News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by everdev on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:23PM (#18029026)
I've always wondered: why poison? It doesn't always seem to kill the victim and makes it easy to identify the perps as state actors.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by arkades on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:43PM (#18029115)
> It doesn't always seem to kill the victim and makes it easy to identify the perps as state actors.

As others have said, identifying a state actor is a feature, not a bug. However, what others have neglected to point out, is that it's unreliable - and that is a feature, too. We can't easily identify the state actor. Polonium-210 pointed at Russia obviously, but Russia has also utilized dioxides (vs. Shchekochikhin), and opioids (fentanyl) (to wipe out the hostage-takers in the Dubrovka theater).

The result is that Russia sends a message: we will reach out and kill our critics and defectors.

Bullets don't have the same effect: a critic dies in his sleep. Was it a drop of fentanyl? Maybe. Maybe. The absence or presence of poison will be speculated on; the absence or presence of bullets is clear-cut.

Through the use of poisons which vary in their ability to point the finger at Russia, any death of a critic that could plausibly be linked to a poisoning now raises the specter of Russian intervention. The result is that their psychological warfare is extended far beyond their actual reach.

The KGB/FSB has always had a very significant attention to psych-ops. Their actions should not be interpreted strictly at face value.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by losteric on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @10:08PM (#18029226)
Poison can also be deployed by untrained individuals coerced into service, and bypass metal detectors as well as bullet-proof vests used by paranoid targets.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by meowface on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @11:05PM (#18029456)
And an obvious point: Russia wants important enemies to die slow, painful deaths, and to send a message that other enemies will suffer a similar fate. Killing Litvinenko or Skripal with a bullet to the head probably wouldn't have been satisfying or vengeful enough.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by dvfjsdhgfv on Thursday September 20, 2018 @02:40AM (#18030250)
> Russia wants important enemies to die slow

I know this is a common oversimplification when talking about governments, but please, could we at last use "Kremlin" instead? Russia is a large country with many people just like us, who want to live, love and have a wonderful time. Sure, at times the public opinion is stirred when some atrocities are reported and you can hear some vocal groups online, but Russians are not different from any other nation in this respect.

Their leaders, however, are a different story. You could say Russians have had bad luck with respect to their rulers for centuries. When you look back at what Lenin, Stalin and others did, Putin starts to look like a savior. But they all have a certain attitude and ambitions. So could we please stop saying "Russia" when we don't mean Russian people at all, and common Russians are actually victims of bad policy of their rulers.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by tim333 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @05:33AM (#18030928)
I see your point but "Kermlin" is a bit over specific - when people like Magnitsky get killed you know it's Russians but not whether the Kermlin or mobsters or what. Elements within Russia perhaps.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by expathacker on Thursday September 20, 2018 @05:58AM (#18031012)
Seeing as Russia has been a democracy for 25 years, isn't this just absolving the Russian populace of any guilt or responsibility over their choice in government, or the actions of said government?
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by everdev on Thursday September 20, 2018 @10:41AM (#18032748)
The same way most Americans don't approve of or want to be associated with Trump. Democracies allow more freedom of choice, but large minorities or even small majorities in democracies can be ruled by people they see as detrimental to the country or opposed to their own personal views.

I'm sure this is compounded by voter intimidation, limits on free speech, etc.

We have a long way to go in the US and Russia until every person is directly represented by either themselves or someone they ideologically agree with. Winner take all democracies are certainly better than aristocracies or dictatorships, but still result in the misrepresentation of huge portions of the population.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by Eldt on Thursday September 20, 2018 @06:46AM (#18031218)
How democratic exactly do you think their election process is?
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by expathacker on Thursday September 20, 2018 @12:18PM (#18033572)
I do not know, do you? I'm guessing that neither of us have observed their election process in person, or are experts in the fairness of their, or any other democratic process. If you are, please school me, I'm a willing student.

I am a US citizen, my birth nation has "elected" two presidents who failed to win the popular vote. 2% of my fellow citizens are unable to vote due to felony convictions. On top of this, the practice known as gerrymandering is essentially carte blanche for a state's ruling power to ensure continuous victories due to the complicated nature of an inconsistent federalist voting system.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by meowface on Sunday September 23, 2018 @06:17PM (#18053603)
The US's election system has many issues, but Russia's system (at the present moment) is a complete charade.

At least with the US system, the rules and loopholes (as stupid as they are) are transparent, known, and understood ahead of time. There's no funny business behind the curtain.

In Russia, elections are secretly manipulated by the state. The US is a sometimes-dysfunctional democracy, but Russia doesn't have a democracy at all.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by expathacker on Tuesday September 25, 2018 @07:20AM (#18065290)
Well, to be a little bit pedantic, the USA doesn't have a democracy either, we have a representative republic.

You're speculating as to the state of Russia's democracy. Have you any specific proof of your allegations? I'm guessing your proof lays primarily with that which is published in the media, and the strong statements / research which come out of NATO and other anti-Russian establishments?

I can't believe people would vote for Trump, but let's face it, they did because they believed his economy promises. I can't believe people voted for Putin, but Russia's economy has flourished under his reign, before him, people literally starved to death. I can't believe people vote for Erdogan, but Türkiye's economy is magnitudes stronger and fairer than it was before the AKP reign. Perhaps these democracies are working as intended, and people just cast short-sighted, greed-driven votes?

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by meowface on Thursday September 20, 2018 @09:14AM (#18032140)
It's just an abbreviation. People say "America", "Russia", or "China" when talking about their governments.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by everdev on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:03PM (#18033920)
An unfortunate one though and akin to saying "white people" or "poor people". Sweeping generalities about mass groups of people although faster usually break down communication.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by meowface on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:42PM (#18034208)
It's not at all the same thing. By "Russia" I mean "Russian state", not "Russian people".
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by BurnGpuBurn on Thursday September 20, 2018 @08:25AM (#18031768)
Skripal didn't die, and his daughter also didn't die.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by meowface on Thursday September 20, 2018 @09:15AM (#18032149)
No, but they intended him to die.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by BurnGpuBurn on Thursday September 20, 2018 @10:23AM (#18032622)
Not sure about intentions, but I consider it largely established that they were poisoned.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by meowface on Thursday September 20, 2018 @11:56AM (#18033411)
Considering the poison is extremely deadly, that other uninvolved UK citizens died and were injured as a result of exposure, that the poisoning was almost definitely ordered or approved by Putin, and that Putin and other government officials have spoken at length about killing traitors no matter where they go, it seems very likely they intended to kill him but failed.

Just making him "really sick" doesn't make much sense, I think. Especially when you consider someone unrelated did die after being exposed.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by BurnGpuBurn on Thursday September 20, 2018 @07:49PM (#18036263)
Sure, somebody did something with a poison to get a couple of people sick and dead, for sure. Maybe the intention was to instill fear? To me that is just as plausible as a murder attempt. Also, you'd think that the Russian secret service is not as amateurish as to screw up a job that should be pretty easy for them.

And, well, I'm just not very convinced of the "almost definitely ordered or approved by Putin" part, nor the "Putin and other government officials have spoken at length about killing traitors no matter where they go" piece. I have never seen evidence of the former, and honestly never saw or heard the latter either.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by Bendingo on Thursday September 20, 2018 @12:20AM (#18029767)
> Russia wants important enemies to die slow, painful deaths

> wouldn't have been satisfying or vengeful enough

You know this how ?

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by GW150914 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @12:46AM (#18029847)
> Russia wants important enemies to die slow, painful deaths > wouldn't have been satisfying or vengeful enough You know this how ?

Alexander Litvenenko springs to mind, followed by Viktor Yushchenko, Alexander Perepilichny, Anna Politkovskaya (later shot to death), Vladimir Kara-Murza (twice!), the Skripals, Georgi Markov (Ricin... nasty), Karinna Moskalenko, and on and on.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by joezydeco on Thursday September 20, 2018 @12:45PM (#18033786)
It's also asynchronous. You could place poison on a doorknob and be thousands of miles away before the incident happens.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by cynicalkane on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @11:44PM (#18029600)
I have a hypothesis that the polonium poisoners weren't planning on being detected.

Polonium has no side effects other than radiation poisoning which can't be detected outside the body. To diagnose it, one would have to go looking for trace amounts in the body or in contaminated areas. If the poisoners weren't aware of the extreme sensitivity of alpha-particle detection -- reliably accurate to the single particle level -- they might have thought polonium would be undetectable and untraceable. Or they might of thought nobody would ever think to look for it. By some accounts, they almost didn't.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by sephamorr on Thursday September 20, 2018 @12:39AM (#18029828)
You're spot on here. As I understand, the Russian state was quite surprised at the capabilities of Western detection science. It was certainly not common knowledge that low-concentration alpha emitters (still plenty poisonous) could be detected in blood, nor that the assassins could be tracked all the way back to Russia just from their limited exposure.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by cynicalkane on Thursday September 20, 2018 @08:58AM (#18032008)
The science is actually old and certainly known to physicists around the world. Such detectors are readily available to university physics laboratories, for example. But if you don't have a physics background, it might never occur to you that such technology exists.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by dzhiurgis on Thursday September 20, 2018 @02:49AM (#18030276)
> opioids (fentanyl) (to wipe out the hostage-takers in the Dubrovka theater)

They used Carfentanil (100x more potent than fentanyl) to wipe them out. Unfortunately medics didn't have enough antidote on hand to reboot all people.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by pulisse on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:30PM (#18029067)
> makes it easy to identify the perps as state actors

Which is what makes it useful as an intimidation tactic.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by freeflight on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:43PM (#18029116)
The US version of it is a Hellfire missile from a drone remote-controlled from 2 continents away.

Way more lethal, way more collateral, quite obvious to identify as the act of a state actor, still common practice barely anybody takes issue with.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by erentz on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:54PM (#18029178)
Your comparison is completely unalike. Yes the US drone war program is bad. Yes the endless war on terror is bad. But these are not the same as a tyrant poisoning anyone who becomes inconvenient to him.

The closest comparison I think you could validly make would be something like the harsh treatment of Chelsea Manning or Reality Winner (or Drake, or Snowden, etc). None of which were taken out with poison or a Hellfire missile.

(Edit: that’s not to excuse the treatment of those people either.)

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by anigbrowl on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @10:51PM (#18029395)
Really, one kind of assassination is very much like another. I'm not saying that to be edgy; I sometimes wonder if a limited number of obvious assassinations isn't better than an open-ended number of casualties in conventional war (viz/ Syria for example).

It's true that drones tend to be military rather than espionage assets, and as insignia-bearing military hardware in a designated battle zone they're legally equivalent to a sniper successfully killing a distant target. However battlefield snipers generally make opportunistic choices based on tactical considerations, with little regard to the identity of their targets. A great many drone attacks begin with intelligence about a specific target and then deploy the resources to eliminate that person, which for me puts it closer to assassination. (This is an idiosyncratic definition and I doubt it lines up with accepted laws of war.)

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by freeflight on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @10:14PM (#18029252)
No, it's exactly the same. Both are extrajudicial and state-sponsored killings aka assassinations.

Just because many people have blind trust in the US government and the validity of its kill list aka "disposition matrix" [0] doesn't change the basic injustice of the act, which is just as unjust as poisoning some "enemy of the state".

The international laws and human rights broken in both cases are exactly the same, the only difference is the methodology of the final "execution".

> None of which were taken out with poison or a Hellfire missile.

It's extremely naive to assume we know every drone victim ever, it's not like the US drone program is a shining beacon of transparency.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposition_Matrix

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by erentz on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @10:34PM (#18029336)
Putin targets Russian citizens that are his personal enemies because they speak up, protest, or otherwise embarrass him. He does it using poison in a manner to make sure everyone knows who did it and what the consequences are if you cross him.

The US drone program does not target US citizens who speak up, protest, or embarrass the president of the USA, at the behest of just the president.

(Stating the obvious, but that’s not a defense of the drone program. You’ve outlined its problems. But it’s just clearly not the same thing.)

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by jononor on Thursday September 20, 2018 @04:36AM (#18030690)
Here is a US citizen and journalist that is on the kill list. https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/how-... He has been lucky to survive so far. But he is struggling to even get a case before the courts to learn why he is on the list.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by dogma1138 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @07:26AM (#18031392)
There is no proof that he is on any kill list what so ever other than his claims of being too close to too many drone strikes which given what he does isn’t that surprising.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by jononor on Thursday September 20, 2018 @07:52AM (#18031537)
If he is not on a kill list, the US government should say so. If they don't want to give out person specific information, they can give a categorical statement like 'no US citizens on a kill list' or 'no US citizens in Syria'.

How do you get evidence that you are on a kill list anyway? The lists are top secret, maintained by world class intelligence agencies...

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by dogma1138 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @08:10AM (#18031659)
The US has killed US citizens before e.g. Anwar al-Awlaki; if he’s on the list then it’s not because he is a journalist if he is nothing more than that then he ain’t on any list.

There is no reason for the US to publicly state if he is on any kill list or not technically.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by freeflight on Thursday September 20, 2018 @12:03AM (#18029692)
> The US drone program does not target US citizens who speak up, protest, or embarrass the president of the USA, at the behest of just the president.

How do you know that? Does the US publish its list? No, it doesn't, so you are making that statement on literally nothing but good faith.

While at the same time you use bad faith to frame the Russian version as something where Putin personally orders people killed for slighting him or some other mundane reason.

The reality is both are killing "enemies of the state", justified and regulated by their own, internal, rulesets and governmental institutions. They and others have been doing so openly, and covertly for decades. Heck, this kind of stuff even has been glorified as a pop-culture export from the UK as "the agent with a license to kill".

In that context, there's literally no difference if it's an Obama, Trump, Putin or their UK equivalent giving the final "okay" or if the target is a US/UK/Russian national who's a terrorist/pedophile/traitor/whatever.

It's about the lack of accountability, the lack of due process, the lack of recourse. All these issues exist regardless of the US, Russia or anybody else doing something like this.

In that context, the US drone war is pretty much the overt manifestation of a practice that used to be kept covertly due to its inherent controversy. But in the zeals of a war on terror, where even torture became openly condonable, too many people have lost their moral compass.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by stickfigure on Thursday September 20, 2018 @12:45AM (#18029845)
> The US drone program does not target US citizens who speak up, protest, or embarrass the president of the USA, at the behest of just the president.

How do you know that?

Well, there's simple occam's razor - if drone strikes were doing this, we'd probably have heard about it. On the other hand we have a rising body count of journalists, artists, and ex-spies with real names and histories.

No matter how you feel about drone strikes, you can't compare these things.

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by tim333 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @05:43AM (#18030955)
We do have quite a lot of info on who are "US citizens who speak up, protest, or embarrass the president of the USA" and who get killed by drones. They don't overlap much. You don't get Drones trying to take out Mueller and the Taliban types who get hit are much more like military/terrorist enemies than political foes.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by ajross on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:41AM (#18030031)
No one drops bombs on their domestic political opposition. Russia isn't poisoning it's military enemies, it's poisoning Russians. There really is an important distinction.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by torpfactory on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @10:30PM (#18029315)
We ought not engage in whataboutism here. Both Russian poising and the US drone program are terrible for different reasons and we ought to demand an end to both.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by fromMars on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @11:45PM (#18029606)
Can we not differentiate these two, morally?

Is killing a civilian who uses words to critique a government not different than killing an enemy who is at war with a government?

Maybe drones are terrible way to accomplish the latter (too many civilian collateral damage).

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by torpfactory on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @11:58PM (#18029662)
Yes, certainly we should discuss them and there is definitely a difference morally. It’s clear extrajudicial killings of political opponents is wrong. Drone strikes are wrong because in a sense they are also extrajudicial. At least, the threshold for lethal force is too low, in my opinion
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by jononor on Thursday September 20, 2018 @04:39AM (#18030703)
Every man above 16 tends to be labeled a combatant in the drone programs. No requirement that they have harmed anyone. Sure there are differences, but also similarities.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:44PM (#18029123)
But they only target terrorists.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by baybal2 on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:24PM (#18029032)
>I've always wondered: why poison?

Exactly for these reasons:

>It doesn't always seem to kill the victim and makes it easy to identify the perps as state actors.

Quick and effortless death by a bullet don't terrify peons as much as death after weeks of excruciating agony.

In this case, it is also to send intimidation message to the country hosting them: hey look, we just wetted a man guarded by a squadron of crack bodyguards on your soil, now, think what we can do to you

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by seppin on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:39PM (#18029100)
Don't excuse people that are bad at their jobs. Poison is meant to kill people, which proves to be more difficult than it sounds. If you don't believe me, read up on capital punishment in the US and how often it fails.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by anigbrowl on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @10:36PM (#18029341)
Because the point isn't necessarily to kill the victim, but to induce fear in the general population. Poisoning is similar enough to illness to be imaginable but different enough to be scary, and we tend to associate poisonings with horrible suffering rather than sudden and painless expiration.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by TangoTrotFox on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:18AM (#18029962)
As an aside, you also just opened a can of worms here.

Things that can be so 'easily' attributed to a given state actor can also then be used to try to frame said actor. Look at all the evidence, now obviously completely fake, that magically appeared when we wanted to 'prove' Iraq had WMD, even though they did not. For that matter look at the list of United States involvement in regime change [1] which is gradually turning into a novel. We make no secret, or at least declassification makes no secret, of overthrowing democratically elected governments, falsifying evidence to hurt sovereign nations, complicity to support of assassination of 'innocent' individuals, and lots of other great stuff.

I think people don't understand that propaganda doesn't mean some crackly speaker in a third world nation spewing daily praise for the divine leader. It comes and all shapes and forms, and the US is actively involved in domestic propaganda that ensures we never really appreciate all the awful things we do. In a way we, as in our intelligence agencies, are probably protected by their own impudence. Many of the things I'm listing even I have trouble believing we'd do, yet declassified documents and open acknowledgement make it complete and crystal clear that we do.

The point of this is not to say whether any party or another was involved in whatever event, but rather that trying to gauge things as an outsider based on the filtering of a news media which hungers both for clicks and war is unlikely to yield anything remotely resembling an educated opinion. We can even look to the history of Pussy Riot or this case as further examples. The victim here is not a member of Pussy Riot. His ex wife was a member. And the band themselves were not arrested for anything they said, but their behavior. They decided to stage a 'guerilla concert' inside a cathedral obviously completely against the wishes of the church and without their permission. They were charged with 'holliganism motivated by religious hatred' and sentenced to 2 years. They were released early on amnesty from the Russian duma/congress after serving most of their sentence. [2] Quite amazing what a different picture was spun by the media when all this was happening.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_r...

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pussy_Riot

Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by make3 on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:29PM (#18029064)
maybe gunning someone down is an act of war, while poisoning sends a very clear message while somehow not being an act of war
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by losteric on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @10:10PM (#18029233)
No, state-sponsored poison attacks are still acts of war.
Re:We Now Know More About the Apparent Poisoning of the Puss... by sbmthakur on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:19AM (#18029967)
It makes it quite difficult to identify the origin. For example, in Skripal's case, we still don't know from where the Novichok came[1] or the assassins were Russians or not[2][3].

1. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/mar/15/uks-claims-q...

2. https://www.businessinsider.in/British-military-scientists-c...

3. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-britain-russia-stockpiles...