News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by electrograv on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:37PM (#18202618)
> There are no secrets to weight loss. Eat fewer calories than you burn. It doesn't matter if that involves keto, or vegan, or one meal a day. Thyroid problems also don't change physics.

That's like saying "There are no secrets to space flight: For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. It doesn't matter if that involves Hydrogen, Hydrazine, or just big tubs of water -- throw them one way, and you'll move the opposite. Your choice of fuel doesn't change physics."

Of course fundamental physics laws hold. But some fuels and systems of using those fuels are more effective than others.

When it comes to diet, different foods and eating patterns do have different effects on our endocrine system, and that does affect how viably we can sustain ourselves on less calories. Different foods will also have different proportions that are retained vs passed the same day.

Unless you also capture ALL your own human waste, and measure it in a 'bomb calorimeter', counting calories (intake only) is not nearly as useful as you seem to think. If you disagree, drink 2000 calories of olive oil every day and eat nothing else, then come back after a year and tell me that calories are all that matter :) Disclaimer: Don't actually do that, because you would starve to death.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by goostavos on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:04PM (#18202853)
I always see this response in these threads and get a little frustrated. I feel like it purposefully misses the forest for the trees a bit.

Sure, at a super granular level, different foods affect you differently, trigger different biological responses, etc.. etc.. but if you zoom out, the details just don't matter. If you're under calories, the weight will come off.

Nobody is suggesting to "drink olive oil." you can keep you normal diet, just eat less of it, and magic will happen.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by base698 on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:18PM (#18202970)
If you eat a 16 to 20 oz ribeye (1200 calories) in the morning you won't want to eat until at least dinner time. If you eat 3 donuts (1200 calories), you'll be ravenous by noon. What you eat effects when you want to eat and how much dramatically. Why run against a headwind?
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by goostavos on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:31PM (#18203088)
Oh boy, I regret commenting in this thread.

I feel like people keep either inventing things to argue against (olive oil) or bringing up scenarios that are purposefully missing the overall point of what people are actually saying.

Again, sure, if you zoom in, eating donuts is probably a bad strategy because you'll be hungry again, and thus eat more calories. But in the grand scheme of things, you CAN eat a donut if you remain below you calories. That is all people are saying. Nothing more. Nothing less.

fwiw, we weight lifters regularly put this into practice. Bulking? add more food. Cutting? less food.

Yes, there are details (gotta hit those macros!), but overall, the strategy boils down to calories in/out.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by jdminhbg on Friday October 12, 2018 @04:59PM (#18204678)
This is basically the equivalent of the "why does it matter what programming language you pick as long as it's Turing complete, which means you can do anything with it" argument. Losing weight by eating a donut and starving yourself is like writing a web application in brainfuck.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by zbentley on Friday October 12, 2018 @10:44PM (#18206101)
Not at all. It's like saying "it doesn't matter what programming language you pick, the computer is still only going to execute the code you told it to".

Neither the GP, nor the original root of this thread are proposing that food choices are automatic, obvious, or don't have bearing on your weight/happiness/whatever; they're saying that food quantities (in calories) are the primary determinant of how much you weigh.

That's it. Narrow ruling, specific point; no "why don't you just"-ism or anything of the sort--or if it's there, I'm not seeing it.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by jpindar on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:04PM (#18203841)
OK, OK, you're just better than us mere humans. We still experience hunger. And we don't like it. And being dumb animals, our behavior is influenced by that.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by amanaplanacanal on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:51PM (#18203244)
You say that like measuring calories in/out is an easy thing to do :-) For most people it absolutely is not, on either end of that.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by electrograv on Friday October 12, 2018 @02:15PM (#18203449)
Case in point: I’ve not met a single person who (in addition to measuring calorie intake) captures all the content deposited in their toilet, and measures it all every day in a bomb calorimeter :)
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by base698 on Sunday October 14, 2018 @10:13PM (#18216956)
You off-gas a lot of carbon when you exhale, so it's not a fair comparison.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by astura on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:46PM (#18203209)
I've found my body feels hungry simply based on when its used to eating, not what I've eaten earlier in the day. So if I eat breakfast every day, I start feeling hungry at breakfast time, if I eat lunch every day I start feeling hungry at lunch time. Prior food consumption doesn't matter, at least in my case.

I never ate breakfast as a kid, so I carried that habit into adulthood. I started eating breakfast once in a while at some point and that caused me to start feeling hungry in the morning. I shut that shit down right away, I don't need to add more food to my diet. Years later I gave up lunch, which I thought would be really difficult, since I always felt hungry at lunch time, but now I don't feel hungry at all during lunch time, because I'm used to not eating lunch.

YMMV, of course, that just has been my experience.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by lenocinor on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:11PM (#18203909)
As somebody who has eaten three normal-sized donuts in the morning (even early morning) a few times, I can tell you I've never been ravenous by noon, or even hungry. Maybe I'd start getting hungry around 3 or 4, which proves your point some, but certainly not by noon.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by L_Rahman on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:49PM (#18204194)
The question is how you eat fewer calories.

Eating fewer calories is a function of two things:

1. Reducing the number of points in the day in which you eat. 2. Changing the kind of food you eat at each of those points. 3. Changing the quantity of food you eat at each of those points.

From the amount of emotional energy or willpower necessary to do that, it seems like an intermittent fasting regimen is a technique that helps people do that.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by thebeefytaco on Friday October 12, 2018 @02:15PM (#18203446)
>Sure, at a super granular level, different foods affect you differently, trigger different biological responses, etc.. etc.. but if you zoom out, the details just don't matter. If you're under calories, the weight will come off.

Not true at all.

A gallon of gasoline has over 30,000 calories, yet you won't gain weight from drinking it,

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by goostavos on Friday October 12, 2018 @04:08PM (#18204341)
This is kind of exhibit A of willfully missing the point...
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by erichocean on Friday October 12, 2018 @05:54PM (#18204997)
[deleted]
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by projektir on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:45PM (#18202694)
People had stable weight without any special knowledge for most of human history. It's something we generally should know how to do automatically. It's very strange to compare it to spaceflight, as if we're only just now discovering how to do it. This just goes back to OP's point. There's a lot of energy being spent on making weight gain and loss be some mysterious, inscrutable thing. Now we're comparing it to space flight?
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by electrograv on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:49PM (#18202727)
The human body as a machine is actually quite a lot more complex than any current human invention. We're not even close to fully understanding everything. So, the analogy to space flight serves to show that it's as naive to imply there's no subtlety beyond "it doesn't matter what you eat, just the calorie count" as it would be to imply "it doesn't matter what rocket fuel you use".

> People had stable weight without any special knowledge for most of human history.

A lot of food products highly available today would be rather foreign to most of human history: artificially high sugar, high cab, low fat, snacks everywhere, etc.

These trick our taste and hunger systems into eating more of less quality foods than we would "naturally" if exposed only to less "engineered" foods, like pure meat and vegetables.

> It's something we generally should know how to do automatically.

Maybe we should, but clearly we do not. At least with modern processed foods that are optimized and designed to maximally stimulate our flavor response while compromising nutrition/health (generally).

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by pjc50 on Friday October 12, 2018 @03:24PM (#18204007)
People, especially kids, have routinely died of hunger and gastrointestinal diseases for most of history. Availability of calories was the limiting factor on human numbers until the industrial revolution. Most people did manual labour of some sort and walked everywhere. And when a few people had enough status to get all the calories they wanted and didn't exercise .. they got fat.

Really the problem goes in the other direction: now we have food from the "space age", and labour-saving automation, we can accidentally eat far more calories than we need.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by vlasev on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:46PM (#18203200)
Yes, you are right. And humans commonly engaged in a feasting/fasting cycle of having too much/too little food. But we've pretty much stopped doing the fasting stage. Look up "autophagy". It's a beneficial bodily process that only seems to happen within a long-enough fast.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by abduhl on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:58PM (#18202808)
I believe research has shown that humans have been malnourished throughout most of human history, which would indicate that we haven’t had a stable weight throughout history.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by auganov on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:57PM (#18202796)
No you wouldn't starve to death. If you didn't take a decent multivitamin you might develop life-threatening nutrient deficiencies, yes.

Also it's not as if we have a great understanding of how different foods influence our food consumption patterns.

I totally agree with ops point. Almost anytime the topic of nutrition comes up people are either unaware of the basic mechanics or have been convinced they're somehow fake [0].

[0] as in that there are huge differences in metabolic efficiency between foods or that people's BMRs usually differ greatly.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by awakeasleep on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:21PM (#18202999)
You and the other poster are disagreeing before removing significant ambiguity in your claims.

If someone eats 2k of olive oil by drinking one teaspoon every 30 minutes, their body will be able to digest a significant portion of those calories.

If someone drinks the whole cup at once, then they're going to have diarrhea without absorbing much at all.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by electrograv on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:58PM (#18202805)
> No you wouldn't starve to death. If you didn't take a decent multivitamin you might develop life-threatening nutrient deficiencies, yes.

You're claiming that a human can viably survive their whole life by consuming a daily diet of:

    1. Olive Oil
    2. Multi-Vitimin
    3. Water
This seems extremely far-fetched. Do you have a source for this claim?
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by goostavos on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:07PM (#18202882)
Semi-related study from the 60s. Guy lived on water and multi-vitamins while his fat stores did their thing: provide energy.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2495396/pdf/pos...

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by electrograv on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:10PM (#18202914)
I'm so confused why people are posting this. I agree fasting is viable until you run out of fat reserves (that's what this study is showing).

My point was that the type of food your calories consist of does matter. If you do nothing but drink olive oil and multivitamins, you will lose a lot of weight and eventually starve to death, no matter how many calories you consume. The point is that the type of food you eat does matter to weight gain/loss (not only the calorie count), because the type of food affects how many of those calories you actually retain.

As far as I can see, this study provides no evidence (nor attempts to) that a diet consisting of nothing but olive oil can sustain your weight. I think it's quite well accepted that different kinds of food will be retained to differing degrees in your body (or put another way, different types of food will end up being passed through your system in differing percentages -- as well as with differing degrees of nutritional satisfaction per calorie ingested).

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by wang_li on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:37PM (#18203128)
Human fat is substantially more complex than olive oil. Also he survived on more than his fat. He also survived on his skin, some muscle tissue, organ tissues, etc. Research shows increased autophagy during fasts like the one described at your link. During a fast whole organ systems shrink as old senescent cells are destroyed and their nutrients recycled.

The oddest thing about reading the comments here is that people are dismissing the words of someone who has spent the better part of a decade in formal education in medicine, and a large part of his professional career focusing on weight management.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by auganov on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:05PM (#18202859)
Specifically olive oil might be tough, but I hope a year-long fast will convince you: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2495396/pdf/pos...
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by electrograv on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:07PM (#18202879)
The subject in that study lost 276 pounds over the year! If anything, doesn't that confirm what I'm claiming?

I'm not sure how you think this corroborates your claim that you can sustain your weight by drinking olive oil and water (+ multivitamin). In fact, I don't see anything remotely relevant to this in the study.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by auganov on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:10PM (#18202913)
Not sure what you mean? If he were to eat that well calculated amount of olive oil everyday his weight would stay constant.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by electrograv on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:16PM (#18202960)
I think we're misunderstanding each other. What I don't get is where you're getting the evidence for this claim:

> If he were to eat that well calculated amount of olive oil everyday his weight would stay constant.

A source for this is needed. The study you provided, as far as I can see, says nothing of this. You're just assuming it's true, and I don't understand how/why.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by auganov on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:22PM (#18203013)
That a gram of fat is roughly 9 calories? You seem to believe that at some amount of regular ingestion it will start getting processed differently? I'm not sure what kind of a paper you'd like, I don't think anyone will come up with specifically olive oil.

As per your other reply to the same link

  differing degrees of nutritional satisfaction per calorie ingested
Yes it's commonly thought to work that way, there are indeed differences - but they're tiny. I might try to dig up relevant papers, but as far as my memory goes, the difference was at best around 3% with certain kind of protein.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by thebeefytaco on Friday October 12, 2018 @02:16PM (#18203467)
Nah pretty sure that'd just give you massive diarrhea.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by amanaplanacanal on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:58PM (#18203305)
Wow! Interesting paper. It appears to be saying that he went over a year without any "essential" amino acid intake. I would not have thought that possible.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by ngngngng on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:19PM (#18202979)
> I'm so confused why people are posting this.

Replying here because I can't reply to where you posted this ^^

Everyone's posting it because you are wrong. A calorie is a calorie. If I eat 500 calories surplus a day, i'll gain ~1 pound a week.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by electrograv on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:19PM (#18202990)
> If I eat 500 calories surplus a day, i'll gain ~1 pound a week.

Not if you expel an excess 500 calories per day on the toilet. This is what would happen if you chug a glass of olive oil, for example -- your body won't digest it all, and the vast majority of it will pass straight through.

This is an extreme example, but I make it to demonstrate a point 'calorie couters' always seem to forget: You keep assuming that you retain 100% of the calories you ingest, minus what you burn. This is demonstrably incorrect.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by zbentley on Friday October 12, 2018 @10:50PM (#18206130)
Would some qualifiers help?

Like, "calorie count is the primary determinant of weight gain, given nearly all typical human eating habits"?

Or "calorie count is the primary determinant of weight gain assuming you don't deliberately bypass your digestive system (likely inflicting discomfort and/or harm on yourself in the process) by consuming diuretics or indigestible food combinations"?

Even in both of those cases, it seems like the general point is still pretty much intact.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by thebeefytaco on Friday October 12, 2018 @02:11PM (#18203418)
>Everyone's posting it because you are wrong. A calorie is a calorie. If I eat 500 calories surplus a day, i'll gain ~1 pound a week.

Bullshit. A calorie is an incredibly crude metric of energy when it comes to human metabolisms. Our stomachs are not furnaces.

Try eating 500 calories surplus of gasoline or wood.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by atomical on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:52PM (#18202757)
> When it comes to diet, different foods and eating patterns do have different effects on our endocrine system, and that does affect how viably we can sustain ourselves on less calories. Different foods will also have different proportions that are retained vs passed the same day.

People who care about this aren't interested in the secrets of the endocrine system. They are interested in how they can remain trim while eating rich food like meat and dairy. These folks like fasting because they can eat one large meal and get more stimulation from the food.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by darkerside on Friday October 12, 2018 @01:11PM (#18202921)
The premise you've presented fascinates me. I wonder what would be the impacts of a 2000 calorie olive oil diet. Is it truly a starvation diet (due to inability of the body to process those calories)? I generally agree with the "calories in, calories out" principles of weight management, but I could see this being a useful counterexample.
Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by parthdesai on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:47PM (#18202710)
If you break it down into carbs, fats and protein, calorie in calorie out model does wonders. OP is right, weight loss is hard work. Frankly, people want to believe that there is an alternate method because a lot of them are just lazy.

Also, it's easier to maintain weight than to loose/gain weight. So once you have lost that weight, it's much easier to be at that weight. Of course you lost a huge amount of weight in a short span, this won't be true.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by msiyer on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:54PM (#18202771)
For the majority, losing weight is not tough in theory. In practice, however, will-power causes most trouble. It is really easy.

Species-specific diet can do wonders in a very short time. I have tried it with my dogs and I am trying this on myself. I am seeing excellent results.

Re:Jason Fung explains why intermittent fasting diets work by bshoemaker on Friday October 12, 2018 @12:51PM (#18202745)
This comment has very little to do with the comment above it, which makes the point that weight is dictated by net calories, with very few exceptions.