There is a reason no country in the world does OP’s proposal, or yours. They would turn things topsy-turvy.
This seems wrong. I would think you would only be able to deduct basics like food and housing, maybe vehicles, with limits. Admittedly, that does get complicated really fast. In fact, as a pastor technically working as a contractor, my dad was able to deduct housing expenses for his whole family. It's not entirely unheard of.
Also, I don't believe getting the government to pay you by deliberately incurring a loss works for business, so I don't see why it would for individuals.
It would indeed be an enormously complicated system. And for what benefit?
(Americans actually have one of the most deduction heavy tax systems in the world btw, including mortgage interest. In Canada we have almost no deductions of expenses from income tax. So our taxes are very simple. Complex taxes favour the rich, and require auditors)
The middle ground we have now is personal exemptions and the standard deduction, which gives single individuals $16,000 in Federal tax-free income. Which is fair-ish. Certainly it's more fair now than when only upper-middle class people with mortgages and high property taxes were able to itemize.