News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The excruciating final hours of George Washington (2014) by nickodell on Sunday October 07, 2018 @05:54PM (#18162835)
>You do not think that established medical treatments generally improve outcomes?

That's not what the linked article claims. The linked article claims that there are specific procedures that do not help in specific situations, yet these procedures continue to be done in those situations.

This is totally compatible with the claim that medical care improves outcomes on average.

Re:The excruciating final hours of George Washington (2014) by simonh on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:52AM (#18165096)
I'm not quite clear what it is that you "don't think is really true", then.
Re:The excruciating final hours of George Washington (2014) by nickodell on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @02:52PM (#18178779)
I'm not the parent commenter. Ask him.

If you want to justify the claim, "future generations will look at modern medical procedure X and remark at how primitive and pointless X is," you don't need to show that all medical procedures are bunk.

Indeed, in Washington's time, not all medical procedures were bunk. Doctors helped people, sometimes. If doctors in Washinton's time never helped people, the average person would notice that, and stop calling for a doctor. Were some of those procedures harmful to patients? Sure, but not obviously so.