News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by alexandros on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @07:45PM (#18135776)
I would like to go on the record as saying that the big car companies of today, short of a miracle, are on track to meet the big mobile phone companies of the pre-iPhone era. Remember when Blackberry, Nokia, Motorola, Alcatel, Sony seemed unassailable?
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by kllrnohj on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:15PM (#18136284)
Both Audi & Jaguar are looking on track to, on their first attempts, quite soundly beat Tesla at the electric SUV game. Similar price, similar range, and vastly better quality.

And really if you think about it that shouldn't be surprising. The big car companies today don't need a miracle at all. They are in a pretty good spot. They know how to do all the really hard stuff about building a car (the actual manufacturing & quality control stuff - the things Tesla is really bad at and struggling hard to figure out). They just need to do the easy part of putting in an EV powertrain. And they are already used to dealing with multiple powertrains for the same car, even.

Tesla took the risk to prove it out, but there's no reason to believe the big companies will be unable to change course on this. It's not at all like the pre-iPhone vs. post-iPhone where the entire UX interaction across the entire platform changed. This is all things considered a pretty small part of the car that's changed, and in pretty straightforward ways.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by illumin8 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:48PM (#18136746)
Sorry, I hate to break it to you, but Audi's E-tron is basically being used as an example of how far behind Tesla the rest of the industry is when it comes to efficiency and battery technology: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/09/18/ubs-says-audis-disappointing...
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by kllrnohj on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:55PM (#18141576)
$75k etron, est range 249 miles ( https://www.caranddriver.com/news/2019-audi-e-tron-quattro-e... )

$80k model x, est range 237 miles.

Tesla may have better battery tech at the end of the day, but it's very obviously not so far ahead. We're talking 10-20% differences at comparable price points even if Audi comes in under estimates.

And critically it's highly likely the Audi will have the build & interior quality of an $80k car, unlike the model x. Time will tell if people will ignore luxury to get a better 0-60 or not. Some certainly will, but most historically don't.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by mjamesaustin on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:56PM (#18136776)
To say Audi & Jaguar are on track to soundly beat Tesla is pretty presumptuous.

Tesla has a cost and experience advantage on batteries and electric powertrains. It becomes clear when you compare the stats of these competitors and realize they require 90kwh and 95kwh batteries to achieve the same range as a 75 kwh Model X.

That's not to mention the elephant in the room, which is fast charging. Tesla's supercharger network is leaps and bounds ahead of anyone else.

I'm hopeful Tesla will face some good competition from traditional automakers, but it's silly to act as if they've already been beat.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by kllrnohj on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:05PM (#18141659)
Yes, but it's very critical to remember that Tesla only has that electric powertrain. The rest of the car is pretty much a joke. The build quality of the $100k P100D Model S is worse than what you'd find on a $20k Civic. The interior is poor. Words like "minimalist" are often used to try and make it sound nicer than it is - it's cheap, low quality, and missing loads of features for its price bracket. General quality control is poor.

The Model S has a currently unique powertrain, but that's basically the only thing it has. Do you really think that can continue to be sufficient to move vehicles when competitors have a powertrain that's 80% the same as Tesla's, but an interior & build quality that's 10x Tesla's?

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by Latteland on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:57AM (#18137301)
It should be that Audi and Jaguar can make a nicer interior. But their dealers hate electric cars, because there's no maintenance. Tesla's biggest advantage is their worldwide network of charging stations that is available to everyone. They also have billions of miles of ev driving experience, input into the autopilot program.

The real engineering advantage tesla has is their proven battery heating and cooling technology - none of the other companies have that, and the recent cars have adopted some of tesla's ideas about heating and cooling but they don't have experience.

Finally, don't forget that there's a world wide shortage of electric car batteries. that's why tesla had to build the irritatingly named giga factory, because without it they couldn't build a lot of evs. and other companies can't either, without new battery production coming online.

Audi announced they wouldn't keep the audi ev at dealers, it's special order. I don't know if this is because dealers didn't want it or they didn't want to train them or what. gm dealers are said to not be enthusiastic about the bolt.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by jungturk on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:19PM (#18136595)
I wonder if they're behind the curve when it comes to the software that's become so central to the Tesla experience.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by SEJeff on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:56PM (#18136775)
Dealer network contractually prevents them from doing OTA updates for most things. I was told this at a Ford dealership (I've got a Fiesta and a Model 3) when I asked they they couldn't OTA update the old Sync voice nav vs putting in a USB drive to update some stuff with it recently.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by btilly on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:08PM (#18135936)
That's been obvious to me for about 20 years. Ever since I read the case study in The Innovator's Dilemma explaining that electric cars would take over around 2020.

If Elon should burn out and crash Tesla, it will still happen. Only instead of being Tesla delivering the death blow, it will be those electric golf carts growing up, turning into full cars, and wiping out traditional automakers.

Either way the underlying dynamic is the same. As batteries become good and cheap enough for mass cars, there is an opportunity for upstarts who only do electric to take on gas cars.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by threeseed on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:26PM (#18136025)
> there is an opportunity for upstarts who only do electric to take on gas cars.

Sure. But the mistake everyone makes is that the drive train technology is not what differentiates a car.

It's the brand, the design, quality of interior, availability etc. Those are much harder for upstarts to get right as we've seen with Tesla.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by btilly on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:59PM (#18136200)
It is not that the drive train differentiates the car. It is that the drive train constrains possible electric cars to be poor fits for the existing mass market. Which provides a market opportunity for manufacturers that focus on what is possible with the technology now, regardless of how well it fits in current Detroit marketing plans.

By the time electric is capable of being used for comparable cars at comparable prices for established lines of cars for established auto companies, they will be up against entrants in electric cars that have lower margins and more experience. When existing car manufacturers try to switch over they will wind up offering an inferior car at a worse price than the upstarts. This is a story that has played out many times in technology, and it never goes well for the established industry giants.

It doesn't matter if the competitors are delivering sports cars or glorified golf carts. What matters is that traditional auto companies with traditional dealer networks will be unable to compete head to head when they become competitive with the mass market.

Everyone knows about Tesla. Go look at https://www.fastcompany.com/40517240/the-biggest-electric-ve... for a company approaching the problem from the low end. There are a dozen more where BYD came from. And other markets where competitors are developing.

There are many niches around the world for electric vehicles. They are filled with companies who are salivating at the juicy pork chop that is the US car market. Technology does not, yet, allow them to compete head to head in Detroit's main product categories. But when they finally can, established automakers won't stand a chance.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by threeseed on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:16PM (#18136576)
> they will wind up offering an inferior car at a worse price than the upstarts

Jaguar I-Pace. Mercedes EQC. BMW iX3.

Far superior to Tesla on all the metrics I mentioned before.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by r00fus on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:36AM (#18137235)
The I-Pace is just starting sales. The EQC is not yet released. You can barely reserve the iX3.

How are these even in the same ballpark as the Model S which has been out for 6 years and the Model 3 which has been selling in decent volume for months?

We have very little data about how production models of these vehicles drive/maintenance/etc.

It will be nice to see some competition to Telsa's Model X but none of them really compete with a Model 3 right now (ie, under $50k base).

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by threeseed on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:43AM (#18137256)
You can barely reserve a Tesla and the long term quality/maintenance of the Tesla 3 isn't known either. And if you want to compare with the Model 3 then obviously we have the hybrids (Prius, Camry) and the electrics (Leaf, Bolt).

The point is that the idea that the established car manufacturers can't make a decent electric car is ridiculous. They can. In fact they look significantly better than a Tesla.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by r00fus on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:51PM (#18141546)
Many of my coworkers and friends have Model3s and they got them in weeks. Neither of the three you mention will receive shipments in 2018 if you order today.

Clearly they can make a car "better" than the Tesla (if you're leaving alone drivetrain), but they generally cost more.

That's the rub. Due to battery costs, any manufacturer not having a lock on battery supplies will either have to produce a vehicle that's weak on range/power or will cost more for the same range/power as a Tesla.

That's why plugin hybrids are all that the big manufacturers offer that honestly compete with Tesla's offerings. You need 1/5th the battery for a hybrid as you would a full EV.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by wmf on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:42PM (#18136104)
And I don't know if Tesla's drive train is that far ahead. Cars like the i-Pace have copied the dual-motor "skateboard" chassis, reasonable range, fast charging, etc. while including all the benefits of established car design/manufacturing.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by SEJeff on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:57PM (#18136781)
Anecdotally, this teardown report seems to refute your statement a bit:

https://cleantechnica.com/2018/02/19/tesla-model-3-stuns-ger...

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by threeseed on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:52PM (#18137049)
> was harshly critical of the build quality of the Model 3, calling it nearly as bad as a ’90s era Kia.

Also it's obviously much simpler and cleaner to build a car with just a touchscreen as its main interface. But the problem is its a nightmare for driving.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by SEJeff on Saturday October 06, 2018 @04:08PM (#18157007)
Have you ever driven one? I’ve got a Model 3 and find it a bit different but not too bad at all. I love that I can click the camera button and get a huge HD rear camera view. “Its a nightmare for driving” sounds an awful lot like you’ve never seriously driven one.

I was leery of the speedometer being in the center and not behind the steering wheel, but it isn’t all that different from diving a Mini, where the speedometer is a giant dial in the center console.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by nickik on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:40AM (#18138151)
Tesla has the most popular brand.

Availability will be a huge problem for traditional makers as well, as we have already seen with all their electric cars. Its not clear at all that they can simply massively scale electronic cars. People who say that as soon as VW makes a electric car they can just produce millions is wildly optimistic.

And quality of the interior is one of the easier things to improve.

I think range, acceleration, mobile phone integration and digital features, 'autopilot' are far more important.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by romed on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:10PM (#18135948)
The case for electric cars taking over by 2020 is looking pretty darn wrong at this point, isn’t it?
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by btilly on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:37PM (#18136082)
I said "around 2020", not "by 2020".

His prediction was based on projecting technology curves out and comparing to a set of requirements around acceleration (able to merge onto a highway), range, and cost. Such projections out decades in advance are naturally imprecise. I would have considered it a darned good prediction if the first mass market electric cars had arrived anywhere between 2015 and 2025.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by Obi_Juan_Kenobi on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:31PM (#18136050)
Sounds pretty good to me. It's not spot on, but maybe up to 5 years off? For being predicted 20 years ago, it's basically correct.

The majority of new vehicles being fully electric will happen pretty soon. The economics of this happening are incredibly compelling, essentially inevitable. I would put this occurring before 2025, but it's hard to say. If the Chinese keep up the heavy push toward electrification, it will probably be sooner. If not, then later.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by kllrnohj on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:31PM (#18136379)
> The majority of new vehicles being fully electric will happen pretty soon.

No? Not even remotely close to true. The Model 3 broke into the best selling sedan list. That's great, but it's not even in the same ballpark as an EV taking the top vehicle sales spot much less EVs being the majority of new vehicles.

Just to return to reality here there are more F150s sold in 6 months than Tesla has sold in its lifetime (450k; https://media.ford.com/content/dam/fordmedia/North%20America... vs. 300k; https://electrek.co/2018/02/14/tesla-delivered-300000th-vehi...)

In the first half of 2018 there were 8.5 million vehicles sold in the US alone. The Model 3's accomplishment of 40k vehicles is a rounding error.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by romed on Thursday October 04, 2018 @05:29PM (#18143836)
Right, it's amazing how blind people can be to reality. In Berkeley, the crunchiest of all possible american cities, the electric vehicle fleet is only 2% of cars on the road, and much less than 2% of all the vehicle-miles. Cars last for 20 years and in the last decade the median age of cars on the road has dramatically increased. For half the fleet to turn over you'd basically need for electrics to have 100% market share for many years.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by bas on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:02PM (#18136810)
Agreed. There is a reason Ford is exiting the sedan market in the US.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by ricardobeat on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:29PM (#18136039)
Is it? In Europe we’re seeing sales shoot up like a rocket. Model 3 deliveries haven’t even started yet. With the Hyundai Kona and Kia Niro the market will grow even more, and in 2020 VW will start flooding the market with EVs.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by jmisavage on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:03PM (#18136217)
My only concern with VW is whether they'll be able to produce those battery packs as fast as the cars. They're certainly ambitious, they want to make 100k the first year and the plant they're using can make 1,500 a day which sounds insane when you hear Tesla is only making 5,000 a month.

[1] https://www.vwvortex.com/news/volkswagen-news/d-electric-hat...

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by greglindahl on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:17PM (#18136296)
Tesla made 80,000 battery packs last quarter, and said that they peaked at 10,000 Model 3 battery packs in one week.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by pound on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:25PM (#18136338)
My next car would be electric. We just decided to wait couple of years to get more brands to choose from (now it's only model3 vs leaf vs bolt (and not sure about i3)) and I think many around us are in the same situation - right now it feels like it's past the very beginning of it being not on a hobbyist scale. So year or two - and that's exactly around 2020
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by Apocryphon on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:07PM (#18135928)
I would dispute that, in that big car companies have much deeper pockets, and thus have been readily spending on new tech, e.g. the big automaker acquisition of Cruise, Maven, Chariot. They seem more responsive to the changing nature of the industry.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by alexandros on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:26PM (#18136017)
Acquisitions are all well and good, but unfortunately, when an asteroid hits you, all the umbrellas in the world won't help. Tesla has been attacking the hard problems (like battery cost) for close to a decade while most others kept busy making fun of them.

When you see Tesla causing drops to the tune of 15% or even 20% to the sales of premium ICE car brands, and who knows how much more it will be in the next quarters, a hit this big and this sudden can be quite destabilizing to a company with a highly optimized supply chain. Also, these companies haven't delivered something truly new in decades, and to do so now, under the gun, would require not a product revamp, but a culture revamp. Never heard one of those being pulled off.

Innovation is hard, let's ask for government assistance: https://www.reuters.com/article/autoshow-paris-electric-sque...

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by revscat on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:09PM (#18136247)
I don’t think the big automakers — especially the Americans and Japanese — can switch gears, as it were. The reasons for this are discussed elsewhere in this thread, but thus far the EV models produced by the legacy manufacturers have been underadvertised, token vehicles. They are not shifting resources away from their current exclusive focus on ICEs, and there is no sign they ever will. Sure, they’ll do a press release. Or something like the Bolt that is lived by owners but forgotten by GM itself, who happily continues on basically the same as yesterday. They can’t change.

Maybe VW. Maybe. But GM, Ford, Toyota, Honda... I don’t see it. Toyota is still trying to make hydrogen a thing, ferchrissake. Meanwhile Tesla is eating the luxury segment alive.

If — and it’s a big if — Tesla can achieve profitability with the Model 3 and get their crossover SUV into production, they’ll own the world.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by tomp on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:26PM (#18136022)
> They seem more responsive to the changing nature of the industry.

Yet most of their responses so far are on paper - they will start producing electric cars, sometime in the future.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by stephengillie on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:04PM (#18136526)
Really this is like the start of digital cameras. Computer companies made the first digital cameras, then eventually camera companies made good digital cameras.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by illumin8 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:49PM (#18136751)
Are you sure about that? The best cameras nowadays seem to be made by computer companies (Apple, Samsung, Huawei, etc)
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by dingaling on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:01AM (#18137313)
Sony, Samsumg and Canon dominate the camera sensor market in that order of volume.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by stephengillie on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:25PM (#18136916)
I thought RED made the best camera today.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by nickik on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:37AM (#18138138)
While I agree that Tesla is in a good spot, I think you underestimate just how huge the car market is. Tesla would have to scale exponentially for a long time to even have chance to capture so much of the market.

And outside of Tesla there is not much, there is no electric car Android, specially outside of China.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by threeseed on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:24PM (#18136010)
There is no evidence of this at all.

The world is full of upstarts being crushed by large incumbents.

And don't remember we still have Microsoft, IBM, Intel, Amazon etc all still doing very well.