Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by endtime on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @05:38PM
(#1808890)
>That's why people are "Pro Life" not anti-abortion.
That's a pretty touchy example. Honestly, I've always thought that "pro-choice" was stretching the truth more than "pro-life".
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by wtallis on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @06:19PM
(#1809037)
If you want to see where "pro-life" may be stretching the truth, consider that not all "pro-life"-ers are vegans. When they say "pro-life", they're trying to imply that embryos are people, which is really the crux of the debate.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by tjogin on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @01:42AM
(#1810168)
Well, many/most pro-lifers aren't pro-life anymore when it comes to the death penalty, or gun-control, or what have you. Then the sanctity of life isn't that uncompromisingly important, anymore.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by endtime on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @09:04PM
(#1809517)
I'm actually okay with "pro-life" as shorthand for "pro-sentient life". I think that's obviously implied - the debate isn't about whether cows should be able to get abortions.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by wtallis on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @09:49PM
(#1809630)
But whether an embryo is sentient or if its life has more value than that of a dog or cow is a debatable point for people who don't derive their opinions from their dogma. If you take "pro-life" to be short for "pro- sentient life", then you've shifted focus away from the issue over to what's pretty much a tautology.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by endtime on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @12:48AM
(#1810025)
I agree with you that an embryo isn't sentient - however, they believe it is, or at least that it has a "soul" (which, in their minds, is the same thing). Their position is that wrong to kill something with a soul. You can (and should) be scientific about whether or not an embryo meets that qualification, but that's a question of their poor science, not their motive nor the position they think they're arguing...which I do think is reasonably accurately captured by "pro-life".
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by jpwagner on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @08:35PM
(#1809453)
"pro embryo life" doesnt have the same ring to it
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by wtallis on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @11:42PM
(#1809862)
And neither does "pro abortion choice". Basically everyone involved prefers oversimplification to accuracy, which is one of the top two reasons why the "debate" can't go anywhere.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by chc on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @07:48PM
(#1809326)
It certainly wouldn't be accurate to call most people on that side of the debate "pro-abortion." A lot of them don't like abortion for various reasons, but believe it's the woman's choice. I agree that "pro-choice" is loaded, but it's less euphemistic than "pro-life," which really does just mean "anti-abortion."
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by endtime on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @09:09PM
(#1809537)
>It certainly wouldn't be accurate to call most people on that side of the debate "pro-abortion." A lot of them don't like abortion for various reasons, but believe it's the woman's choice.
Well, it's a legal debate. The argument is about the legal issue shorthanded as "abortion", no? In which case I can understand why someone would call "pro-choice" the pro-abortion side.
Re:Apple changes words in order to change the debate
by winthrowe on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @10:12PM
(#1809676)
Well, to my mind, it's about the distinction between prohibited, permissible, and mandatory. To my mind 'pro-abortion' implies mandatory, forced abortion; 'pro-life' and 'anti-abortion' both seem reasonable terms for making carrying to term mandatory; and 'pro-choice' is about it being a choice.
I'd be perfectly happy calling both 'pro-life' and 'pro-abortion' (if they exist?) both 'anti-choice'.
Both sides of any argument do this. Google by calling it "open" which means more than it really does. Apple doesn't debate it's not open, it just debates that the results aren't any good because of the confusion of choices. "Open" is supposed to be a good thing, Apple doesn't believe it is.
But the fact is that Apple is crying about it, they're explaining why they made the decisions they made. They need to justify this to their investors. Google needs PR to make Android look good.
That's why people are "Pro Life" not anti-abortion. Do these guys read the news, maybe they just started?