News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by ugh on Monday October 18, 2010 @05:24PM (#1805225)
Steve Jobs is just now highlighting Android’s “fragmentation” and discussing Android’s openness. He is also talking about upcoming tablets and their 7" screens. (Trash talking them, that is. No 7" screen from Apple anytime soon.) Ars Technica is blogging: http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2010/10/liveblog-q4-2010-e...
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by solutionyogi on Monday October 18, 2010 @05:31PM (#1805249)
Select Q&A:

Q: What do you think about the 7" tablets?

A: one naturally thinks a 7" screen offers 70% of the benefits of a 10" screen, but this is far from the truth a 7% screen is only 45% as large as a 10% screen because the measurements are diagonal. This size isn't sufficient to create great tablet apps, in our opinion. One could increase the resolution to make up for the difference, it's meaningless unless the thing also includes sandpaper so users can sand down their fingers.

Another comment by Steve:

"It's being grabbed out of our hands. I talk to people every day in every kind of business who are using iPads boards of directors, nurses, doctors, etc. The more time that passes, the more i am convinced that we have a tiger by the tail here."

Q: Could this be your second biggest business behind iPhone?

A: I try not to predict, I just report.

Q: Any updates on you stance on Flash?

A: Ah, Flash memory? We love Flash memory! [I wonder if the reporter who asked the question understood the joke. ;)]

Q: So if the market starts to move toward lower-functionality smartphones and dramatically lower price points, and you feel you can't make an appropriate product on those price points, you'll throw in the towel?

A: You're looking at it wrong. you're looking at it as a hardware person who doesn't know much about software. who doesn't think about an integrated product and thinks the software will just take care of itself. You assume the software will just somehow come alive on this product you're dreaming up, but it won't. Because these app developers are taking advantage of products that came before it, with larger screens and more capabilities. it throws you back to the beginning of the chicken and egg problem again most developers won't follow you.

Pure gold from Steve. Competitors better listen to this call and learn from the man himself.

-------------------------------------------------

You really gotta hand it to Steve. Absolute no corporate speak (aka bullshit) when he talks. Compare this with recent email from Steve Ballmer,

"I sent a message to the world that we’re ‘all in’ when it comes to the cloud. In that speech I noted that Ray’s Internet Services Disruption memo nearly five years ago, and his work since, stimulated thinking across the company and helped catalyze our drive to the cloud." (from http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/press/2010/oct10/10-18ste... )

Cloud? Why do executive use the word 'cloud' when the word 'Internet' is so much better. 'Stimulated thinking'... 'catalyze our drive', looks like someone has been reading too much of Dilbert.

The difference between Steve Jobs and Steve Ballmer is staggering.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by butterfi on Monday October 18, 2010 @06:39PM (#1805447)
Interesting article in WSJ about some research around the language used by lying CEO's:

http://blogs.wsj.com/deals/2010/08/11/how-can-you-tell-if-a-...

I'm not saying Ballmers lying, it's just interesting to read the quote above after reading the article.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by kenjackson on Monday October 18, 2010 @06:41PM (#1805454)
Actually the term "cloud" and "internet" generally mean different things. The cloud refers to services sitting on endpoints that you don't maintain (or likely don't own either).

The internet generally refers to the communication infrastructure between endpoints. You can be all in on the internet and not care about the cloud. The opposite is more difficult though.

Also Steve's 7" answer seemed odd. The iPod Touch is a 3.5" tablet. He's saying that he can't figure out how to create a device that made good use of twice the diagonal?

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by jsz0 on Monday October 18, 2010 @07:39PM (#1805594)
I think his point was the size of the human finger creates some hard limitations for multi-touch UI design. So at any resolution a 7" tablet isn't going to offer the physical space required to significantly increase the number of tap targets on screen. As a result you're probably going to end up with applications that look, feel and operate more like a SmartPhone app though with less scrolling & resizing. I believe this might be partly negated by the way Android hides so much functionality under the Menu button. You possibly don't need significantly more tap targets on-screen at any given time in Android to have a good workable tablet UI. It does water down the whole multi-touch experience by adding a layer of abstraction to the UI. Direct manipulation is the real magic of multi-touch and that's lost when we start working with multi-step procedural UI checklists to do common tasks.
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by kenjackson on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:11PM (#1805671)
OK. I get what you're saying, but I think it is BS myself. And to be perfectly honest I think Steve thinks its BS too. And they'll be working on it until the day he says, "A lot of people have said 'Steve, a 7" tablet would be great'. Well today we have something a lot better than great".

Anyone who thinks you can't do a differentiated multitouch 7" UI is either lying or incompetent. Steve is clearly not the latter. My prediction is that within the next 18 months they release a 7" iPad. Sooner if a 7" Android tablet takes off.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by thought_alarm on Monday October 18, 2010 @09:26PM (#1805821)
What software will this 7" iOS device run? iPad software shrunk down 50% in size, or iPhone software expanded 50% is size?

Neither works. Neither is compelling. UI design is fundamentally different between a 4" screen and a 10" screen, regardless of the actual screen resolution.

The only reason people are talking about 7" tablets because Android 2.2 is absolutely ridiculous on a 10" screen (see previous paragraph). It's also a way for these manufacturers to compete on price with the iPad.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by glhaynes on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:18PM (#1805687)
It's just hard for me to see what value a 7" iPad would bring. Just as Steve said, I can't pocket it, so I still have to have a smartphone. And if I'm going to use something other than my smartphone (which Steve went out of his way today to say that most iPad buyers already have), why would I want to use something only slightly bigger? If anything, the 10" iPad is too small.

The concern isn't that Apple couldn't make a variant of iOS run well on a 7" tablet: it's that the product itself doesn't really have a purpose for being, and that it's asking too much for app makers to target (well) three different sizes that are so close to each other.

(Now, is the current iPad too heavy? Yes. I strongly expect the next iPad revision to be 9.7" and 1/3rd lighter.)

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by kenjackson on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:32PM (#1805719)
I disagree almost across the board with you. The 10" iPad is just too big for me to feel comfortable carrying around (and yes, it is too heavy. That is the main reason I returned mine).

The problem today is that I have a phone that is really too small to be super useful. I've made considerable concessions, but really browsing and apps on the iPhone kind of suck. It's just they suck a LOT less than phone apps used to. And given the relative infrequency for which I talk on the phone, why do I want to have the phone drive the size of this device?

At about 7" I have an adequate mobile experience, and I can stop using my phone for things it really isn't very good at.

With that said, I'll take a 10" tablet at .75 pounds, which folds in half to the width of something like the Samsung Galaxy tab today (and of course, unfolded there is no visible seam).

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by glhaynes on Monday October 18, 2010 @09:35PM (#1805840)
Please stop downvoting this post. My sentiments are not the same as kenjackson's, but his are valid and well-expressed. Reply if you disagree with him, but there's no reason to downvote.
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by roc on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @12:18PM (#1807635)
Do you have a 7" tablet?
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by kenjackson on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @12:36PM (#1807710)
I've used one, but I don't own one. I do plan on owning one soon though. I was anticipating owning a 7" iPad early 2011, but now it appears that it'll likely be a 7" Android 3.0 device. I have owned a 10" iPad though.
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by roc on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @01:13PM (#1807863)
I'm just wondering what device it was, and what tasks it did better than the phone, to the extent that you'd carry it around.

Because I'm having a hard time seeing what tasks would be notably better on a half-ipad-sized screen. Reading would be better than a phone, sure. Videos, sure. But beyond that, I'm not sure what the draw is.

It seems any task beyond those two (consumption, the very thing people dismissed the ipad as only being good for) would suffer from the lack of significantly increased tap real-estate.

I mean, even the keyboard itself would have to be annoying. In portrait, it'd be little-better than a phone and in landscape it's the same width as the ipad's portrait keyboard, which is just not good. (far too narrow to touch-type, but too wide to thumb-type[1])

And I can't say I'd be optimistic about Android app developers notably filling the gap at the outset. Even if they can figure out how to add capability in that space, with the array of screen sizes on their way, I wouldn't want to gamble on how much attention they'll be spending on any one screen size. Not until there's some shake-out and consolidation.

I recall that you had and disliked an iPad. It just seems odd to me that you'd dismiss the iPad as not being useful enough, yet jump on the bandwagon for a device that is inherently less-useful.

It'll be smaller and lighter. But still large enough that it's not going in your pocket. So what's the draw?

[1] and that's coming from a fairly large-handed fellow; I found the original xbox "duke" controller to be the most comfortable gamepad I'd ever held.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by kenjackson on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @02:17PM (#1808109)
First, I disliked the iPad, but the main reason was the weight of the device. Besides the weight I think it is a pretty great device, especially with iOS 4. (Although I don't believe it is a laptop replacement).

So actually it is two devices I've used: The Archos Home Tablet 7 and the Samsung Galaxy Tab. The Samsung was way better. The Archos has a resistive display which makes it hard to navigate and a REALLY slow processor. But in terms of button size and general UI layout, both do a good job.

For me the big app draws are those you listed, videos, reading ebooks, but also general web navigation and maps.

The keyboard on the Galaxy is better than the iPad keyboard. In part due to the size. The same reason I prefer portrait sliders over landscape sliders for phones.

My use for a tablet is almost all consumption. This is in part why I think the 7" form factor is so great. I don't pretend this is a laptop replacement.

And the Galaxy tab fit into the pocket on my jeans, admittedly I have them really loose and they have pretty big pockets. But it will also fit comfortable in an inside jacket pocket or a purse.

But the price needs to come down. Even if I prefer a 7" form factor, I'm not going to pay the same price as a 10" form factor. I'll just feel cheated. But I expect we'll see good 7" Android tablets for $299 in the next six months -- if the Tab comes down to that price, I'd get it.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by lotharbot on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:49PM (#1805749)
The latest kindle has a 6" screen (which could be expanded to 7" without changing the form factor) and I can fit it in my coat pocket or my wife's purse easily, and my pants pocket with just a little fiddling to get the angle right. It also fits well in the side pouch of my kid's diaper bag.

I find the size far more convenient than larger devices. I'd much rather have a generic prepaid phone and a kindle-sized pad than an iPhone and a 10" iPad.

There's plenty of room for a roughly 7" tablet of some sort to enter the market.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by ugh on Monday October 18, 2010 @06:49PM (#1805472)
I believe Jobs was talking about fragmentation. You would have to especially adapt the UI for a 7" device, like you have to especially adapt the UI for a 3.5" and 10" device. You can’t just shrink it down or blow it up.

Jobs seems to believe that Apple shouldn’t fragment their product line any further. He seems to think that 3.5" (pocketable) and 10" (more stationary and more capable) are sort of local optima and that Apple should stick to those.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by glhaynes on Monday October 18, 2010 @07:06PM (#1805516)
Yep. And he made it sound specifically like they think of 10" as a minimum for the iPad line, not necessarily a maximum.

Edit: I've always thought that was the biggest problem with a 7" Apple device: either you have to scale 3.5" iPhone apps up or 9.7" iPad apps down. Neither of which is optimal. And I don't believe you're gonna be able to (or even that you want to) get devs to adapt their existing apps for a third "sub-platform".

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by solutionyogi on Monday October 18, 2010 @06:52PM (#1805483)
Can you give me some example of 'cloud' services? Aren't they web application/services?

And Apple classifies iPod touch as portable music player/gaming device and not 3.5" tablet.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by kenjackson on Monday October 18, 2010 @07:03PM (#1805506)
Cloud services don't have to be web services, although it is becoming more common that they are.

FTP sites are often hosted for a single user or small group of users who host and maintain the site. They own the burden of full site upkeep. It's not something that sits in this "cloud", but its a service on the internet that they maintain.

There's another thing that is implicit about cloud services, which is why I choose the FTP example, which is that the content on the service that is of most value is the content you, the user put in the service. So CNN.com, while a service on the internet, isn't generally considered a cloud service. Whereas FaceBook, Flickr, and GMail are examples of cloud services.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by allenp on Monday October 18, 2010 @07:04PM (#1805512)
There are many cloud services not tied to the web - an example is a service that replaces tape backups (for enterprise data) by letting you stream the data to an online service.
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by ugh on Monday October 18, 2010 @05:35PM (#1805260)
Aw, cute!

Q: Any updates on you stance on Flash?

A: Ah, Flash memory? We love Flash memory!

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by marze on Monday October 18, 2010 @06:20PM (#1805398)
There were rumors of an Apple 7" device earlier this year. I wonder if they were deliberately started by Apple to send competitors down what they considered a blind alley.
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by cletus on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @01:15AM (#1806298)
I don't buy into this kind of conspiracy thinking.

Apple builds more products than it releases. It's entirely possible (if not probable) that Apple developed a 7" prototype. Just like I'm sure there's been a CDMA iPhone prototype. That means nothing however. Just because there is/was a prototype doesn't mean there will be a product.

I believe the 7" competitors come down to two things:

1. The competitors might feel like they need to differentiate themselves from the iPad; or, more likely,

2. Apple has tied up the world supply of 10" capacitative touch screens so the competitors needed to go for parts they could get.

Unfortunately a lot of these Apple rumours are started and propagated by people who simply don't understand how Apple operates or are simply link-baiting.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by marze on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @05:26AM (#1806600)
On the outside it is of course impossible to know. But if you listen to Steve Jobs speak, you see he has healthy sense of humor. I would guess if Apple did feint in the 7" direction earlier this year, Steve probably got a big kick out of now slamming competitors for following. Probably not as big a kick as he got from his comments about the PC being the "truck" to the iPad "automobile" that only farmers will still use, after in 2007 in his joint interview at All Things Digital with Bill Gates when he stated that PCs and mobile devices would coexist in a PC-centric ecosystem, but fun nonetheless. By 2007 the iPhone design was basically complete as were Apple's plans to supplant the PC.

In this earnings call, Jobs basically ranted about how it isn't Open vs Closed that is important. This is probably aimed at solidifying the competition's commitment to an Open system and making them less likely to switch to Closed and "admit Apple was right", when the "Closed" nature of Apple's devices is a critical competitive advantage of the Apple platform.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by CamperBob on Monday October 18, 2010 @10:51PM (#1806010)
More likely Apple's feverishly working on a 7" device but it wasn't ready to be announced yet. This is a recurring trope in Steve Jobs's speeches -- slag an idea as being unworkable or undesirable, only to announce it at the next major conference.
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by leviathant on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @12:14PM (#1807609)
I'm not sure why you got downvoted for that. It's demonstrably true that Jobs has talked down certain product lines before releasing something in that field. Remember that post-iPhone joint talk with Steve Jobs and Bill Gates, where Bill Gates was all about the tablet-format computer, and Steve Jobs dismissed that, focusing instead on the phone?

When the iPhone first came out, third-party development was, in Jobs mind, to be relegated to HTML and javascript. John Carmack had 'a fairly heated argument' with Jobs that had him saying "I have an iPhone right now and it's a platform I would enjoy developing for but Apple is not taking progressing steps in regards to [gaming]."

I' sure there are more (better) examples, but I think it's a pretty safe bet that when Steve Jobs ramps up the negative rhetoric towards something, Apple is simultaneously testing and developing something along the lines of that thing being dissed.

Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by DougBTX on Monday October 18, 2010 @06:50PM (#1805474)
Not wanting to point out the obvious, but Apple is the leading seller of 3.5 inch tablets - the iPod touch.
Re:Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results by ugh on Monday October 18, 2010 @06:51PM (#1805479)
I’m only quoting Jobs here, not presenting my own opinion but I think I can shed some light on that point: iPad and iPod touch do not use the same UI, they do not have the same intended uses. Jobs obviously seems to think that 3.5" (where you sacrifice functionality for compactness) and 10" (where you sacrifice compactness for functionality) are local optima.