News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by CalRobert on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:01AM (#18111270)
It always seems odd to me that people still plan their lives as though the world fifty years from now will be basically the same as now. I hope they're right, to be honest. But we're talking 3+c warming (5.4F) and that could be horrific. I guess it's nice if you want a winery in Norway but that's small comfort.
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by 2ion on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:22AM (#18111353)
> It always seems odd to me that people still plan their lives as though the world fifty years from now will be basically the same as now

Even planning for anything 10 years in the future is a daunting task. For any prognosis there are a dozen more claiming different results or different trends with different outcomes. It's an information flood that does not let you make a definite judgement since it's overwhelming, and even when you try to base a decision on scientific evidence, because there's usually a "model", the certainty of the outcome "depends" (on any number of "variables").

What do? Make a conversative projection on what things are like today, and a plan based on that.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by madaxe_again on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:52AM (#18111491)
You also have to adjust for the fact that most of what climate scientists publish is already conservative. Get them talking one-to-one and their predictions for the next decades are dire.

Me, I take a pessimistic view - I don’t think you have to have a large percentage change in, say, crop production, or storm damage rebuilding costs, for economies to feel the effect - prices rise, labour is diverted from growth to maintenance, and adaptations are ultimately made, but in the intervening period expense has been incurrred, and by now the climate has warmed further. The costs end up growing astronomically, and at what point do governments fail due to popular discontent, at what point do further governments collapse and even wars start due to resource cost rises and the need for popular distraction, and mass migration caused by revolution and war nearby?

I’ve put my money where my mouth is - I’ve become itinerant, while I scope out where on earth to live this out - somewhere quiet, and remote, and self-sufficient, that hasn’t yet seen ecological disaster and might escape the worst of climate change due to geography. Sadly, everywhere I’ve been in the past few years, across all continents and hemispheres, even when these places as yet appear verdant and untouched, are feeling the wrath of a changing climate, and human-wrought ecological destruction, from drought to flood, from aquifer pollution to overfarming and desertification, and vast agricultural monoculture, highly vulnerable to moving growing zones and viable climates for pests.

I’d love to be able to do something to prevent this - I recycle, I don’t buy much, I travel overland wherever possible - but I fear we’re too far gone.

What humanity and our civilisation will be in 20 or 30 years I don’t know, but I fear it’ll be unrecognisable and almost unimaginable to us, even now.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by logancg on Monday October 01, 2018 @07:53AM (#18111766)
I'm curious: if you think so much about climate change and its effects, and even plan your actions and location around it, have you considered directing your energy to combatting climate change with your skills on a systemic level? (For example, building sustainability companies, being part of climate activism, earning-to-donate?)

I'm in a similar spot but optimistic about systemic action.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by madaxe_again on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:41AM (#18112021)
I’m doing consultancy at a CTO level for a number of medium/large environmental technology companies while I travel, comprising everything from supply chain management around hazardous materials to sustainable living systems to pipeline management - and I’ve been contributing photography and footage to documentarians as I go.

I’m not optimistic about systemic action - the people taking it seriously don’t have the power to overcome a far more dominant system: our consumption-driven way of living, and the economies built around it. Mindshare may grow sufficiently in coming decades, but by then it’ll largely be too late, and that growth will likely come from more people witnessing and enduring the effects of climate change - and if we’re at that point, it’s already too late, as systemic collapse beckons as I laid out in my previous.

The climate is a chaotic system - it finds a metastable mode for a given set of inputs, and once moved by changing those inputs (e.g. CO2 ppm) from that point of stability can wander drastically before finding that point again. As forests die, as methane is belched from the thawing permafrost, as marine ecosystems collapse (everywhere is overrun by jellies - even Antarctica), as ice caps and glaciers melt, as coastal plains flood, as grassland turns to desert, core components of the current system of stability are yet further altered, thus pushing the current mode yet further from its stable point and making that stable point harder to reattain.

Like I said, get a climatologist talking in private, and it’s grim listening. They see the bigger picture in their work, but only publish studies on specific observations. Longitudinal studies end up being conservative otherwise they sound radically alarmist and don’t get published.

Anyhow. We should keep on playing while the ship sinks.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by bjourne on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:54AM (#18112113)
There were large scale demonstrations held on September 8. Hundreds of thousands of people marched and demanded change around the world. You didn't hear about it? Not strange. Zero media coverage.
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by CalRobert on Monday October 01, 2018 @09:58AM (#18112557)
tl;dr I got tired of people saying I was "lucky" that I could ride a bike to work and made a tool to help them do the same thing. It shows flats for rent on a map with transport and bike routes instead of roads.

https://www.gaffologist.com/ (Ireland-only)

Sorry if it sounds like a plug but it's the best answer I have to your question. I studied physics in college and hoped it would help me work on energy efficiency or renewable energy generation technology, but it turns out that when I graduated (in to the worst recession in a century) nobody had any interest at all in what I was able to offer. I'd still love to work on saving the planet if I could do so while paying rent or a mortgage.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by jacquesm on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:06AM (#18112620)
Super neat, and cool to see you act.
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by majewsky on Monday October 01, 2018 @12:13PM (#18114033)
> What humanity and our civilisation will be in 20 or 30 years I don’t know, but I fear it’ll be unrecognisable and almost unimaginable to us, even now.

This is certainly true when looking at 2018 from the perspective of 1988 (or even 1998).

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by mabbo on Monday October 01, 2018 @06:06AM (#18111297)
People are growing corn further and further north here in Ontario. Places where it used to be unthinkable because the season was too short.

The pessimistic oportunist in me thinks it might be wise to start buying up vacation property in Newfoundland.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by barrow-rider on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:05AM (#18113200)
Newfoundland? Too coastal. Gamble on future waterfront property in SK or AB.
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by lazyjones on Monday October 01, 2018 @07:41AM (#18111706)
I don‘t like alarmism. Most of it is simply proven wrong in the long term. People are good at adapting most of the time. For example, I got myself air conditioning in a country famous for skiing. People in poor countries will probably suffer much more, but they need to tackle their population growth issues anyway. In essence, there are life-changing problems affecting us every day (who would have thought 50 years ago that we‘d need barriers againt car attacks at all major public events?), don‘t obsess over one thing like some sort of religious freak („the end is nigh...“).
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by dm319 on Monday October 01, 2018 @07:51AM (#18111752)
I think alarmism is a retrospective assessment. We can probably say a lot of our reporting on current Western terrorism is alarmist - numbers wise, it didn't compare to road deaths or regular shootings.

But global warming will be/is unprecedented and will affect the whole world. Immediate action is unlikely to reverse this process either.

Your comment about population growth issues is disgusting.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by oceanghost on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:44AM (#18112045)
In any other context, an obsession with the end of the world would be evidence of mental illness.
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by lazyjones on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:30AM (#18111960)
> We can probably say a lot of our reporting on current Western terrorism is alarmist - numbers wise, it didn't compare to road deaths or regular shootings

Because we have adapted. But how many are affected by the terror it involves? Terrorism = terrorizing people, not just murdering them.

> But global warming will be/is unprecedented

Erm, no.

https://www.climate.gov/news-features/climate-qa/whats-hotte...

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by rotw on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:44AM (#18112042)
> Erm, no.

Why do you bother commenting on this if you just flat-out refuse to accept scientific evidence in the original post?

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by CalRobert on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:00AM (#18111808)
"who would have thought 50 years ago that we‘d need barriers againt car attacks at all major public events"

To be honest, we still don't need them. Obviously it's horrible but considering that we accept ~1.25 million people a year killed on the roads (~25k in the EU, 30-40k in the US, or about one 9-eleven a month) it's probably not the best ROI. Though to be honest I think we should put massive barriers between cars and people anywhere we can, or just remove the cars wherever possible, but I'm odd that way.

Like I said I hope I'm wrong, but right now it looks like all the earlier estimates were too conservative and to think that we can cause major disruptions to the world's food supply, as well as making some places simply uninhabitable without air conditioning, strikes me as naive. To think that you can do it while still planning a 401(k) and buying holiday houses on the beach a cheap flight away for when you retire seems especially naive (though I worry we'll still have the cheap flights, which would be a bummer unless they're electric).

As far as population - it's true that we could stand to have far fewer people around, but even if your motivations are purely selfish, making hundreds of millions of people hungry, thirsty, and desperate doesn't sound like a good idea. And of course, most poor people emit basically nothing, so reducing the population of people living on under 5 dollars a day won't do much for the planet as a whole.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by lazyjones on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:36AM (#18111988)
I don‘t really want to play this game of stupid comparisons. Because then we don‘t need treatments for many uncommon diseases either. It‘s a fact that people demand these barriers for their peace of mind and cities build them.
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by Daishiman on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:16AM (#18112695)
This is some seriously shortsighted thinking.

There's nothing you'll be able to do about oceanic anoxia, or a myriad other effects that are simply catastrophic.

Speaking of skiing, good luck when those economies collapse when the brunt of tourism goes away.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by konschubert on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:03AM (#18111820)
I think you're falling for a fallacy of scale.

The perceived need to add car barriers to public events ks nothing in comparison with having to air-condition homes and public spaces around the globe. Also, remember nature?

[dead]
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by dang on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:55PM (#18118692)
Personal attacks will get you banned here. Please don't post like this again, regardless of how bad someone else's environmental practices are.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by lazyjones on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:33AM (#18111975)
> Honestly, this is a vile and selfish attitude.

I don‘t care about your assessment. You are free to live in humility, poverty, extreme heat, whatever - if you think it will make you a superior human being. I prefer having bearable temperatures where I live, sleep and have visitors, without having to beg and wait for the whole world to stop burning fossil fuels, eating meat etc.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by yaps8 on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:45AM (#18112054)
> without having to beg and wait for the whole world to stop burning fossil fuels, eating meat etc

You don't have to beg and wait for YOU to stop burning fossil fuels, eating meat etc.

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by lazyjones on Monday October 01, 2018 @09:22AM (#18112280)
I would feel stupid if I did. I believe in technology as a provider for solutions to such problems, not regression to a primitive lifestyle like the eco-hippies demand. They aren’t particularly thorough anyway, because there’s about 10-20 tons of CO2 emissions to save by relieving the world of one‘s unhappy existence after being deprived of all the fun life has to offer (we exhale about 1Kg per day). ;-)
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by rotw on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:42AM (#18112027)
> I prefer having bearable temperatures where I live, sleep and have visitors,

What gives you the right to all that at the direct expense of the people who can't afford it?

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by lazyjones on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:49AM (#18112084)
The right of the stronger, fitter. I’m sorry if it hurts your feelings, but that‘s how nature and evolution works. Perhaps your religion preaches something else, but why should I care?
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by dang on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:57PM (#18118698)
Please keep generic ideological tangents off HN, especially when the thread topic is already divisive. They just lead to predictable flamewars, equal parts destructive and tedious.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by Jedi72 on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:24AM (#18112760)
If you accept climate change is real, and accept we need to tackle the problem, the simplest and most powerful solution would be coordinated action. However, we are stuck in a prisoners dilemma, because people with your attitude will not stop, will not change, and if that is say 1/100 people then it becomes unbearable for the other 99, socially and economically, to commit to the plan.
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by CalRobert on Monday October 01, 2018 @01:08PM (#18114602)
I'm not sure I can convince you otherwise. If memory serves, even Socrates reached an impasse with Thrasymachus.
[dead]
Re:IPCC: Climate scientists consider ‘life changing’ report by lazyjones on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:30AM (#18113551)
> Right, so why don't I just come along and murder you? I have the right, by your logic. Or, maybe, this Social Darwinism is fascist nonsense and you fully admit to being disgustingly amoral.

You are free to try if you want to bear the consequences and the risk of a different outcome. What you people tend to forget: different morals and amoral is not the same thing, don‘t force your morals on me. You have no right to.

> The only reason to care about social wellbeing and people other than yourself is religion?

I care very much about our survival as a species, but I believe that by allowing each and every one to survive at a high cost to society, we put the wellbeing of mankind at risk. I‘m all for getting dumb people to stop eating meat for perceived ecological reasons though!