etc.

[2] https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/ftc...

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by adamnemecek on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:04PM (#18275813)
Can you recommend some material on this and how to design the incentives properly?
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by jsonne on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:20PM (#18275967)
Yeah let me try and find some good articles. As for my talk, the tl;dr is that the lack of inventory transparency by ad networks coupled with the way that the CPM pricing model is currently administered incentivizes a system where the only that matters is clicks and not context or outcomes. Fake news is an extreme example, but a less sinister one is the Buzzfeeds and Upworthys of the world.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by tyingq on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:22PM (#18278125)
It's been pretty pervasive in certain niches for a long time. Homeopathic health products, for example. You can find lots of ads disguised as news reports that are more than a decade old. Dr Oz has been slinging crap for a similar time period.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by whyaduck on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:58PM (#18276280)
My thought experiment for considering the moral limits of capitalism: If producing Soylent Green were legal and profitable, would there be actors willing to produce and sell it?

If you answer no, see: Philip Morris, Lockheed, Beretta, etc.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by smt88 on Monday October 22, 2018 @01:16PM (#18276439)
Coca-Cola will likely kill more people than guns and organized crime, honestly. But I see your point.

There is a lot of evidence that organized crime is a substitute for opportunities in legitimate society, so that example is perhaps not applicable. The opioid crisis caused by US pharma may be a bigger and better example.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by notatcomputer68 on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:58PM (#18277284)
Organized crime is a huge problem. Like just take Mexico. Really poor and that's because of organized crime. If they were richer they could probably save a lot of lives. I think that's a bigger factor than the number of people shot dead.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by whyaduck on Monday October 22, 2018 @01:51PM (#18276728)
"Organized crime" is an exceptionally poor example since the premise involves the legality of the activity/product. Edited. Regarding Coca-Cola vs guns - the list wasn't comprehensive :).
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by castlecrasher2 on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:41PM (#18277128)
I agree with you, people can do all kinds of terrible things especially for the sake of profit. I believe comparing defense contractors and firearms manufacturers with eating people could be considered disingenuous, however.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by paulddraper on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:11PM (#18276889)
I suspect you are being downvoted for comparing secretive cannibalism to security/defense.

But yes, supply will provide every legal thing in demand. Indeed, that is how the invisible hand is "supposed" to work.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by whyaduck on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:26PM (#18277002)
Lockheed's involved in the maintenance (and previously, manufacture) of thermonuclear weapons. I'm pretty comfortable with my comparison.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by paulddraper on Monday October 22, 2018 @03:19PM (#18277484)
Thermonuclear weapons also have been the single most effective peacekeeping tool in the history of the world.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by whyaduck on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:23PM (#18278133)
That's a remarkably confident statement that's completely unprovable.

I could just as easily posit easy international travel, world trade, mass media, democracy, and many other things as more effective than h-bombs for bringing about the relative peace of the late 20th/early 21st century.

Those particular things have the added benefit that they generally don't risk the side-effect of world annihilation.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by paulddraper on Monday October 22, 2018 @06:59PM (#18279326)
> completely unprovable

Yes, it's challenging to answer with certainty.

Though "easy international travel, world trade, mass media, democracy, etc." were not invented at almost the precise moment that all-out large scale wars ("world wars") on Earth ended.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by canhascodez on Monday October 22, 2018 @10:36PM (#18280331)
The world came pretty close to large-scale nuclear war, actually. I'm not sure why you think that's no longer possible.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by justtopost on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @01:35AM (#18280960)
So you are upset we won ww2 and think they are responsible somehow? Whats your reasoning?
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by whyaduck on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @06:34AM (#18282216)
Blatant straw man.

There are moral implications to building weapons of annihilation in exchange for wealth.

Also, Lockheed's role in Manhattan Project era nuclear weapons development was non-existent. And the delivery aircraft was manufactured by Boeing.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by NeedMoreTea on Monday October 22, 2018 @01:50PM (#18276723)
You're being downvoted for some reason, but the point on morality and capitalism is sound.

For examples you might have been better choosing cases where the production rather than use by customers is problematic.

Radium paint and dials, asbestos, prior to 20th century regulations food and medicine fraud and adulteration so endemic that finding just the correct product was almost impossible. Which is what led those regulations in the first place.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by whyaduck on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:02PM (#18276824)
Allowing businesses to divorce themselves from responsibility for the effects of what they produce, regardless of consumer choice, is too easy. I have no idea what the equivalent of "Saturday morning cartoons" is today, but 20 years ago, that slot was filled with commercials for sugary foods, targeted at children. Now we have payday loans, "buy here pay here" and a host of other services that capitalize on unsophisticated consumers in precarious economic conditions.

Capitalism is what it is - an utterly amoral engine of profit. Without regulation and legal frameworks it will create slaves, destroy the environment, kill and maim people - there's almost no limit.

What the OP's anecdote illustrates is that there's also a deep cultural issue at play.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by tareqak on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:35PM (#18278255)
What if my business is the one of informing people of the possible risks their neighbors or other inhabitants of their nations pose to them?
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by utternerd on Monday October 22, 2018 @03:59PM (#18277875)
Free Markets aren't amoral at all, if I produce something of value and we swap value, I fail to see how that is amoral. In fact, preventing that transaction is amoral. Slavery itself was amoral, and codified and enforced by the state.

Many in the South abhorred slavery and segregation, but had no choice but to follow the law.

Killing and maiming people has been a State activity since they've existed. It's one of the things they're very efficient at.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by fzeroracer on Monday October 22, 2018 @08:49PM (#18279927)
This is some absolutely disgusting historical revisionism with regards to how the south treated slavery.

Make no mistake, Slavery was an intended feature. Not a bug, nor a result of a state gone wild. It was considered part of their economy and part of their free market.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by krastanov on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:09PM (#18278000)
I think you confused the words "amoral" and "immoral". OP was talking about "amoral" - lack of concern about moral principles. You seem to be talking about "immoral" - actively breaking moral principles.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by NeedMoreTea on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:09PM (#18278002)
Wow. Laws which were put in place by plantation and slave owners wishing to preserve the profit and status quo they created. They controlled most of the machinery of government as well as their little plantation.

Slavery was only ended at the insistence of laws put in place by the state.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by forapurpose on Monday October 22, 2018 @03:07PM (#18277358)
Like other commenters, I think this thought experiment goes much too far. On the other hand, many companies worked with the Nazis, work with the Saudis, Russians, and many others today, and sell all sorts of things to oppressive governments including the tools of oppression (such as those selling censorship and hacking tools to various dictatorships[0]). If the U.S. became an authoritarian dictatorship, I don't doubt that many companies would do business with the dictator too.

But I'd like to examine it with more nuance: Does it vary across time or across place? Is it different than the culture of the people from which the company emerged (e.g., how do private American citizens behave differently than large American companies)? Most importantly, on what factors does good and bad corporate behavior depend? My guess is that some of this research has been done - I'd love some pointers to it.

[0] A recent headline: https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-israel...

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by whyaduck on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:26PM (#18278164)
Capitalism is capitalism. It's limited by laws and culture. In the US, that means it's limited by laws - Wall Street doesn't care about culture.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by mattferderer on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:06PM (#18275844)
Is your talk or similar online anywhere?
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by jsonne on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:17PM (#18275941)
Unfortunately, I don't believe it was recorded. That said I've been submitting it to some local TedXs so hopefully, I can get a recording in the near future.
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by guachesuedehack on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:34PM (#18276076)
Would you happen to have a slides or transcripts then ?
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by marmadukester39 on Monday October 22, 2018 @07:36PM (#18279546)
I’d love to see/read that talk. Any way to get hold of it?
Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by honestlyidk on Monday October 22, 2018 @02:43PM (#18277154)
Is this something that requires government oversight or is it just a business plan/strategy. If the latter then the free market should tell you that your plan is right or wrong. If it requires government overshight I would say its inherently flawed. "Fake news" isnt a problem the problem is a lazy populace that take any word for granted as long as the production value is good enough.

Fake news is how free speech is supposed to work. People get to say what they want and the populace decides for themselves what is right or wrong. Liable and slander are still in effect.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by kartan on Monday October 22, 2018 @03:04PM (#18277335)
> Fake news is how free speech is supposed to work.

I can't agree with your statement. Game news is the contrary of what free speach stands for. Free speach is about being able to express your opinions. Fake news are intentionally misleading and hurt other people's well-being.

> Fake news" isnt a problem the problem is a lazy populace that take any word for granted as long as the production value is good enough.

Blame the victim. If you cheat me, it is my fault to not see thru your lie, if you rob me it's my fault for not being more vigilant.

If I lie about my products, or about other things for economical gain. Shouldn't the state make sure that I'm punished for that? Should not be the same case that for breaking a contract?

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by Kalium on Monday October 22, 2018 @03:27PM (#18277557)
> Free speach is about being able to express your opinions. Fake news are intentionally misleading and hurt other people's well-being.

As fake news is a form of expression, how do you propose to draw a meaningful distinction between protected speech and speech that may hurt the well-being of others? Especially one that does not risk chilling effects or becoming prior restraint, and is thus compatible with freedom of speech.

Re:Fake news ‘as a service’ booming among cybercrooks by utternerd on Monday October 22, 2018 @03:34PM (#18277635)
I wonder if we'll look back at the Bloomberg "chip implant" story as fake news, and if that's the case, can you imagine the police breaking into their offices with a warrant because of it?

Fraud is one thing, but hiring some e-celeb to pitch your product isn't something we need jack-booted thugs kicking in doors for. We don't even have an objective definition of "fake news", and you'll never convince me the State should be the one defining or enforcing that.