News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by mahmud on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:01PM (#1812808)
Personally I see reddit more as a liability than a commercial asset.

The community is the loveliest on the internet, but also extremely self-conscious and suspicious of change, much less one dictated from the top. Whoever owns reddit will have to foot the development, support and hosting fees, while remaining subservient to a moody and very sophisticated user-base.

Better cash out and be a community hero.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by endtime on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:06PM (#1812826)
>The community is the loveliest on the internet

I hope you're being sarcastic. reddit's been a sordid mix of conspiracy theorists, political extremists, and 4chan users for the last year or two.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by mahmud on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:13PM (#1812863)
Reddit raises money for people in need. They might dabble in their fun kiddie pool subreddits, but they have consistently walked the walk when and where it matters.

Let me say that I have only yesterday signed up to reddit, for the first time, under my own name. And that I would happily go elsewhere for intelligent feedback. But if I was wronged by a bigger adversary (government, business, etc.) Reddit would be the first place to air my grievance.

Even in their most sordid humor, they're both clever and humane. I just get the feeling they're nice people. People post pictures of their kids, their pets, their hand-drawings, hobbies, even their own private parts (if you know where to look.) I think Reddit covers the whole spectrum of the human experience .. if all humans were charitable, fairly well educated, suburbanite, closet-Marxists with short attention span (which I emphatically identify with :-)

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by cookiecaper on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @06:58PM (#1813488)
Maybe you haven't noticed how reddit treats the users who espouse ideas they don't like. /r/atheism redditors have launched invasions on /r/christianity multiple times now, and go in and totally destroy threads that contained nothing especially provocative; they've downvoted all the Christian viewpoints and upvoted all the mocking viewpoints. I expect most other religious subreddits have encountered similar intimidation.

Even isolated within subreddits, it's hard to get someone who is at odds with the ideas of most of reddit's userbase to visit a friendly subreddit when they visit the main page and see a bunch of f-bombs, nsfw links, militant atheist and liberal content, etc. My parents, for instance, would be offended by something on the main page at almost any time you captured it. Things are better now that /r/atheism is off the front page, but it's still not good.

Reddit changes its logo site-wide to celebrate same-sex marriage victories. Any time the Salvation Army is mentioned on reddit 100 redditors jump to write about how the Salvation Army opposes pornography so nobody should ever donate to them. And so on.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by _delirium on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @07:47PM (#1813643)
Even isolated within subreddits, it's hard to get someone who is at odds with the ideas of most of reddit's userbase to visit a friendly subreddit when they visit the main page and see a bunch of f-bombs, nsfw links, militant atheist and liberal content, etc.

That's true of HN too, though, just in different political directions. There's a lot of polemical stuff that makes the front page, and especially a lot of fluff libertarian-partisan stuff, e.g. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1795577 . The comments often have a lot of militant-libertarian stuff too if the topic is politics/economics.

As someone who doesn't much like hardline socialism or hardline libertarianism, I don't really find reddit that much worse on this subject, especially considering its larger size. Mostly it's just skewed in the opposite direction.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by cookiecaper on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:41PM (#1813912)
I don't think it's the same thing here at all. Look at the item you posted -- there's a lot of agreement and disagreement going on, and both affirmative and negative viewpoints have good scores. The discussion is relatively civil and sensible. It's not that someone occasionally posts that kind of article, it's that all those articulately and civilly offering opposing viewpoints are considered enemies instead of enrichers, as they should be and at least relatively often are here on HN.

Also, I think on HN a story called "Socialism saved the miners" could have been front-paged and had a similar discussion. On reddit, if you post something that doesn't fit with their preconceptions against religion, capitalism, etc., all you can hope for is < -100 karma.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by jbooth on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:06PM (#1813834)
>Reddit changes its logo site-wide to celebrate same-sex marriage victories.

That and the porno thing are way more about age than ideology. Old democrats are against same-sex marriage and young republicans are more likely to be for it than most other deviations from the party line. Look at a graph of opinion on that issue over age sometime.

I suppose ideology is in there a little as far as secularism (!= atheism), but hey, it's the internet.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by cookiecaper on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:30PM (#1813887)
So is reddit intentionally trying to alienate potential older users? I see no reason to celebrate or mourn the success or failure of a given political issue site-wide like that. It just emphasizes the idea that reddit has a commonly-accepted set of political ideals and that if you don't agree, you shouldn't be there.

And redditors will definitely treat you that way. They usually don't care if your objection is well-reasoned or articulately expressed, they just instantly destroy anything vaguely pro-religion, pro-life, pro-traditional-marriage, etc.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by loewenskind on Thursday October 21, 2010 @03:52AM (#1814643)
This is not a given. When I do post on that site I very often contradict the hive mind (even on religious subjects on occasion) and usually get (to my surprise) positive karma from it. I've never gotten worse than -10 ever.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by jbooth on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:14PM (#1813995)
The people who are celebrating it would say it's not a political issue, it's a human rights issue.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by cookiecaper on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @11:07PM (#1814123)
That's nice, but they know that idea is not commonly held. The only reason to make a logo for it is to intentionally scare off/irritate people who disagree, further contributing to reddit's homogeneity.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by redthrowaway on Thursday October 21, 2010 @12:00AM (#1814227)
>That's nice, but they know that idea is not commonly held.

Only amongst those opposed to gay marriage. It is very much a human-rights issue for everyone I know, particularly those who are gay. As for the decisions reddit takes as a site (not the community), they are generally both popular with the community and the admins. Take, for example, the stance they took on running pro-prop 19 ads, or their decision not to run anti-gay marriage ads. The first was genuinely political, but it was also popular. The second was a matter of principle.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by v21 on Thursday October 21, 2010 @03:40AM (#1814621)
No it's not, why would they want to do that? The logo is to celebrate something they think ought to be celebrated. They're not afraid of having personalities and letting those show on the site. Given they're young, relatively liberal and techy, then they'll appear young, relatively liberal and techy. You also don't have to agree with them, as I'm sure they'd agree. It's a delicate line, having opinions and also moderating others opinions, but I think they're making a fair fist of it so far.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by lhnz on Thursday October 21, 2010 @06:29AM (#1814900)
You reckon they are intentionally trying to create a homogenous atmosphere? How do subreddits fit into this? I don't think that makes real sense.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by points on Thursday October 21, 2010 @07:41AM (#1815027)
the illusion of freedom...
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by jbooth on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @11:45PM (#1814192)
It will be, take another look at that graph over time. Miscegenation used to be a controversy, too.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by StavrosK on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:45PM (#1813788)
That's not really fair, though. /r/atheism is the atheist equivalent of Christian fundamentalists. If atheism is a religion like "not collecting stamps" is a hobby, /r/atheism wants everybody to stop collecting stamps.

Everyone who has been on reddit for a while knows to unsubscribe from /r/politics, /r/atheism and maybe /r/worldnews.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by pjscott on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:37PM (#1814057)
I'm sure part of it is the size. /r/atheism has over 94 thousand subscribers. In a group of people that large, there are inevitably going to be a bunch of super-assholes. The true measure of a subreddit is its ability to keep the assholes in check and denounce them when they rampage. A quick skim of a few threads suggests that /r/atheism is fairly average in that regard.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by cookiecaper on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:35PM (#1813900)
One would have to unsubscribe from almost every popular subreddit to avoid that kind of thing. IAmA is full of "I grew up in a Christian household where I was abused by being taught that religion is good, when I turned 24 I snapped out of it, AMA" or "I am a sex worker, AMA" or "I have sexual fantasies about gravy, AMA", and the comments are usually about what you'd expect; users congratulating each other for not being religious any more, etc., and if someone comes in and tries to defend it, just by virtue of defending a religious viewpoint, they are downvoted to oblivion.

The attitude prevails throughout almost every popular reddit.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by StavrosK on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:37PM (#1813905)
I have no idea where you're getting this from, it sounds like prejudice. To wit:

http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by cookiecaper on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:00PM (#1813951)
#3: I am a brothel keeper, AMA #13: Waitress at high-end strip club #15: "Evangelical pastor's kid". Inside: "I'm 27 now and agnostic bordering on atheist." and so on, that's just on the first page just right now.

Of course, it's not necessarily bad to have these come up sometimes. It's just the amazing frequency with which they do, the universally supportive attitude of reddit, and their extreme desire to lynch and denigrate anyone who violates their universal support.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by StavrosK on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:05PM (#1813966)
I don't understand why users shouldn't support someone of an unusual profession. Are they supposed to get all riled up because someone owns a brothel, or is a waiter in a strip club?

Hell, I remember a pedophile who recognised that his tendencies were harmful to children and had vowed never to act on them. Given that he can't change his condition, I think that was a brave and mature thing to do. While I obviously don't support pedophilia, I think that realizing that your desires can cause harm and restraining yourself from them is not something to condemn.

Apart from that, I find that it's really valuable to try and see things from someone's viewpoint, no matter who that person is. There have been many people doing IAmAs, and I find that critically deciding whether this person is someone to support or to condemn was eye-opening. Can you elaborate on why you find the community's support a bad thing?

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by cookiecaper on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:25PM (#1814024)
I don't find support of these people to be a bad thing. I find the homogeneity and cruel, almost-textually-violent reactions of redditors to non-homogenous thought to be the bad thing. Look for AMAs where the subject is positive to religion ("IAmA practicing Mormon", "IAmA Catholic priest") or opposed to same-sex marriage, etc., and see how those turn out.

reddit is extremely antagonistic toward people who they consider unenlightened. There is a culture of incivility. It's not a numbers game -- it doesn't matter for instance that a larger portion of reddit is irreligious than religious -- it's just a matter of human decency, courtesy, open-mindedness and humility, which are almost non-existent on reddit.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by StavrosK on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:32PM (#1814040)
I have seen quite a few religious IAmAs, and, as a rule, everyone was respectful. Reddit mostly has a problem with people who try to undermine rationality and critical thinking in the name of religion, not with religion itself. If you show me a post where redditors are being disrespectful to a (sane) IAmA-er, I will be very surprised.

In fact, I remember a recent post by a theologian, it had hundreds of comments and everyone (including the poster) loved it, it was very civilized and informative.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by rdmlx on Thursday October 21, 2010 @10:01AM (#1815357)
Do you remember the title or have the link? I'd be interested in reading this.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by StavrosK on Friday October 22, 2010 @12:17PM (#1820215)
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by loewenskind on Thursday October 21, 2010 @03:47AM (#1814636)
There are certain subreddits that really get out of control (e.g. /r/atheism). The thing about Reddit is that the base is so huge that I don't think there is anything you can say to describe the majority of them anymore. Pretty much anyone and everyone is represented to some degree.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by endtime on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:16PM (#1812873)
There are nice people on reddit, of course. You might be able to say that some subcommunity of reddit maximizes `lambda subcommunity: f(subcommunity.size) * g(subcommity.loveliness)` over all possible subcommunities of all community websites (and for some reasonable weighting functions f and g), but if you're generalizing to the entire reddit community then I can't help thinking you're mistaken.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by mahmud on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:23PM (#1812911)
If this was reddit, someone would take your pseudo-math prose and come up with a formal system in Coq. But the highest ranked comment would be about a cat with proper table manners.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by heed on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:02PM (#1813957)
No, some people on a website called reddit.com raised money for people in need. 'Reddit' isn't a person, it is a thing.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by jonursenbach on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:08PM (#1812835)
Reddit's community is dependent upon what subreddits you're part of.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by endtime on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:18PM (#1812881)
I agree. But surely "the [reddit] community" without qualifiers refers to the entire community, not some subset thereof.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by mkr-hn on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:06PM (#1813104)
It's a good place on average with a few loony subreddits.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by endtime on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:13PM (#1813137)
Well, if in "a few" you include most of the largest ones, including /r/reddit.com, /r/politics, and /r/worldnews.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by mkr-hn on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:31PM (#1813189)
Happens when any community gets big enough.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by sudont on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:19PM (#1813150)
Would you consider reddit analogous to a country, and the sub-reddits to states?

Can we raise the dixie flag of /r/circlejerk and rabble rouse for states rights to stupidity?

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by mkr-hn on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:29PM (#1813183)
I'm not going to defend the south broadly, but there are little pockets of sanity here.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by krakensden on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:37PM (#1812964)
You obviously haven't been to much of the internet then- it really is one of the better communities.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by rick888 on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @06:06PM (#1813308)
"You obviously haven't been to much of the internet then- it really is one of the better communities."

"better" is relative. To me, HN is one of the "better" communities. Reddit is comprised of 1% people that are actually smart, 20% kooks, 15% political nutjobs, and the rest are early 20-something pseudo-intellectuals that feel that anything against the US, religion, or corporations makes them more intelligent and witty in the eyes of the world. I also get the feeling that people there have very little experience beyond a keyboard in their parent's house.

When I look at any HN article, most of the comments are sane, well-articulated, and thought-out. It's quite refreshing, actually.

Reddit to communities is what Craigslist is for dating.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by redthrowaway on Thursday October 21, 2010 @05:54AM (#1814841)
I spend a considerable amount of time on reddit, and some on HN. What I would say is this: If I want a dry, knowledgeable discussion about a particular tech topic, I'll come to HN. If I want to laugh/cry/rage, I'll go to reddit. The SNR might be higher here, but there's far more wit there.

Both communities serve their purpose. HN is nice in that it is specifically not trying to be big. It seems that Paul Graham is trying quite hard to avoid an Eternal September-type scenario arising from the dilution of the community as it exists now. That's great, and I respect that. The flip side of that, however, is a lack of dynamism.

There's nothing unique about either site. I find the comments on HN to be generally more knowledgeable than those on r/technology, slightly better than r/programming, and about the same as r/netsec. When you get down to the smaller subreddits, the idiocy usually goes away.

>Reddit is comprised of 1% people that are actually smart, 20% kooks, 15% political nutjobs

I'll give you the last two, but I'd say you're off by an order of magnitude on the first one. That's a generalization of the site as a whole, mind you. Your figure might be entirely accurate for, say, r/pics.

>and the rest are early 20-something pseudo-intellectuals that feel that anything against the US, religion, or corporations makes them more intelligent and witty in the eyes of the world.

Again, depends on the subreddit. On r/politics, I'd say you're probably right. Many other subreddits would defy that description.

Check out:

http://www.reddit.com/r/DepthHub/

http://www.reddit.com/r/Foodforthought/

As I said before, r/tehcnology is hit and miss, but the smaller tech subreddits are good. I personally frequent r/netsec, and I often find good links and discussion at r/python, r/linux, and other tech subreddits.

You may find this article: http://www.amerika.org/technology/the-entropy-of-reddit/ vocalizes many of your issues with reddit. I don't agree with the author on everything, but some of his points are valid.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by rick888 on Thursday October 21, 2010 @12:18PM (#1816103)
"I'll give you the last two, but I'd say you're off by an order of magnitude on the first one. That's a generalization of the site as a whole, mind you. Your figure might be entirely accurate for, say, r/pics."

My figure is from every subreddit on the front page (without adding any of the specific ones you can add yourself). I could find conservative/republican subreddits, but that wouldn't represent the community as a whole either.

It's pretty obvious even from the link titles users have posted.

"As I said before, r/tehcnology is hit and miss, but the smaller tech subreddits are good. I personally frequent r/netsec, and I often find good links and discussion at r/python, r/linux, and other tech subreddits."

This also doesn't represent the community as a whole. These are small subreddits.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by redthrowaway on Thursday October 21, 2010 @02:50PM (#1816913)
Seriously, though, if you just remove pics (add pics2), funny (add humour), worldnews, atheism, politics, and maybe reddit.com, you'll tripple the quality of discussion you run into.

It's easy to classify the big subreddits as "Reddit", but that's just not the case. The "community as a whole" is an ephemeral thing. You can't really judge it by the tone on some of the, admittedly larger, subreddits.

Seriously, you say how much better the community at HN is, but you dismiss the subreddits I mentioned, many of which have more users than HN. HN itself was originally supposed to be a subreddit, but the admins wouldn't give Paul what he wanted. Reddit itself is more of an umbrella than a group.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by aerique on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:13PM (#1813705)
Sometimes the same articles get much better comments on Reddit than they do on HN. Also, for some reason, the Apple and Microsoft fanboys don't seem to be as rife there, or at least they're properly downvoted.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by mahmud on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:33PM (#1813759)
It's easy to point out fanboys we disagree with. A better mental tool might be reflecting upon yourself and finding out what you might be a fanboy of, what are you irrationally attached to that you will defend vehemently, even when at odds with reason?

Once you discover the object of your irrational affection, try to sympathize with those irrationally at odds with it (i.e. haters, detractors, bashers, the Other fanboy, etc.)

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by aerique on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:04PM (#1813961)
I'm totally zen, or Neutral Neutral if you will, and not attached to anything. Not even Common Lisp, Emacs and Linux... nope.

Seriously, there's a disproportionate amount of irrational pro-Apple and -Microsoft posts here on HN that get upvotes.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by loewenskind on Thursday October 21, 2010 @04:16AM (#1814695)
HN is smaller. When you have a forum of this size the members will be much closer to the ideals of the site (i.e. if it's about civil discourse then everyone will respect that, if it's about being a troll that's what you'll get). As the sites get larger you start getting closer to the average amount of kooks/idiots/assholes/etc. I can't think of a single site that got big and didn't have this.

Facebook is an interesting take on this by effectively blocking you from hearing much from people you don't wish to hear from.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by rhizome on Thursday October 21, 2010 @01:43AM (#1814426)
Oh, that is one of the most PKD things I've read in a long time!
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by ericflo on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:24PM (#1813739)
This whole notion that Reddit is one personality is ridiculous. Reddit has idiots, philanthropists, rapists, and startup founders. And those probably overlap.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by vaksel on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:09PM (#1812841)
I think he was talking more about all the feel good reddit stories...i.e. all the money they raised for all the different charities, having that girl who got bullied get a all you can buy day at a toy store etc.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by acgourley on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:08PM (#1812836)
If you consider the size of the community, it's relatively miraculous. But you're of course right in an absolute sense.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by MrFlibble on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @07:13PM (#1813539)
This is a key consideration. Reddit is pretty frakkin big and yet still remains relatively well balanced depending on your subreddits.

What I've been impressed with on many occasions is the community keeping in check the over-the-top commentators who are just being douches, regardless of which side of the debate they are on. The community really does moderate itself quite well considering its size.

If you hang out in r/wtf or some such, you kinda get what you would expect, but select your subreddits well and you can be part of some pretty interesting discussions and occasionally learn some really cool things. Reddit ftw in my opinion.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by mkr-hn on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:06PM (#1813101)
Only if you venture in to those subreddits. That's the nice thing about it. You can select which sections of the community appear on the top bar.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by davidmurphy on Thursday October 21, 2010 @05:41AM (#1814829)
I used to love Reddit, but lately I've gotten some abusive and hurtful replies to stuff I posted there. Definitely seen the ugly/shameful side of the internet.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by someone_here on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:07PM (#1812834)
Actually, Conde Nast is not footing any of the costs. Reddit is entirely self-sufficient.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by spez on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:22PM (#1812905)
Actually, if reddit is truly self-sufficient, it's a relatively new development. Reddit was bought four years ago, and repeatedly told to not worry about money for the first 2.5 of those years and was accordingly not self-sufficient.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by masklinn on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:21PM (#1812897)
As far as I know, this is incorrect. In fact, before the introduction of reddit gold reddit was so self-insufficient they were not allowed to hire because they were not making enough base revenue for Conde Nast to consider it worth growing in staff. Not profit, revenue.

It might have changed post Gold, but I'm not so sure about that.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by redthrowaway on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:33PM (#1812945)
It definitely changed post-gold. IIRC, they're bringing in 40k/month from gold alone.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by points on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:29PM (#1813185)
So that pretty much only covers their hosting costs...
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by redthrowaway on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @11:47PM (#1814195)
That's 40k on top of what they were already making from ads, Which was still more than their expenses.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by points on Thursday October 21, 2010 @03:09AM (#1814570)
What? You're saying they're making 40k (hosting costs) + all salaries from advertising? I find that incredibly hard to believe. Like impossible to believe.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by redthrowaway on Thursday October 21, 2010 @04:52AM (#1814760)
I have no idea what their hosting costs were, or their 5 salaries, but they did make enough to stay afloat, although not enough for CN to approve more staff. Jedberg's commented in this thread, so I suggest you ask him whether they were profitable pre-gold.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by points on Thursday October 21, 2010 @07:28AM (#1815008)
Their hosting costs were around $35k according to http://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/ctz7c/your_gold_dollar...

Since then afaik they've added more servers.

> "but they did make enough to stay afloat"

I think Reddit has been operating at a loss for quite some time.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by redthrowaway on Thursday October 21, 2010 @02:53PM (#1816933)
Actually they were around $22,400 according to the comment just under that. Still, I wouldn't be able to tell you whether or not they operated at a loss. You'd have to ask jedberg.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by points on Thursday October 21, 2010 @03:40PM (#1817116)
There's simply no way they're making anywhere near that from advertising. I would even have a hard time they're making that a year from advertising.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by redthrowaway on Friday October 22, 2010 @06:00AM (#1819132)
300 million pageviews/month goes a long way. Sure, their CTR is probably lower than most sites, but their traffic is huge.

Let's say their CTR is 0.1%. That's 300k clicks/month. I'm building in some wiggle-room here, as a 0.1% CTR is abysmal, but often their ads aren't really ads. Even at $0.01/click, that's still $30k/month. More than enough for hosting. Now, I'd hazard a guess that most of my numbers are quite a bit on the low side, as reddit has operated for years without CN shutting the doors. Also, from what the admins have intimated from time to time, they make money, but not enough to register on CN's radar.

I wouldn't discount their ad sales; traffic like that carries a lot of weight.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by zavulon on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:19PM (#1813151)
> The community is the loveliest on the internet

I'm going to post this every time I see a misconception like this (and I really don't care if I get downvoted, it's more important to get the truth out).

Reddit is one of the biggest anti-semitic hate sites on the 'net.

One of many examples: http://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/ccnir/im_gonna_get...

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @06:25PM (#1813374)
Plenty of jokes on Reddit about atheists, Christians, Muslims, etc. Seems pretty equal-opportunity to me.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by nandemo on Thursday October 21, 2010 @12:55AM (#1814338)
It's very much not equal-opportunity. For instance:

http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/d6lll/whats_your_...

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by ceejayoz on Thursday October 21, 2010 @10:31AM (#1815510)
Uh, that's a thread that asks "what's your most offensive joke". Using that as evidence for anti-semetism is like using Wikipedia's inclusion of Nazi emblems on their page on Nazism to prove that Wikipedia is anti-semetic.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by nandemo on Thursday October 21, 2010 @11:24AM (#1815819)
My reply was not meant to assert that redditors are actually anti-semitic in a nazi sense, but to show that it's not really "equal-opportunity". In short, jokes about jews and blacks are clearly acceptable and even popular but gay jokes are not.

Maybe one could claim that gay jokes aren't there because they aren't considered "most offensive" to start with but I really doubt it. I think it's just a code for "let's make racist jokes".

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by ceejayoz on Thursday October 21, 2010 @11:45AM (#1815945)
I'd say racist jokes (and the dead baby ones also found on that page) tend to be considered more offensive than most other categories. I'm trying to think of gay jokes more offensive than the ones posted in there and am coming up short.
Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” by chr15 on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @06:10PM (#1813328)
I wouldn't judge the entire community based on the actions of one redditor. You also have to look at the converse. There are also people on there who are genuinely kind, but may not be as vocal. There are many instances where redditors have banded together for a positive purpose. Some are apathetic and just want to have a laugh.