News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by voltagex_ on Friday September 21, 2018 @03:08AM (#18037730)
>Motorola’s use of a single QFUSE that must be blown to unlock the device, permanently voiding the warranty.

If this isn't illegal (the warranty part), it should be.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by drdaeman on Friday September 21, 2018 @03:50AM (#18037931)
Not that simple. Depends on what warranty is on.

Hardware warranty shouldn't be generally affected, unless it's about parts that can fail because of software malfunction - e.g. when failsafes are defined in user-overridable software. It is fair that a hardware vendor shouldn't be responsible for user e.g. overclocking something.

Software warranty should be voided. Although I can't remember when it was the last time I saw a warranty for software, explicit or implied. Rather, I believe there's an explicit dismissal of any warranties in every single licensing agreement out there.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by taneq on Friday September 21, 2018 @08:18AM (#18039132)
My phone's screen sometimes wouldn't come back on after a phone call. The sound quality transmitted was sometimes terrible. Both of those things present as hardware problems (prox sensor, microphone) but turned out to be software related. How would you prove that a hardware problem's not actually software?

As an aside, LineageOS seems to have been getting gradually more buggy on my Nexus 5X. 15.1 has the two issues above, plus Bluetooth music streaming is broken and crashes the music player. I reverted to an old 14.1 ROM and everything works perfectly.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by craftyguy on Friday September 21, 2018 @10:53AM (#18040109)
> As an aside, LineageOS seems to have been getting gradually more buggy on my Nexus 5X. 15.1 has the two issues above, plus Bluetooth music streaming is broken and crashes the music player.

I have none of those problems with 15.1 on my nexus 5x, but I also make it a point to install the latest weekly updates and the latest vendor partition blob.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by taneq on Friday September 21, 2018 @11:47AM (#18040548)
Maybe I set it up wrong, then? My basic install flow:

- Get latest nightly build from lineageos.org

- Get matching factory image from Google and extract vendor and radio images from it

- Install TWRP

- Do a full wipe of the phone

- Install LineageOS, vendor image and radio image

Then when an OTA update came out, I'd install it and update the vendor image manually if it complained.

What'd I miss?

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by craftyguy on Friday September 21, 2018 @11:53AM (#18040584)
That seems about right, and similar to what I do. Maybe it's a hardware issue? I also don't use the default music app for streaming music over bluetooth, so it could be an issue with that..
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by taneq on Friday September 21, 2018 @12:20PM (#18040759)
Yeah, I assumed it was hardware (there's a known issue with some 5Xes with poor mic quality) but I've gone back to 14.1 and all is fixed, so meh. The only thing I really miss is the new power saving features and I can live with charging every two days instead of every three days.
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by craftyguy on Friday September 21, 2018 @12:37PM (#18040882)
> I can live with charging every two days instead of every three days.

Yea it's incredible how long the battery lasts on this device, compared to previous nexus devices (though I never owned a nexus 5..) I've only ever run lineageos on this thing and regularly get multiple days on a charge with light/moderate usage. I once took it on a 8 day backpacking trip where it was powered on but in airplane mode (to serve as camera and backup map), got out of the wilderness with something like 40% battery left. IMHO that really shows how much negative impact on performance google's shit has on a mobile device when it can last that long without it.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by TheChaplain on Friday September 21, 2018 @03:50AM (#18037934)
I believe Samsung have/had something similar, though it doesn't blow on unlocking but only if you insert an unsigned kernel.
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by lozaning on Friday September 21, 2018 @05:04AM (#18038249)
It's also my understanding the rooting a samsung phone will forever disable samsung pay from working on it ever again.
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by diaz on Friday September 21, 2018 @05:25AM (#18038349)
Haven't installed a rom on my sony xperia yet because it explicitly said in a few places that doing that voids the warranty. I still have around 1 year and half of waiting until mandatory warranty ends so I can feel ol with doing it.
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by mjones72 on Friday September 21, 2018 @03:50AM (#18037932)
It is illegal.
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by gehsty on Friday September 21, 2018 @04:03AM (#18037990)
Yep and if the teacher doesn’t arrive in 10 minutes you can legally leave the class room.

Come on. If you modify the device to work in a way it wasn’t intended (eg overclocked) you have clearly voided the warranty. This is what this is there to detect.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by hyperman1 on Friday September 21, 2018 @05:18AM (#18038313)
Most western countries already had this discussion.

There were car makers voiding warranties when users replaced a tire. They gave the same arguments: Users modifying the car might do anything, so better give them no chance, as nobody could ever walk safely on the streets again.

Wiser heads prevailed, and e.g. the USA created the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. It is today legal to replace tires on your car. It is nevertheless illegal to make it non-street-worthy. If you stupidly damage your car while replacing a tire, you do in fact void your wararanty. If reality isn't clear enough, a judge decides. While streets might not be that safe, it is extremely rare that modified vehicles are part of the problem. The system works.

Why do we have to rediscuss all of this again? Exactly the same idea is applicable to software.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by gehsty on Saturday September 22, 2018 @03:54AM (#18045009)
I’d say this is more like remapping the ecu, not really like changing tires...if you mapped the ecu to run in an unsafe way (increased engine pressure etc) then you have voided the warranty.
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by hyperman1 on Saturday September 22, 2018 @09:10AM (#18045835)
You made 2 independent changes to this example: Replace tire with ECU, and add 'in an unsafe way'.

The important point is that the second of your changes is the one that voided the warranty: Replacing the tire to run in an unsafe way will void your warranty too. Modifying the ECU, on itself, doesn't do anything to the warranty.

And it is up to the manufacturer to prove your specific modification is unsafe. Claiming that some parts are inherently so complex that any change voids your warranty is legal bullshit for cars.

If I understand your argument well, it is that for cell phones the OS is so complex that any person on this planet should be declared unfit to make changes to it, except the manufacturer.

* First of all, the very audience of this site disproves this statement. Note the 'hacker' in hacker news.

* Second, I invite you to take a look to the garbage you find in most software powering our hardware. Someone going trough the effort to examine a device and create a modification is almost guaranteed to create better quality. There is something Darwinian going on here: Software mods, when they are supported for some time, give by their very existence away something of the persistent and qualified nature of their creator (otherwise they would not have been published).

* Third, the nature of software is that it is hard to create and easy to copy. Only 1 person has to create the firmware modification. The rest of us can copy it. This is exactly the reverse of the tire example and makes firmware mods a lot more easy.

UPDATE: After rereading, this post sees a bit harsh and a personal attack. So let me add that I have respect for your 2 posts. You provide a valid viewpoint in a reasonably toned, adult post. I also respond to more than can be found in your posts alone. I disagree with people downvoting you. I do however respectfully believe your viewpoint is incorrect and dangerous.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by mjones72 on Friday September 21, 2018 @04:31AM (#18038096)
https://fsfe.org/freesoftware/legal/flashingdevices.en.html

You are moving the goalposts, because we were talking about "changing the ROM", not about "changing the ROM and then doing something that will fuck the hardware up"

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by gehsty on Saturday September 22, 2018 @03:58AM (#18045016)
I think it’s fair for a device manufacturer to say you have voided the warranty if you load a 3rd party ROM onto the device, the device manufacturer has no control over the 3rd party software, how safe it is to run etc. If the 3rd party rom bricks the device why should the supplier pick up the bill when they haven’t approved the software that did the damage?
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday September 21, 2018 @04:46AM (#18038156)
The point is that changing the ROM allows the user to do something that will "fuck the hardware". Presumably the stock ROM doesn't allow overclocking.
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by mjones72 on Friday September 21, 2018 @04:48AM (#18038168)
Even if changing the ROM allows me to break the hardware, just by changing the ROM I don't lose my right to have the mobile repaired under free warranty. The manufacturer has to prove I managed to break the hardware only because I changed the ROM.

By the way, if you fuck up the CPU by overclocking it I guarantee they won't notice it because they will just throw the entire motherboard away. The subcontracted company that fixes your mobile (it's almost never the manufacturer) won't spend their time doing some CSI on it.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by 1023bytes on Friday September 21, 2018 @12:18PM (#18040751)
Yep, in the EU it's definitely illegal.
Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by kevin_b_er on Friday September 21, 2018 @10:18AM (#18039840)
If you modify your car in any way, have you voided the warranty?

This is a lie sold to you to convince you to give up control to the manufacturers, to make a warranty a flimsy and easily discarded thing. Their products are getting lower in long term quality and reliability each year, but they don't want to take responsibility for them.

Re:Qualcomm’s Chain of Trust by gehsty on Saturday September 22, 2018 @03:49AM (#18044992)
If you purposefully bypass control measures that maintain the integrity of the cpu, then run the cpu outside of what it is supposed to do, you have voided the warranty.

If you modify your cars engine increasing the pressure in the cylinders beyond what they are designed to handle you have voided the warranty, and wouldn’t be covered when the seals fail etc.

Your warranty covers the intended use cases. It does not cover you t do what ever you want...