News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by ummonk on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:31AM (#18082464)
As a security engineer, I cannot overstate just how horrible this is. Phone numbers might not be an ideal 2nd factor for authentication, but to punish users for setting up 2FA by using the provided phone number for ad targetting is incredibly unethical.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by cmroanirgo on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:46AM (#18083568)
I agree with your sentiment.

But, as someone who understands that not all people and companies use the same moral set as myself, this is why I've never set up 2fa using a phone.

Why should I give some company my phone number? Increasingly it's become a single point of metadata to uniquely describe myself (just as my email addresses have).

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by jsjohnst on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:35AM (#18083833)
> just as my email addresses have

That doesn’t need to be the case though with just a little bit of effort and minimal cost. Use your own domain for email and set your account to be a catchall. Then use [email protected] and your email address is no longer a cross site unique identifier.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by barkingcat on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:08AM (#18084047)
Isn't this it though, the engineers designing the ad targeting system at Facebook is linking the random emails you use as "catch all" to your main identity so you can be targeted specifically even though neither party has full knowledge of the linkage between your catchall email and your main identity email. This is facilitated by information that is not under your control.

If facebook was able to design and build this system, you can bet that other companies are doing this too.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by jsjohnst on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:42AM (#18084358)
Check the TOS and/or implementations for many of the tracking providers and you’ll see they use hashed emails. Show me a way to extract the common domain name from the below:

9425ca8eb02d022309ec175a7067b1567a5f741ec7010cc1b5034287f9db6e2f

4d1c86b9f418c713e784760fea809e34418c2f13e993d907783572ecc2c9bb6e

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by kadoban on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:58AM (#18085704)
The simple way would be to use part of the hash for the domain and part for the user. If you alternated bits it wouldn't be obvious.

I doubt it'd be worth spending the effort to target people with personal domains though, and it would have some negative effects, so your point is well taken.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by tener on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:27AM (#18085394)
If the hashing algorithm is known (and my guess is it is at least possible to reverse engineer it, if it isn't documrnted) then cracking a hash with a GPU may be quite feasible.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by jsjohnst on Thursday September 27, 2018 @05:59PM (#18089166)
The hashing algorithm is well known, it’s unsalted md5/sha1/sha256. That doesn’t make it necessarily possible (sure, some cases yes, but not even most), let alone feasible, to rainbow table them.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by Bhilai on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:07PM (#18086473)
Its pretty simple to crack unsalted hashes using rainbow tables, unless each hash is salted with a random distinct salt and if that is the case then these hash seem pretty useless. So how do tracking providers use these hash ? What other info is sent along with the hash ?
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by jsjohnst on Thursday September 27, 2018 @05:55PM (#18089132)
> So how do tracking providers use these hash?

They use it to match traffic across devices and IP addresses.

> pretty simple to crack unsalted hashes

Go ahead and rainbow table those hashes then. If you do it and are the first one to email me (email address in profile), I’ll pay you $100.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by ardy42 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:48AM (#18084419)
> Isn't this it though, the engineers designing the ad targeting system at Facebook is linking the random emails you use as "catch all" to your main identity so you can be targeted specifically even though neither party has full knowledge of the linkage between your catchall email and your main identity email.

If you use the method described in the grandparent, you use a unique email address for every site (e.g [email protected], [email protected], etc). The domain will be the common part, which would be very hard for a company to use because most domains are shared between many separate users.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by barkingcat on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:08AM (#18084597)
This is no longer "just a little bit of effort and minimal cost" - most likely no one will use unique emails for every site as well as use private browsing mode permanently in order to avoid cross cookie / cross site contamination via 3rd party (non facebook) tracking. Which is cited as a "feature" - allowing clients to bring their own ad tracking database and integrating that into the FB one in order to make ad targeting more specific.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by jsjohnst on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:02PM (#18089188)
> most likely no one will use unique emails for every site

I do and have done so for over 10 years. It’s been very eye opening to say the least to see how many sites have leaked my email.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by 394549 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:38PM (#18086816)
> This is no longer "just a little bit of effort and minimal cost" - most likely no one will use unique emails for every site

It takes a tiny amount of effort: you setup your domain with a wildcard so all you need to do to create a new email address is to use it. You could send mail to [email protected] right now, and it will be delivered to my inbox with no setup required.

It's also great in case you start spamming me. I don't have to struggle with your unsubscribe links, I can just blacklist all mail sent to [email protected], and be done with it without any collateral damage.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by tjoff on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:12AM (#18085250)
Lots of people do this, in the past it has exposed data leaks.

My if my site-specific email giqjtodvdksu@... has been getting spam lately then it is likely that either they sold it or they got hacked.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by will_brown on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:40AM (#18085534)
>Lots of people do this...

You mean a very small percentage of FB users do this?

The point being as parent comment said it’s not “a little effort and minimal cost”. Figure a $10-15 overhead cost for the domain and maybe $5/month/e-mail account? Effectively to minimize tracking on Facebook one would have to spend a minimum of $70/year?

It doesn’t seem like a great solution...go with a “free product” like Facebook in exchange allowing them to collect and monetize your data, only to pay to combat their business model? May as well offer a competing service that doesn’t track you, collect/monetize your data and pay say...half the cost of a domain and email.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by tjoff on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:41PM (#18086843)
No, it sucks, but it is the only way.

> May as well offer a competing service that doesn’t track you

I would kill for that. But this day and age it would be hard. Also, even subscription services typically see fit to track you and serve you ads.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by njarboe on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:50PM (#18087523)
Sort of like at first people thought paying for cable tv would mean that there would be lots of channels without ads. Didn't happen. Only a few where you get to pay even more for now ads. Now Netflix begins the cycle anew.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by hiccuphippo on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:34AM (#18084874)
It is completely possible to fingerprint a browser and then group all the email accounts used on it and treat them as a single user. When was the last time you lent your device to someone so they could check their email?
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by daveFNbuck on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:16AM (#18085291)
Google claims that multiple people checking their e-mail in the same browser is common enough that they had to redesign browser log-in around it.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by jchanimal on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:12PM (#18085837)
Doing this seems like it would slow down an adversary with Facebook like capabilities for a handful of milliseconds.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by gruez on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:24AM (#18084185)
>Then use [email protected] and your email address is no longer a cross site unique identifier.

unless sites smarten up and realize [email protected] is the same person as [email protected], especially when johndoe.com isn't a "common" email domain like hotmail.com

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by lancesells on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:32AM (#18085431)
As someone that has created a facebook account with an unused email without using my name or any information they still recommend my friends, family and interests. Instagram did the same thing with my interests.

There's a lot more going on than linking email addresses.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by cmroanirgo on Friday September 28, 2018 @06:48AM (#18092362)
If you used an app (rather than just a website), then all your contacts were uploaded. (Instagram has always been an app, hasn't it?)
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by jsjohnst on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:37AM (#18084321)
Most marketing companies don’t share raw email addresses (rather md5/sha1/sha256 hashes of the emails). In that scenario, linking the common domain name is very difficult to near impossible to do currently.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by codedokode on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:06PM (#18085780)
This is not what an average user of Facebook can do. What an average user can do is demand adopting laws like GDPR to regulate PII.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by kozikow on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:46AM (#18084396)
You can do it with Gmail to some extent already. E.g. instead of using [email protected] I would use [email protected]. Gmail ignores anything after the plus. As someone mentioned, marketing companies usually share just the hash of email. The trick is not too popular and I didn't experience a company handling it yet.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by krageon on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:17AM (#18084681)
A vast majority of companies either don't accept the plus because they are too lazy to implement proper email validation, or they strip the pluses from gmail addresses because they're strictly useless to them.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by Mathnerd314 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:52AM (#18085644)
Then you can use dots. An 11-character email has 2^10=1024 different addresses.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by asaph on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:28AM (#18084826)
The "trick" is both popular and commonly made to be moot by programmers. Source: I know programmers at multiple companies that have written production code to strip the +suffix from the username portion of gmail addresses.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by Breza on Sunday September 30, 2018 @01:18PM (#18107113)
Agreed. This isn't done just for ad targeting, either. If a user invokes a GDPR right to be forgotten, it's useful to make sure you've found all the instances of that user's email address in your system regardless of the +additions.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by chainsaw10 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:44AM (#18084975)
If someone does that with one of my (custom domain) addresses, it won’t work, here’s what I implemented: https://zackorndorff.com/2015/03/10/disposable-email-address...

(To save you a click, they look like [email protected], with shorthash being based on COMPANY and a secret)

Downside is the address ends up absurdly long, and I’ve had to manually create some aliases for companies that won’t accept the plus.

I don’t recommend this setup, it’s kind of a pain to maintain, but I wish one of the mainstream providers would implement something similar.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by cmroanirgo on Friday September 28, 2018 @06:47AM (#18092349)
I've been typically using [email protected] to distinguish email origins (and leakage). Ironically, I've already set up [email protected] to hide registrar information, but hadn't thought of using it for day-to-day signups until now.

I think I'll extend the latter (and reduce the required Spam score) before it gets sent to my inbox.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by otachack on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:27AM (#18083789)
You don't have to but it's the most user-friendly, although flawed, method of enabling 2FA. They could have easily used a software token but that requires non-tech savvy users to download a 3rd party authentication app, as well as understand the basic usage. Why do that when users can simply get a text sent on a method they most likely have?
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by qrbLPHiKpiux on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:17AM (#18083242)
I never heard of this company when I did a monitor.firefox.com search of my work address.

Exactis Breach date:June 1, 2018 Compromised accounts:131,577,763

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by tumetab1 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:23AM (#18083261)
https://haveibeenpwned.com/PwnedWebsites

> Compromised data: Credit status information, Dates of birth, Education levels, Email addresses, Ethnicities, Family structure, Financial investments, Genders, Home ownership statuses, Income levels, IP addresses, Marital statuses, Names, Net worths, Occupations, Personal interests, Phone numbers, Physical addresses, Religions, Spoken languages

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by TangoTrotFox on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:30AM (#18084249)
It's also something that people should have expected. I don't understand how people have not noticed that all of the major sites that generate revenue through user profiling and advertising have been pushing hard for users to either be obligated to register using their phone, or to setup a two factor authentication using their phone when it's not necessary for registration.

The reason I say it's something people should have expected is because if people were more critical of the things asked of them, then things like this would never get off the ground. Instead, because people do not seem inclined to naturally believe that corporations might have ulterior motives, such practice has become common place and on some sites even mandatory.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by rchaud on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:41AM (#18084948)
> Instead, because people do not seem inclined to naturally believe that corporations might have ulterior motives

People worship at the altar of success, and there aren't many relatively new companies as profitable as FB. That's not to say that these companies don't spend significant coin in pushing their inane message of "we're connecting the world" wherever they can. And mass media for the most part go along with it, mostly focusing on the stock price, rarely bothering to examine how FB makes its money and what tradeoffs that comes with.

Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by dymk on Thursday September 27, 2018 @03:52PM (#18087973)
How is a difference in how ads are targeted a punishment?
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by samstave on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:43PM (#18086868)
Somewhere in the bowels of FB is the product manager who feels like a smug genius for coming up with this 'feature'.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by propman on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:43PM (#18087452)
There has to be a reason Facebook reminds me 50 times (yes 50 times) a year to put my phone number in for security reasons. That’s extremely unethical tbh and then I can’t recall if this is true because I’ve stopped using Facebook but I’m 80% sure they then filled out my phone number and just wanted me to confirm it.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by matz1 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @03:18PM (#18087729)
I'm using adblock, how does this affect me ?
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by kevin_b_er on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:13PM (#18087180)
Ethics do not matter vs profit, so long as the elected representatives can be properly paid off and the public lied to that regulation is always bad.
Re:Facebook Is Giving Advertisers Access To Your Shadow Cont... by gammateam on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:45AM (#18085585)
It is unethical and negligent to force people to use SMS 2fa without any other alternative

It is OBVIOUSLY for ad targeting, I think I mentioned it not even two weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18020177