You have a single employer on one side, you need a single union on the other side to make negotiations fair, otherwise they just would just low ball each other to get more jobs.
The history of labor activism shows that workers only get big gains when they work together.
Unions were largely a victim of their own success, though — once a lot of their gains were codified into laws and regulations there wasn’t as much to fight for.
Of course, if the triopoly was enforced by statute, then a corrupt member could act with impunity knowing that it cannot loose too much of its power.
I love how this argument gets applied to unions but not to companies. Many companies have killed themselves through greed and short-term thinking, yet you are not arguing that something is wrong with corporate structure.
Ultimately every human organization is prone to screwing up - unions are not at all unique here - but in the US unions often get singled out as a boogey man that hurts the economy.
Corporations can sink themselves because they are granted self-determination. That's sort of fundamental, sans bailouts.
That said, I would be happy if we could tweak incentives to shift focus away from short term returns towards long term. Companies are not perfect either, and my omission was not meant to imply they were.
It's not necessarily a big deal. The workers can just go and get another job. It's the owners who are really crying.
It's not especially perverse for unions to be indifferent to the risk of sinking the company if the people they represent hold no stake in it.
Especially since the threats that this will happen from the owners will be overblown.
I guess it's like that "fairness experiment" where monkeys would rather deprive the other side of 8 berries than take 2.
If that were true, we wouldn't need unions in the first place.
The company going out of business is a problem for the employees and is obviously a risk, it's just not a big and existential risk like it is for the owners.
"So how do you create a CEO and Board that has the right amount of power? When CEO's and Boards are able to, & do, kill the host company through greed & short-term thinking, something is wrong with the structure".
I'd argue that a CEO running a company into the ground for their own selfish, short term gains is far worse than a union ruining a company, because at least when the latter occurs it's because a significant amount of the employees aren't being sufficiently paid, or are being subject to unsafe/inadequate conditions. That is far more important than a CEO getting a bonus.
How many times has this actually happened, and were they even the root cause or would the company have failed for some other reason anyway?
> Strikes have been used to resolve labor disputes, but if your goal is long term and meanful improvement to working conditions and remuneration, then the only times unions have ever achieved that is by restricting access to the profession.
Collective bargaining is how unions achieve long term and meaningful improvement to working conditions and renumeration.
> Salaries are determined by market forces, political influence will never be able to exert much pressure on the equilibrium.
This is just demonstrably untrue -- we've been in a bull market for almost a decade. Worker pay -- in contrast to company profits -- hasn't even kept up with inflation. Something is missing.
> The only time unions have truly succeeded in this is by limiting labor supply over the long term.
Do you have any citations for this? Any data?
Couldn't you say the same about corporations?
The results differ by sector. In some cases, this plurality allowed for classic “divide & rule” strategies from management; in others, it produced chaos because each union can (and will) call for strikes at different times with little or no coordination, or refuse to agree on deals that everyone else has accepted.
The best outcomes have been consistently obtained in companies and sectors where the plurality was reduced to one or two dominant unions. Some competition is good, but it significantly increases complexity in all related processes.
Agree with the idea, but in pracice every employee can just pack their baga and go to another other company. If enough employees do that, then companies sooner or later have to change, or remain with the worst of the workforce. There is monopoly on employment.
Maybe you don't live in America, or maybe you grew up with lots of privilege, but in reality, not a lot of people can do this. If you pack your bags and leave, you need to have some way to feed yourself, clothe yourself, and get health care, which is most likely provided by your employer.
The people who have the least ability to do these things without a job are also the ones who are most exploited.
Of course, universal health care and a universal income would solve these problems...
In my experience corruption sinks in on both sides when people can get away with putting in place policies to protect the status quo. When there are multiple options, and the same antitrust policies that are in place to prevent collusion between employers are also enforced to prevent “unionization of unions,” I believe that is when the individual worker actually wins.