Re:Airbnb asks SEC to let it give hosts equity
by stale2002 on Sunday September 23, 2018 @02:10PM
(#18052337)
This misrepresents what Citizens United was about.
The idea of Citizens United was not that corporations are people, and therefore have free speech rights.
It is instead that corporation is just another word for "groups of people", and that groups of people retain their rights, even when they join together to do something.
Re:Airbnb asks SEC to let it give hosts equity
by gammateam on Monday September 24, 2018 @12:36AM
(#18055055)
The comment wasn't about Citizens United, it was about hiring the same law firm for representation because they're good
OHHH I think you thought that was the case law I referring to! There will be plenty
Re:Airbnb asks SEC to let it give hosts equity
by xevb3k on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:26AM
(#18051195)
Could someone spell this out for me, I don’t really understand how speech is chilled here.
Re:Airbnb asks SEC to let it give hosts equity
by evbots on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:34AM
(#18051241)
I think the line of reasoning here is that money == speech
Re:Airbnb asks SEC to let it give hosts equity
by arkades on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:29AM
(#18051216)
Because spending money is now “speech:”
Re:Airbnb asks SEC to let it give hosts equity
by toast0 on Sunday September 23, 2018 @11:22AM
(#18051455)
The real question is if this is meaningful stock ownership or not. If it's meaningful ownership, then the company needs to do the public disclosure. Otherwise it's very hard for the stockholders to have the right information to value the stock.
I think you could do the disclosures, not have a public offering, include restrictive covenants on sales, and be able to give shares away.
Re:Airbnb asks SEC to let it give hosts equity
by Kinnard on Sunday September 23, 2018 @10:48AM
(#18051295)
Flagger, why did you flag this comment? I think it's an excellent comment.
Re:Airbnb asks SEC to let it give hosts equity
by usaphp on Sunday September 23, 2018 @11:01AM
(#18051352)
Not a flagged but maybe because of caps?
Re:Airbnb asks SEC to let it give hosts equity
by bogomipz on Sunday September 23, 2018 @12:35PM
(#18051836)
>"Any federal district judge in the country can say these aspects of the Exchange Act (and the Securities Act) chills speech."
Could you elaborate on how and why this provision(701) chills free speech? Thanks.
Any federal district judge in the country can say these aspects of the Exchange Act (and the Securities Act) chills speech. The only reason this hasn't been challenged is because it doesn't affect accredited investors like you, and the people it does affect don't even know it affects them BECAUSE THE SPEECH IS CHILLED!
Please help. These laws are nearing 100 years old, but it has only been the last 20 or so where its been a problem because companies are going public so late as well as few and far between, all while the market efficiencies have improved enough where it makes sense to easily give out equity and things that may be construed as securities. But these laws have always chilled speech and recent case law can be used to extend "free speech" into corporate and financial matters. So please, go for it! Hire the same law firm that did Citizens United, they always go for 1st amendment no matter what the context!