Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by wtallis on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @06:19PM
(#1809037)
If you want to see where "pro-life" may be stretching the truth, consider that not all "pro-life"-ers are vegans. When they say "pro-life", they're trying to imply that embryos are people, which is really the crux of the debate.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by tjogin on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @01:42AM
(#1810168)
Well, many/most pro-lifers aren't pro-life anymore when it comes to the death penalty, or gun-control, or what have you. Then the sanctity of life isn't that uncompromisingly important, anymore.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by endtime on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @09:04PM
(#1809517)
I'm actually okay with "pro-life" as shorthand for "pro-sentient life". I think that's obviously implied - the debate isn't about whether cows should be able to get abortions.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by wtallis on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @09:49PM
(#1809630)
But whether an embryo is sentient or if its life has more value than that of a dog or cow is a debatable point for people who don't derive their opinions from their dogma. If you take "pro-life" to be short for "pro- sentient life", then you've shifted focus away from the issue over to what's pretty much a tautology.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by endtime on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @12:48AM
(#1810025)
I agree with you that an embryo isn't sentient - however, they believe it is, or at least that it has a "soul" (which, in their minds, is the same thing). Their position is that wrong to kill something with a soul. You can (and should) be scientific about whether or not an embryo meets that qualification, but that's a question of their poor science, not their motive nor the position they think they're arguing...which I do think is reasonably accurately captured by "pro-life".
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by jpwagner on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @08:35PM
(#1809453)
"pro embryo life" doesnt have the same ring to it
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by wtallis on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @11:42PM
(#1809862)
And neither does "pro abortion choice". Basically everyone involved prefers oversimplification to accuracy, which is one of the top two reasons why the "debate" can't go anywhere.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by chc on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @07:48PM
(#1809326)
It certainly wouldn't be accurate to call most people on that side of the debate "pro-abortion." A lot of them don't like abortion for various reasons, but believe it's the woman's choice. I agree that "pro-choice" is loaded, but it's less euphemistic than "pro-life," which really does just mean "anti-abortion."
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by endtime on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @09:09PM
(#1809537)
>It certainly wouldn't be accurate to call most people on that side of the debate "pro-abortion." A lot of them don't like abortion for various reasons, but believe it's the woman's choice.
Well, it's a legal debate. The argument is about the legal issue shorthanded as "abortion", no? In which case I can understand why someone would call "pro-choice" the pro-abortion side.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by winthrowe on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @10:12PM
(#1809676)
Well, to my mind, it's about the distinction between prohibited, permissible, and mandatory. To my mind 'pro-abortion' implies mandatory, forced abortion; 'pro-life' and 'anti-abortion' both seem reasonable terms for making carrying to term mandatory; and 'pro-choice' is about it being a choice.
I'd be perfectly happy calling both 'pro-life' and 'pro-abortion' (if they exist?) both 'anti-choice'.
That's a pretty touchy example. Honestly, I've always thought that "pro-choice" was stretching the truth more than "pro-life".