News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by est on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:57AM (#18030099)
Total noob here, what's the difference between wrapping a quadcopter with a duct and this?

Is it because a single rotor is much harder?

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by theon144 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @04:00AM (#18030535)
Well, in simple terms with four rotors you vary their speeds to tilt the copter whichever way and thus steer it.

Here you have a single rotor, and just try to imagine what happens when you vary its speed. It might bob around, fly up and then crash into something, but you won't be able to point it anywhere. Imagine trying to fly a ceiling fan.

This guy uses something called "thrust vectoring", i.e. "pointing the thrust of the single rotor in some specific direction" to steer it around, but for that you need something to redirect the flow of air, which he designed and custom 3D printed.

Which is pretty damn cool.

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by close04 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @04:21AM (#18030616)
But what's the benefit of taking this approach instead of the classic open propeller design or to ducted multi propeller designs?
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by A2017U1 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @06:22AM (#18031115)
The advantages of a single blade over the equivalent 4 smaller blades is efficiency. A tiny part of that is losses from extra motors but mainly its from blade length which dramatically affects power efficiency, up until the point where the tips go over the speed of sound, helicopters heavily optimise for this.

The duct itself offers some advantage but it's used here to vector thrust for control rather than just go up and down.

Battery power is quite constraining already for aircraft, ducted fan offers some benefit. The US military use a petrol powered ducted fan drone operationally, though i believe that's dual rotor, this is single rotor that offsets counter rotation with vectoring.

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by madeuptempacct on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:24PM (#18034081)
So, is this thing guaranteed to go faster in a straight line even without wings to provide lift? (Slight downward vector on thrust?)

What would happen if rotors were added, ala Kamov helicopters.

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by blattimwind on Thursday September 20, 2018 @05:29AM (#18030902)
Fun building it
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by psiops on Thursday September 20, 2018 @08:56AM (#18031997)
As the parent said, it's pretty damn cool :)
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by toss1 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:34PM (#18034155)
Mainly a completely different control mechanism and single vs multiple power-sources.

On a multirotor, there are obviously 4/6/8 motor/rotor sets, typically positioned far from the mass centroid, so control is effected by 1) varying the thrust from each rotor (primarily pitch & roll), and 2) varying the speed of each rotor for inertial effects (primarily yaw). This uses a single rotor and thrust vectoring fins to influence the direction and reaction to the thrust.

I'm more interested in how the efficiency numbers work out.

Typically, a larger rotor produces more thrust per unit of energy. However, a ducted fan is also typically significantly less efficient than an un-enclosed rotor. Since I don't have numbers, my question is which effect dominates -- is it overall more or less thrust efficient than a multirotor?

Either way, it is a very cool design & build -- nice work Ikarus!

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by hoorayimhelping on Thursday September 20, 2018 @02:04AM (#18030117)
I believe a quadcopter has variable-pitch wings that spin to create lift. This is a fan that pushes a column of air down to create thrust.

Helicopter blades pull the vehicle up from the top, rocket thrust pushes the vehicle up from the bottom.

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by FredFS456 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @02:09AM (#18030134)
Quadcopters never have variable pitch props, they just vary the speed of them to vary thrust. Moreover, thrust from the bottom or top doesn't really matter (look up the Pendulum Rocket Fallacy)
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by dirktheman on Thursday September 20, 2018 @02:58AM (#18030310)
Well, they usually don't have variable pitch. But there are a few rare examples of variable pitch quadcopters, for instance this monster from Curtis Youngblood:

http://www.curtisyoungblood.com/legacy-product-support-curti...

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by ryanmarsh on Thursday September 20, 2018 @10:53AM (#18032854)
For most applications you don’t need variable pitch blades on a quadcopter, they’re also very delicate and break easily on drones.

I used to fly r/c helicopters before drones became popular. The pitch mechanism was routinely a source of problems for me. It’s pretty amazing to watch it work though.

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by modzu on Thursday September 20, 2018 @08:49AM (#18031933)
neat! but (speaking of the pendulum fallacy) if the fuel tank was attached with cables instead of a fixed structure, wouldn't that actually work?
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by Ao7bei3s on Thursday September 20, 2018 @02:50AM (#18030282)
No, not at all.

The technical difference is how the overall thrust is steered:

* Quadcopter: the speed of four (fixed pitch[1]) propellers is managed independently. Spinning a single propeller a bit more tilts the copter away from that propeller[2]. This is very unstable, so speed needs to be adjusted at kHz rates[3][4].

* "Electric rocket": the thrust of the single propeller is steered using the control surfaces at the bottom to deflect the thrust. This is called thrust vectoring. Since the propeller is not directly used to steer, the speed doesn't have to be adjusted that often. However, the position of the control surfaces does.

* Helicopter: tilts the rotor plane[5] to tilt the aircraft, and inclines the individual rotors to change the magnitude of thrust. The rotor speed typically remains constant.[6] Helicopters are aerodynamically stable and don't require an automatic control loop [edit: no, see follow-up post!].

In theory the "electric rocket design" with a single propeller might allow higher efficiency: larger propellers are generally more efficient (thrust per watt). (However, the model in the video won't be very efficient, the props are quite small. And there'll be other tradeoffs too.)

Also, this is a refreshing take on RC aircraft that hasn't been done as much before.

Lift is generated on both sides of the propellers in both cases.[7]

Optional reading:

[1] Generally - variable pitch quadcopters exist. However that gives up the mechanical simplicity that's one of the main advantages of quadcopters over helicopters. Their advantage is that they can actively decelerate a lot more efficiently and also fly upside down easily.

[2] And turns the copter (yaw). Quadcopters use two pairs of counter-rotating propellers to be able to cancel the yaw.

[3] Quadcopters are unstable and need to measure linear and angular acceleration and correct the propeller speeds very quickly. Control frequency of 100Hz flies, 1kHz is somewhat standard, 32kHz is state of the art. (Note: Propellers have significant inertia. To give an idea, reversing prop turn direction in-flight takes ~1sec (and requires special symmetric props if it's supposed to work efficiently).

[4] This is feasible since the propeller is smaller (less mass, less inertia) than for helicopters.

[5] Due to gyroscopic effect, the tilt of the aircraft is 90 degrees out of phase.

[6] Assuming the typical variable-pitch helicopter. There are other options both for real life helis as well as for models (fixed pitch, coaxial, ...) but they're rare (or very cheap toys).

[7] Side remark: lift is generated due to flow turning, not due to different pressure differences caused by different airspeeds over top/bottom of wings as is taught in school. Search for "NASA incorrect lift theory" to learn more. https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/wrong1.html

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by bboreham on Thursday September 20, 2018 @03:28AM (#18030421)
> Helicopters are aerodynamically stable

That’s not my experience as a helicopter pilot.

I believe the textbooks say they are “statically stable and dynamically unstable”, but the bottom line is you surely do need a control loop.

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by Ao7bei3s on Thursday September 20, 2018 @03:44AM (#18030480)
Thanks for correcting that part then.

I've never even been in a real helicopter unfortunately. I really wish I could touch the stick of one once to see how it compares to models in terms of touchiness... it's (un)fortunate that there's probably no realistic way to try that.

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by nradov on Thursday September 20, 2018 @10:17AM (#18032584)
If you can afford $150 some helicopter flight schools offer prospective students a brief introductory lesson where you can touch the stick.

https://www.specializedheli.com/helicopter-training/

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by bboreham on Thursday September 20, 2018 @03:51AM (#18030507)
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by infogulch on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:06PM (#18033936)
I really enjoyed Smarter Every Day's video about learning to hover: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eXR1olg_I0w
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by baddox on Thursday September 20, 2018 @04:52AM (#18030759)
I think the main advantage of variable pitch quadcopters is the ability to change the thrust of each motor more quickly. You don’t need to wait for a motor to speed up, you just slam on the pitch of the blades and the rotational momentum in the blades gives you zero-latency thrust (meanwhile the motor is spooling up to prevent the rotation speed from dropping too much).

Of course, you’re also right that the aircraft can decelerate faster, since each rotor can thrust in either direction (the same effect that allows for flying upside down and accelerating toward the ground faster than 1g).

Lastly, I assume that variable pitch quadcopters are able to autorotate in the event of a motor failure (not that that’s super important for relatively inexpensive unmanned aircraft).

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by mannykannot on Thursday September 20, 2018 @07:54AM (#18031555)
With regard to footnote 7: As someone who has played a very small part in correcting some misconceptions about how airfoils generate lift, I find that I now have to apply some corrections the other way: there is necessarily a pressure difference across an airfoil if it is generating lift, and Bernoulli's equation does correctly describe the relationship between that difference in pressure and the equally real difference in local airflow speeds (up to airspeeds where compressibility is an issue, as Bernoulli's equation is only strictly correct for incompressible flows.) What was most wrong with the old explanations was the use of a fallacious 'equal transit time' argument in an attempt to explain the difference in speeds.
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by flurrything on Thursday September 20, 2018 @07:34AM (#18031440)
> Also, this is a refreshing take on RC aircraft that hasn't been done as much before.

Maybe the reason it hasn't been done much before is because one doesn't have to actually go and build this to know that it will be extremely inefficient and painful to fly...

Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by kjeetgill on Thursday September 20, 2018 @02:34AM (#18030228)
Surely the only difference between push and pull is near the ground right?
Re:Ikarus electric “rocket” – Thrust-vectored flying ducted ... by Ao7bei3s on Thursday September 20, 2018 @03:13AM (#18030359)
Another example would be rapid descents: the aircraft can become quite unstable when it gets into its own downwash.

(A high control frequency makes all the difference here for quadcopters. Compare a toy and a hobby quadcopter, it's easy to spot the difference.)

Also, lift generated due to the top and bottom of airfoils can be quite different.