News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by garyfirestorm on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:18AM (#18212984)
Sure. First hold Equifax accountable, then we'll talk about Google.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by Waterluvian on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:29AM (#18213025)
Half the job of a politician is to get re-elected. This is part of that half. There's outrage and standing up for the people against a big company. Someone will be dragged before Congress and get embarrassed publically. And then we move on.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by DecayingOrganic on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:47AM (#18213108)
This reminded me of a story:

In an op-ed promoting campaign finance reform, the Oracle of Omaha, Warren Buffett, proposed raising the limit on individual contributions from $1,000 to $5,000 and banning all other contributions. No corporate money, no union money, no soft money. It sounds great, except that it would never pass.

Campaign finance reform is so hard to pass because the incumbent legislators who have to approve it are the ones who have the most to lose. Their advantage in fundraising is what gives them job security. How do you get people to do something that is against their interest? Put them in what is known as the prisoners’ dilemma. According to Buffett:

Well, just suppose some eccentric billionaire (not me, not me!) made the following offer: If the bill was defeated, this person—the E.B.—would donate $1 billion in an allowable manner (soft money makes all possible) to the political party that had delivered the most votes to getting it passed. Given this diabolical application of game theory, the bill would sail through Congress and thus cost our E.B. nothing (establishing him as not so eccentric after all).

Consider your options as a Democratic legislator. If you think that the Republicans will support the bill and you work to defeat it, then if you are successful, you will have delivered $1 billion to the Republicans, thereby handing them the resources to dominate for the next decade. Thus there is no gain in opposing the bill if the Republicans are supporting it. Now, if the Republicans are against it and you support it, then you have the chance of making $1 billion.

Thus whatever the Republicans do, the Democrats should support the bill. Of course, the same logic applies to the Republicans. They should support the bill no matter what the Democrats do. In the end, both parties support the bill, and our billionaire gets his proposal for free. As a bonus, Buffett notes that the very effectiveness of his plan “would highlight the absurdity of claims that money doesn’t influence Congressional votes.”

This situation is called a prisoners’ dilemma because both sides are led to take an action that is against their mutual interest. In the classic version of the prisoners’ dilemma, the police are separately interrogating two suspects. Each is given an incentive to be the first to confess and a much harsher sentence if he holds out while the other confesses. Thus each finds it advantageous to confess, though they would both do better if each kept quiet.

From the book The Art of Strategy. Great book.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:59AM (#18213187)
> How do you get people to do something that is against their interest?

You remove them from the system. This is why we have a process through which the states can amend the Constitution.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by rasteau on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:50AM (#18213466)
The prisoner's dilemma hinges on lack of communication between the prisoners. In the original scenario, communicating prisoners would both choose to stay silent. In the above scenario, communicating politicians would choose to never let the bill out of committee.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:58AM (#18213502)
> communicating politicians would choose to never let the bill out of committee

This presumes every politician is equally dependent on outside financing. Self-financed and small-donation financed politicians would be politically incentivized to bunch together and knock the legs out from under the competition's money machine.

Politics is complicated. Condemning campaign finance reform is premature. (Saying it's a tough fight would be accurate.)

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by Waterluvian on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:52AM (#18213139)
Wow. That sounds both brilliant and diabolical. But what stops politicians from flipping the switch again? Just that they have large coffers? Somehow I'm not convinced any amount of money would satisfy them.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:54AM (#18213152)
> This is part of that half

The other half, selling proposed legislation to one's own (and one's colleagues') constituents, involves the same process.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by HillaryBriss on Sunday October 14, 2018 @12:12PM (#18213564)
whether rightly or wrongly, this is an East Coast Democrat taking a swipe at one of California's most important tax revenue sources. but California is the Democratic Party's heartland.

i'm not trying to make a political statement here, just an observation that the Democratic party is of two minds when it comes to tech nowadays. it didn't used to be this way. further evidence of an emerging political realignment.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by Waterluvian on Sunday October 14, 2018 @12:37PM (#18213710)
May also be evidence of the problem of only having two parties. Surely there's many valid left wing positions worthy of sparring in the political arena.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by paulcole on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:54AM (#18213151)
The only job of a politician is to get elected.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:52AM (#18213132)
> First hold Equifax accountable, then we'll talk about Google

They're both screw-ups. If someone breaks into your house, we don't say "first let's solve peace in the Middle East; then we'll talk about your house."

Something being second (or further down the list) doesn't mean it should be ignored. It's just another reason to look at the issue.

Google is more politically vulnerable than Equifax because more people know what it is. That makes it a better whipping boy for getting public support behind any resulting legislation.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by darawk on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:54AM (#18213148)
What Google did isn't even a scandal. The whole story is "Google fixes security bug". Companies fix bugs all the time without notifying anyone. This is the silliest non-story.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:56AM (#18213167)
> What Google did isn't even a scandal

There is a case to be made that tech companies hoarding sensitive data should have heightened disclosure requirements around confirmed and potential breaches. It doesn't have to be a public process. But maybe there should be some process.

Regarding "it's just a bug," I personally disagree. A bug that takes down the video player is different from a bug that could expose data. ("Could expose" isn't language we like to use in technology, but the law is fine with such ambiguity.)

Analogy: we don't wait for bridges to fail before giving a damn about the cracks. Google et al have never been treated as critical infrastructure. This is a discussion about whether that should change.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday October 14, 2018 @12:00PM (#18213516)
There's a case to be made, but it's not a good one. Under the proposal you're making, there would be a non-stop firehose of "potential breach" disclosures from every major company. It would provide zero value to the public, who would quickly become inured to such reports. And it would significantly increase the friction involved in doing business.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 14, 2018 @03:41PM (#18214807)
> the public...would quickly become inured to such reports

Who said mandatory public notices? There are lots of options between staying silent and broadcasting every bug.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday October 14, 2018 @04:13PM (#18215024)
I've seen your response to this effect in another branch of this thread. Your suggestions there seemed pretty half-baked and none of them seemed like they would solve any real extant problem.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by Klathmon on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:33AM (#18213370)
We need to stop using analogies with hardware. Software is fundamentally different and they don't apply in a lot of cases. And in my opinion this is one of them.

While I agree that not all bugs are the same level of severity, if there is no evidence of abuse of a bug, and it has been fixed, I see no reason to have them disclose it in any way. It would be akin to forcing companies to disclose when they repremand an employee, or when they change an internal HR process to avoid interpersonal problems.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by TangoTrotFox on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:39AM (#18213406)
Google is not saying there is no evidence that user information was accessed by third parties. They are claiming that they have no idea and supposedly were not logging access to privileged information. This seems highly questionable. And if this passes for acceptable, it creates a significant incentive for all companies to do away with logging as suddenly they can just claim ignorance on everything.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by asdfasgasdgasdg on Sunday October 14, 2018 @12:07PM (#18213544)
Actually that's exactly what Google has said. Note that this is different from saying there's positive evidence that no user data was accessed.

Oh, and are we going to be mad at Google for purging logs now? I thought our hobby horse was Google retaining unneeded logs, but I guess it's even more fun to be mad at them for both so we can be mad no matter what they do.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by TangoTrotFox on Sunday October 14, 2018 @01:20PM (#18213957)
Google is relentless in collecting data on everybody and everything. Until suddenly collecting data could possibly incriminate them in an action, at which point they suddenly claim to lack any data whatsoever. Occam's razor would indicate that Google is being less than truthful.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by corndoge on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:35AM (#18213383)
Yes, it's bizarre how the media has siezed on the passive mention of a bug patched in a blog post about Google+ that revealed basically no information of value and turned it into a story. I suppose it's just a reminder how little the media, public and of course the gov't understand this industry. Google certainly thought of it as a non issue or they wouldn't have made it an anecdote...
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by kurthr on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:03AM (#18213219)
One is a known breach/leak which produced demonstrable harm. The other is a bug that can't be shown not to have been used past the stored logging.

One is the known burglary of your hotel room with your items for sale online. The other hotel used locks that could be bypassed, but only has security footage saved for the last month to show you weren't robbed then.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by mirceal on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:48AM (#18213457)
Not a big Google fan (actually actively minimizing Google products use) but I do not agree with you. Having your SSN/all details about your credit history exposed is way way worse than having your google account compromised. People know what a credit bureau is as good or better than what google is. There should be real, measurable consequences to the Equifax leak (as in they should no longer be allowed to operate). As far as Google goes and how they choose to handle this: I for one think they should have closed the security hole, keep monitoring it and kill the service separately after a while. It does not look good for them that they did it in one go, but at the end of the day, you are free not use google.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:56AM (#18213490)
> Having your SSN/all details about your credit history exposed is way way worse than having your google account compromised

I'm not disagreeing with you. I'm just saying these are both examples of privately-owned American digital infrastructure being vulnerable. In one case, we have evidence of a breach. In the other, we do not.

Taken together, these cases don't argue against each other. They argue together. That's why this is getting Congressional attention. The "how dare they ask these questions" tone on this thread, while understandable given how most of us earn our keep, is a bit off the mark.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by mirceal on Sunday October 14, 2018 @03:26PM (#18214663)
Yes and no. When it comes to Google I have a choice. When it comes to credit I do not.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by loceng on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:57AM (#18213174)
Equifax is arguably a more serious breach, with more obvious problems in security - complete lack of forethought in security.
Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by UncleEntity on Sunday October 14, 2018 @11:57AM (#18213494)
> Sure. First hold Equifax accountable, then we'll talk about Google.

Nah, first hold OPM accountable then we'll talk about the private sector.

Re:US senator urges investigation into Google+ bug ‘coverup’ by mothers on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:52AM (#18213133)
Please stop. Whataboutism is not helpful.