News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People can die from giving up the fight by amelius on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:04PM (#18086438)
Does this book make one feel better or more depressed?

The article has not a very good vibe to it, tbh.

Re:People can die from giving up the fight by fsloth on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:51PM (#18086949)
Does going to a therapist and discussing about things frankly as they are make one feel better or worse?

Viktor has a very objective tone of voice. He never paints himself as a saint, a martyr or a superman. This creates a certain feeling of detachment that shields from the full emotional impact of what he actually went through.

Overall, however, the book is about survival and the strength of human spirit. Especially since Mr. Frankl personally went through hell, retained his sanity and will to live, and wrote the book.

It's a book that gave me hope and strength in dark times.

Re:People can die from giving up the fight by martin-adams on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:13PM (#18086545)
I read this book a few weeks ago. It was such a surprise for what I expected. Make no mistake, it objectively talks about horrific events, but I felt humbled and appreciative of the life I have and how to deal with challenging times.
Re:People can die from giving up the fight by gerbilly on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:30PM (#18086741)
The book as I remember it made you feel hopeful.

It is a very persuasive argument about how one can deal with even the most 'hopeless' situation.

It is also a brilliant description of the psychological effects of camp life.

The way he described the odd dislocated feeling they got when the allies set them free was particularly memorable for me.

Re:People can die from giving up the fight by Buttons840 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:19PM (#18087257)
Things like Nazi gas chambers are interesting in a horrific sort of way, but this book did not concentrate on those types of things.

The book focused on things which I found to be subtly more disturbing, like the ability of an overweight Nazi guard to curse a death camp prisoner for being "swine, who doesn't know how to work!" while the prisoner is literally working themselves to death in front of the guard to just stands around being fat and worthless. Does the guard not see the irony? How is it possible that he does not? Do I myself hold any absurd views like that Nazi guard?

Ultimately the book showed me that there are decent and indecent people in any group, and made me want to be a decent person. I wouldn't say the book is depressing.

Re:People can die from giving up the fight by mettamage on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:07PM (#18087127)
For me it felt a bit like a science book with fascinating insights. Yes, what happened in those places was awful but that wasn't the focal point of the book IMO. The focal point is an analyzed account of how people have a higher (or lower) chance of survival in such a dire setting.

Also his book are secretly 2 books for which this part is the first part. The second part is about Logotherapy, something he developed after WWII based on the insights he gained from people in concentration camps.

Re:People can die from giving up the fight by piyh on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:42PM (#18086847)
It's a rational analysis of some of the worst experiences a person can go through. It wasn't written to wrench your soul like Sophie's Choice and gives a great look at the human psyche pushed to its limits.
Re:People can die from giving up the fight by amelius on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:43PM (#18086871)
Okay. Is it written from the point of view of the (almost) dying person, or of the bystanders?
Re:People can die from giving up the fight by Boulth on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:50PM (#18086947)
It's written by a person that did not give up, survived and analyzed the experience. I read it previously and I highly recommend it, don't worry you won't be depressed after that. On the contrary.