"I'm Robin hood stealing from rich people" doesn't work for the people on the right who are more likely to complain more about the irs in the first place.
Joe the plumber who runs his own plumbing business and doesn't pay taxes is going to get audited as well and he's (rightfully) going to lose despite his position in the middle class.
This isn't "the bourgeois" stealing, it's anyone who deducts significant amounts of money, which is a broader/simpler message everyone can get behind. Every small business/individual contractor has the means to illegitimately write off tens of thousands of dollars.
Why are crimes for some people not crimes while crimes for others punished so harshly? How is that not unfair already?
But I'll add that every small business/contractor has the right to write off a lot of things, or portions of things that they use for business.
What sort of "promoting" of IRS tax audits and fraud cases do you think should be done?
Why? That's exactly what it is.
Meals, travel, vehicles, basically everything a regular person has to spend out of their own income to survive, these people get away with expensing as business expenses.
That's actually not true, and is in fact the point of the IRS auditor. Namely, that people are expensing these items as business deductions when they are in fact normal living/lifestyle expenses.
A partner at a law firm can easily get away with expensing 1 of their 2 luxury cars, 50% of their meals, 50% of their travel, their home computers and software, etc. Car companies even make SUVs and Crossovers that are slightly over 6000lbs so they can be deducted as 'working' trucks for white collar workers.
If it wasn't setup as the employer paying for 1/2 of it, do you not think that most workers would want to be paid 7.5% more to pay it?
However, those people are not getting away with expensing them, because the IRS has no statute of limitations on going after these sorts of issues (income tax returns which are fraudulent are not subject to a statute of limitations, which means that the related crimes aren't either). Basically, it's a timing issue of when they get punished for the tax evasion, though at some point the backlog gets big enough that they might have to triage out the smaller cases.
For the thin margins, imagine a company that makes 2%. But they pay 30% tax. Suddenly they’re at a loss on every sale due to tax. So thry raise price. Except every component in their chain alos does this.
You’d probably also see a lot more vertical integration. No sale, no tax. Whereas separated companies have to pay tax every time thry deal withan outside company.
But the world is not vertically integrated. So this tax plan wouldmforce america to drop best practices and go for extremely inefficient methods.
Your plan for fairness would almost certainly destroy the economy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_and_occupation_tax#Ma...
So a federal B&O scheme might work if the rate was low enough. Auditing a business would be massively simplified, no need to carefully check expenses and write-offs to calculate net income. Compliance would be much easier. The question is would gross income taxation create a bigger pie, and would that pie be big enough that a low rate would substantially tax revenues.
There is a reason no country in the world does OP’s proposal, or yours. They would turn things topsy-turvy.
This seems wrong. I would think you would only be able to deduct basics like food and housing, maybe vehicles, with limits. Admittedly, that does get complicated really fast. In fact, as a pastor technically working as a contractor, my dad was able to deduct housing expenses for his whole family. It's not entirely unheard of.
Also, I don't believe getting the government to pay you by deliberately incurring a loss works for business, so I don't see why it would for individuals.
It would indeed be an enormously complicated system. And for what benefit?
(Americans actually have one of the most deduction heavy tax systems in the world btw, including mortgage interest. In Canada we have almost no deductions of expenses from income tax. So our taxes are very simple. Complex taxes favour the rich, and require auditors)
The middle ground we have now is personal exemptions and the standard deduction, which gives single individuals $16,000 in Federal tax-free income. Which is fair-ish. Certainly it's more fair now than when only upper-middle class people with mortgages and high property taxes were able to itemize.
https://www.inc.com/manon-defelice/ceo-mom-expense-childcare...
Individuals shouldn't be able to misrepresent personal expenses as business costs, but the amortization of a $500,000 crane also isn't all that similar to needing to eat.
All I'm saying is that both should be treated equally, which ever option that ends up being.
This seems like language specifically crafted to encourage an us vs. them view of taxation. Also, I notice the examples given are upper middle class/lower upper class, and not the top of top that evade the most taxes. Often legally, since there are so many massive tax loopholes that the richest get to legally avoid paying a share in proportion to the government goods and services they consume.
On some level it feels like punishing the poor for trying to emulate the wealthy, and the merely very wealthy (an interesting way of putting it) like lawyers and doctors often fall into the poor when you break it down to those who are truly rich or not.
On some level it feels like punishing the poor for trying to emulate the wealthy,
Let's get things straight: they're being punished for breaking the law, or more specifically, for fraud. The fact that they want to emulate the wealthy is irrelevant.
When the IRS is enforcing a corrupt law, it makes people who fear the corrupt law being enforced against them view the IRS as the bad guys. That it is the law only hurts the IRS's position in this. Until the IRS makes the truly wealthy pay their fair share, not their legal share, they will find themselves in a position lacking moral authority.
Put another way, yes those loopholes are legal, but so is reducing the IRS's budget until they aren't able to operate at all.
This isn't the IRS's job. This isn't within their authority. Under these conditions, the IRS can't ever be in a position of moral authority.
Is it possible that you may be blaming the IRS when blame might be better apportioned elsewhere?
You are right, which is part of the reason why there is a non insignificant part of the population that wants to disable the IRS and sees them as a threat.
Same as a police officer who is sent as set of drug laws to enforce that are crafted specifically to target minorities. The only winning move is to not play, and those who don't quit begin to be seen as opponents regardless of how much the individual doesn't like the laws they are enforcing. Regardless of if you think this is a correct or incorrect way to view things, one has to accept that this does happen and it explains why entire communities turn away from the police and engage in self enforcement of their own rules and begin to craft policies such as 'snitches get stitches'.
The IRS is not enforcing a corrupt law, and the story Fox News doesn't want you to know about the IRS' conservative "charity" crackdown is that all of those charities were openly violating tax laws to the private inurement of their executives and challenging the IRS to do something about it, knowing that they had members of the House GOP in their pocket to prevent IRS action.
I wasn't speaking about that case. I was talking about how the tax law is currently written to favor some groups at the expense of other groups. And to be honest, this doesn't even have to be true. Only the appearance of it has to be seen by enough of the population for the reaction I describe to happen. Even if you think the tax law is completely fair, you would have to admit that significant portions of the population are not in agreement, and their views of the IRS will be driven by their views of the tax law.
This leaves that middle ground of people who don't earn traditional wages, but also don't earn enough to employ fancy tax evasion schemes. Instead, they literally break the law and hope to evade justice long enough for it not to matter.
The key lies in the awkward distinction between tax evasion and using the tax system to minimize your tax liability. They look pretty damn similar to most people. But they're different in a very important way to the IRS - evasion is illegal and minimization is not.
And indeed, many of the examples given will likely be settled under audit instead of criminal cases; Wrote off jet skis? Oh, that isn't allowed, but I used them for business meetings, to show clients 1st hand example policies; limited criminal intentionality there.
But since you can't live within a country without taking advantage of the benefits the government provides, such as rule of law and a living space that's relatively safe and has legal recourse for problems, good luck getting them to stop "stealing" from you. I guess you could move out to remote wilderness region, or some country with basically no government oversight. Somehow I doubt you'll be happier there, nor that you'll be able to make nearly as much money there as you would in a country with a strong government, even if none of the money us taxed at all.
Taxes are the price we pay to support civilization, and as such it's an investment in our own current and future well-being, financial and otherwise. It's the implicit agreement you accept by continuing to live here. You can either lobby for a change, or attempt to move somewhere with different laws, but it's not theft, and acting like it is is willful ignorance of the reality we live in.
The income tax basically only funds: Interest on the debt, and Entitlement programs (welfare, etc).
Entitlement programs like Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid are funded mostly through individual line items, and slightly through indirect means, such as interest paid to the programs by their bond holdings.
Income taxes fund so much. You can't say it "funds only ..." because it funds almost everything. Sometimes directly, such as the military, but often times, it's indirect, such as college professors who receive grants from the NSF.
Why is it that any criticism of our current tax regime is instantly expanded to AGAINST ALL TAXATION. I'm more than happy to pay taxes I feel are reasonable in amount and directly beneficial in some way. The federal income tax is not that. Not even close. It's a money black hole that goes towards god knows what, and is a huge drag on the middle class, the people Mr. IRS in the quote is supposedly helping.
It is impossible to completely separate the functioning of the current system from the way it is funding. Every single thing in the United States benefits at least in part by functioning within the system as a whole, and that includes the legal and regulatory framework.
> Roads are mostly state,
A large amount of that state funding is from grants to the state by the federal government.
Updated data from the Census Bureau's 2015 Annual Survey of State Government Finances published last week indicates that federal aid made up nearly a third of all states’ general fund revenues in fiscal year 2015. The single largest line items in states’ budgets include federal funding for transportation, Medicaid and other social assistance programs. ... The federal government distributed $41.6 billion in roadway infrastructure and highway safety funding to states in fiscal 2015.[1] The article also includes a handle by-state breakdown of funding received for transportation, and the percentage of that states transportation spending that results in.
> airways are mostly private
But the FAA regulates how planes fly, and what safety precautions must be taken.
> doctors and hospitals are outrageously expensive
But there are rules about what they must and must not do, and how drugs and treatments must be verified and what can be said about them.
> I'm not sure what that means in this context but yea, government regulations sure saved that one from going to the shitter.
It means some protections are better than none. There's a difference between being in the toilet and being flushed into the sewer.
> Why is it that any criticism of our current tax regime
Classifying taxation as theft is not "any criticism". If you use extreme, and in my eyes unjustified rhetoric, expect it to be called out.
> I'm more than happy to pay taxes I feel are reasonable in amount and directly beneficial in some way.
...and that's supposed to have been expressed by "Stop stealing 30% of my income"?
1: http://www.governing.com/topics/finance/gov-state-budgets-fe...
You originally said that all Federal taxes were confiscatory. But in your reply above you hedged by saying that most roads, etc were state funded.
> Oh yea? Stop stealing 30% of my income if you really want to be helpful.
That means a ~30% levy on middle class income is pretty outrageous if that is the class of people you are intending to help. And the income tax is hardly the only federal tax. The state income tax is relatively minor compared to federal, and roads are funded via gas taxes and tolls, i.e. use taxes, which is far more direct in figuring out where your money is going. Sure the feds will kick in grants to assist with roads et al, but if that were all they were spending their income tax haul on they would not need such a high percentage to begin with.
And to be clear, all taxes are confiscatory, by definition. If you don't pay you risk going to jail, and if you resist that it will be at gunpoint. Whether one thinks that confiscation is reasonable and beneficial overall is another issue. But it's not like you can just opt-out of taxes, or death.
- the government takes 30% of my income, and
- that's stealing.
To many of us, that was the plain meaning of your exact words. "All taxation is stealing" seemed the clear not-quite-stated implication.
> And to be clear, all taxes are confiscatory, by definition.
Which definition? dictionary.com says:
> 1. to seize as forfeited to the public domain; appropriate, by way of penalty, for public use.
> 2. to seize by or as if by authority; appropriate summarily.
The first (primary) definition has an element of forfeiture or penalty; the second does not. All taxes are confiscatory by the second definition; not by the first. When you say "all taxes are confiscatory", people are apt to hear "confiscatory" in the first sense, which makes your statement wrong by definition. It also may make it claiming more than you intended it to claim.
This is all besides the point, because what I mean when I say "stealing" is "the government is taking a large portion of my income and I am receiving little to no benefit from it, and yet I am not allowed to stop paying for the lack of return for my money. In fact the first link for "confiscatory" on google provides the definition "Being or imposing an excessive or unreasonable tax or cost". That's what I see the federal income tax on the middle class as, excessive and unreasonable. Not that all taxes are necessarily bad, but that one, and the sheer amount it confiscates, certainly is.
It's no surprise, for totalitarian arguments to be made in totalitarian fashion.
The Highway Trust Fund is still a thing, and (IIUC) pays for the federal highways. The states pay for the state highways. There are probably more state highways, but the most important ones (and the most used ones) are federal.
> airways are mostly private
The planes are mostly private. Airports aren't. Neither is the air traffic control system.
So if you're one of those "Joe the Plumber" people who take time out of work to throw teabags at me on my way into the office in the morning: You are the middle class! I'm helping you!"
https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/09/what-pe...