Re:Show HN: A new protocol for packet radio including ECDSA ...
by glockenspielen on Monday September 24, 2018 @02:25PM
(#18060033)
FEC is forward error correction. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forward_error_correction
Re:Show HN: A new protocol for packet radio including ECDSA ...
by moftz on Monday September 24, 2018 @01:34PM
(#18059606)
AX.25 has no FEC but there is FX.25 which is an encapsulation of the AX.25 packet with a preamble at the front and reed soloman at the end. But the issue is the speed of AX.25, 1200baud is dreadfully slow to be adding much onto the packet. The FX.25 protocol is a neat idea that allows for old TNC hardware to still be on the air. However, TNCs can be built with the cheapest of the raspberry pi clones so there really is no good reason as to why things can't progress to something like FX.25. There are certainly limitation to using 1200 baud AFSK but moving outside of the audio band, you could get some higher data rate but maybe loose some dB.
Re:Show HN: A new protocol for packet radio including ECDSA ...
by Steltek on Monday September 24, 2018 @02:22PM
(#18060000)
The stagnation of packet radio is due to FCC legal restrictions on data rate that are divorced from the reality of bandwidth usage in modern protocols.
You need to get to UHF before doing anything reasonable (if you call 56k reasonable) and by then, your range is toast unless your friend is on top of a mountain.
Re:Show HN: A new protocol for packet radio including ECDSA ...
by aidenn0 on Monday September 24, 2018 @12:53PM
(#18059222)
Does AFSK imply the use more than two frequencies? Using 4 or 8 frequencies and trellis modulating should get significant gain (i.e. using 4 frequencies and trellis modulating 1 bit per chip should be more robust than using just 2 frequencies).
Re:Show HN: A new protocol for packet radio including ECDSA ...
by someguydave on Monday September 24, 2018 @01:10PM
(#18059399)
AFSK, as used in amateur radio modems today, uses the Bell 202 modem standard, which is 2-ary FSK https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_202_modem
Unfortunately, most folks on the VHF/UHF bands use FM radios with pre-emphasis and de-emphasis circuitry, so you would need to design a waveform that deals with those challenges.
Re:Show HN: A new protocol for packet radio including ECDSA ...
by Evidlo on Monday September 24, 2018 @01:48PM
(#18059720)
Also known as binary frequency shift keying (BFSK).
Re:Show HN: A new protocol for packet radio including ECDSA ...
by vvanders on Monday September 24, 2018 @01:06PM
(#18059355)
Nope, just two pairs of bell tones on the same frequency.
Simple FEC just works pretty well with parity bits, just needs to be supported on all encoder/decoders.
Re:Show HN: A new protocol for packet radio including ECDSA ...
by mycall on Monday September 24, 2018 @08:59PM
(#18062762)
Could FEC be considered a form of encryption?
Re:Show HN: A new protocol for packet radio including ECDSA ...
by myself248 on Monday September 24, 2018 @09:09PM
(#18062799)
No, just like speaking in phonetics isn't encryption. It doesn't hide the content of the message, it just adds extra data to make it easier to recover in the case of noise.
FEC could be mistaken for encryption if the algorithm wasn't published, but the same could be said for pretty much any other digital mode. Even Morse...
From what I've seen out there would be a 40% improvement[1] in just base APRS if there was some form of basic FEC built into the protocol. Sadly most of "state of the art" is stuck back in the 80s.
[1] http://eludium.stensat.org/mcguire/projects/FX-25/FX-25_perf...