It’s also helpful when you use a key that lives in a machine to not have to remove it. If you lose the machine, use another key to sign in and disavow the lost key.
If I have one key and someone takes it, I know it immediately.
If I have 2 keys and someone steals my spare, then I might not realize it for quite some time.
With AWS you are the company, and you should be allowed to set your own policy, and decide things like whether you trust yourself enough to store a backup key in a safe or something similar.
Suggesting Amazon should treat you like some employee of theirs is silly.
But for personal accounts, solo founders, travellers etc this is a no-go.
Really? I'd expect someone who's paying $50 for a yubikey to spend another $100 to have a backup key, a key for their laptop, and one for their desktop. Add another one for your keychain if you are using it on your phone (if your phone supports it).
Maybe techie personal users have more than one, but I only carry one device (a yubikey) for work, someone at work can reset my MFA if I lose it.
I'd be surprised if "most" people have a backup device/codes.