News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by wccrawford on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:07PM (#18025208)
And yet, you can bet that they'd collect if the error were in their favor. And they probably have.

Absolutely disgusting.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by paulddraper on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:40PM (#18025499)
That's because the terms (ignoring conflicting laws for a minute) choose FanDuel as the arbiter.

The imbalance is obvious even before the bet is placed.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by pweissbrod on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:21PM (#18025327)
I mildly disagree in the sense that what constitutes a "palpable" error is just too broad of a grey area.

It would be encouraging to see FanDuel just cough up the erroneous wager (which is surely cheaper than a lawsuit) and tighten down the definition of errors in spreads to something more specific such as anything outside like 2 standard deviations within the scope of a game*

*I'm not a gambler just someone who believes the definition of error can be mathematically defined for everyone's benefit

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by alwaysdoit on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:56PM (#18026203)
If it can be mathematically defined, then they can add that code to make that check in their system.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by dkrich on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @04:52PM (#18027617)
They would probably rather pay this out and have it go away instead of being a widely circulated ESPN article and potentially still losing in a lawsuit.

I think the reason they won't is they don't want to set a precedent for future similar mistakes. If they pay out here they would almost certainly lose future similar disputes in court.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by frgtpsswrdlame on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:04PM (#18025707)
I don't see why that should matter. What is the definition of a "palpable" error that the bettor can make and get his bet refunded after the fact? Of course none exists, it doesn't matter if your kid clicks a bet or you fat finger the wrong number or even if your own homebrew betting algo has a glitch, if you don't notice until after the bet has resolved you're just out of luck.

As long as there is no "I made a mistake, get out of jail free" card for bettors there shouldn't be one for the companies serving those bets either. FanDuel would have collected this man's money if the Broncos had lost and they would have collected his money if he had clicked this bet accidentally, to that end he deserves to collect his money.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by lowlevel on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @02:37PM (#18026567)
Totally. Hopefully the judge orders they pay him over and above his deserved winnings if it gets that far.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by ddingus on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:23PM (#18025355)
Exactly.

What they could do is pay this guy off, then follow the good press for a very likely net gain.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by TwitchySeal on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:29PM (#18025400)
Except then they have to pay out every other time there's a bug.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by heavymark on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:36PM (#18025464)
I imagine if they had to honor, they would make it priority number one resolving those bugs, and make changes to make the bugs more apparent to people in the process. If they don't have to pay, there isn't much of an incentive to prioritize the fixes, especially since I imagine if the bugs are in the favor of the company they can make a lot of money.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by tomtheelder on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:46PM (#18025549)
I'm sure it is already a high priority, but it is a system built by humans, and it will always have mistakes. What if they were being forced to pay out 82 million instead of thousand? What about 82 billion?

There should be clear cut laws surrounding clear errors, like there are in most places, and ones like this should not be forced to pay out.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:40PM (#18026042)
When SCADA software fucks up and runs a ship aground someone has to pay. When something breaks because some engineer relied too much on FEAs and didn't do any destructive tests someone has to pay. "Whoops, our bad" is not an acceptable excuse except in tech.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by tomtheelder on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @04:55PM (#18027633)
"Whoops, our bad" is actually a valid excuse in virtually every industry, as long as your mistake doesn't cause damage that needs to be repaired. Such damage is the only reason anyone has to pay in the situations you described.

This situation is much more comparable to, say, ordering something from a store that turns out to be out of stock. The store has to refund you for the sale, of course, but that's all they are on the hook for. They aren't punished beyond that, they don't even have to go out and find the item for you.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by ddingus on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:32PM (#18029075)
There are legal arguments that become valid at those amounts.

There is a difference between:

Ouch, that stung! Must do better.

That amount kills the business!

They own my whole enterprise now?

This is a sting. Quality control tax.

They should pay up, suck it up, maximize good will, and prevent it from happening again.

Given this gaffe, it is even odds they have pocketed more than this amount from errors going the other way.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by turtlecloud on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @08:09PM (#18028665)
Then thy go out of business and someone more competent should take their place.

Otherwise there is no honor and incentive for them. Bookies have to live by their honor.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by TwitchySeal on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @07:27PM (#18028480)
in this case the odds jumped from -600 to +75,000 ($12 profit to $82,000) What if they went to +75,000,000? Would they have to pay the guy $82,000,000? As long as the mistake was obvious, of course not.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by ddingus on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @03:27PM (#18027000)
Litigate it. That will be the answer.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by modzu on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:56PM (#18025641)
it seems that errors are not uncommon and when they are "obvious" they typically void the contract. not sure why people are freaking out here. if you logged into your bank account and saw an extra zero that was caused by a temporary CSS bug, do you really think you are entitled to it?
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by ticmasta on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:14PM (#18025795)
If I remember my contract law, you're not 100% correct. Errors in the contract can be used as cause for severability or termination in some rare cases, but errors in execution are generally not. They're one of the reasons we have contracts in the first place. It is perfectly acceptable to sign a contract that in hindsight was one-sided. It's the pre-execution that requires mutual benefit. Otherwise every gambling wager could be challenged after the fact as mathematically the deal is biased to allow the book to arbitrage a wager!
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by modzu on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @02:53PM (#18026720)
maybe i should not have used the phrase "void"; in this case the contract includes a clause that says, "where a blatant or palpable error is made in... prices offered... bets may be settled at the correct price at the time at which the bet was placed". so more accurately, the incorrect price is voided
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by modzu on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @02:55PM (#18026730)
i think the issue here is that in some states, there is an authority that needs to determine whether the price was an error, and that it cannot be at the sole discretion of the sportsbook?
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by ddingus on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @03:27PM (#18026995)
No risk, no reward.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by ddingus on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:34PM (#18029081)
Let me rephrase:

No honor, no bets.

I would not place a bet with them now.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by draw_down on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:35PM (#18025456)
Sounds like a great incentive to fix the bugs to me!
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by dumbfounder on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:27PM (#18025379)
Disgusting? So if you see a sign on a car for sale that says $19,95 because a digit fell off, the dealer is obligated to sell it to you at that price? People and systems make mistakes, that doesn't mean it's "disgusting" that they protect themselves financially from those mistakes.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by cesis on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:33PM (#18025428)
It's more like - dealer sold you the car for $19.95, then came after you and demanded the rest $19k because of the error.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by ticmasta on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:08PM (#18025740)
Reminds me of the story from SparkFun's founder where a nightly currency conversion batch process failed and set all prices to $0. If you had ever bought anything from them before I believe they honoured the purchase and sent out the order for free. If you were a first timer I guess you were S.O.L.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by village-idiot on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @03:35PM (#18027053)
Seems reasonable to keep good faith customers happy while rejecting those who wanted to pile on.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by lgeorget on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:02PM (#18025694)
Once I went to recredit my public transportation badge in a shop mandated by the city to do the transaction and they mistakenly charged me something like 15€ instead of 150€ (I don't remember the exact figure but it was a 0 missing). Two days later I got my badge blacklisted (and earned myself a loud and obnoxious buzz from the badging machine in the bus).

I had to make a call and go to the transportation office to settle the matter. They told me the shop was likely to suffer repercussions after the incident.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by dumbfounder on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:35PM (#18025452)
If you bought it online you bet they would come after you.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by tk75x on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @03:04PM (#18026818)
I once saw a price for a car listed on a dealer's website that was much lower than the car was worth. Turns out when it was entered into the system, it was entered as the base model instead of the upgraded version with more options. The dealer offered to sell it to me at the lower price anyways if I put a deposit down.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by 51lver on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:42PM (#18025512)
Which is completely different than a digit falling off a window, right?
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by dumbfounder on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:52PM (#18026163)
No, it isn't. It's still a mistake. A programmer could have dropped a digit just as easily as a person failed to properly tape a digit to a window.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by mikeash on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @02:11PM (#18026359)
When you go to buy that car where the digit fell off the price, the sales person will tell you that the erroneous price is wrong, and tell you the correct one.

If for some reason the sales person does not do this and goes through with the sale at the erroneous price, sucks to be them. They had their chance to correct it and they failed to do so.

This is the same situation, except instead of a sales person, it’s a computer.

It seems to me that this is yet another instance where companies automate processes that previously involved humans, then compensate for the newly introduced errors by blaming the customer.

If you don’t want software bugs resulting in sales at absurd prices, maybe you should have a human review each order to make sure the numbers are sensible.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by shawnz on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @07:10PM (#18028390)
> this is yet another instance where companies automate processes that previously involved humans, then compensate for the newly introduced errors by blaming the customer

In either the digital or analog cases of your example, the end result is that the customer ends up paying the intended price. The only difference is that with the digital case, they might find out about it slightly later. How is this a "newly found error" in that case and how is it "blaming the customer"? It sounds to me like the potential for error has always been there and nothing about the assignment of blame has changed whatsoever between the two examples.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by mikeash on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @07:46PM (#18028565)
That’s not the end result at all. There are three possibilities:

1. The error is corrected before the sale and the customer pays the corrected price.

2. The error is corrected before the sale and the customer changes their mind.

3. The error is not corrected before the sale and the customer pays the erroneous price.

Companies are trying to change a 3 into a 1 by blaming computers and saying the error should have been clear to the customer, when in fact it’s their own fault for not noticing the error before completing the transaction.

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by mmt on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @09:00PM (#18028908)
To be fair, they may also be trying to change a 3 into a 2 (or providing that option), but "trying" is the key word. There are enough high-value and/or physically large items that aren't cars (e.g. HDTVs, furniture) where undoing the transaction can be a huge imposition, even not considering that the merchandise is now no longer brand new and the customer must duplicate effort in the purchase process.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by corobo on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:59PM (#18026246)
The bet was already made, the details agreed upon. In your scenario if the dealer said "Yerp, whatever's on the window is whatever you're paying" and you hand over your $20 and they accept it as payment then yes, I would expect them to honor it.

Would FanDuel void your bet if you misread the odds?

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by 51lver on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:41PM (#18025502)
Totally different issues. Making a bad sale and then later backing out, vs advertising a price that is not able to be confirmed at the time of sale resulting in no sale.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by ticmasta on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:09PM (#18025751)
Lots of grocery stores give you the product for free up to a limit (say $10) if it is priced incorrectly or rings through different from advertised
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by FireBeyond on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:16PM (#18025809)
That was a consumer protection issue from the introduction of scanners, to assure customers that the scanner wasn't a black box that would rip them off.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by tom_ on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:06PM (#18025722)
The price sticker is an advertisement, not a binding contract. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invitation_to_treat
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by Kim_Bruning on Thursday September 20, 2018 @11:04AM (#18032928)
This is true in some countries, but not in others. Eg. in the Netherlands it is binding the moment a customer indicates they accept it.

(On the other hand -relevant to the topic- an agreement may be declared void in the case of "obvious error"; so Fanduel could possibly have been off the hook if they had been operating in .nl .)

Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by jkaplowitz on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:17PM (#18025820)
A lot of places have consumer protection laws about price signage and labeling which take precedence over contract law.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by tom_ on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @05:30PM (#18027877)
I was under the impression that this was the case in America and Australia as well, but it's possible it is only true for the UK.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by jkaplowitz on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @07:24PM (#18028466)
I know from first hand experience that it's true in NYC and in the Canadian province of Quebec. I think it's true in many more countries and many more places in the US and Canada, but as those two examples show, it's not always legislated at the top level of a county, even when there is a law or binding regulation about it.
Re:FanDuel not honoring bet that would have paid over $82,00... by shawnz on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:12PM (#18025774)
Do you have any evidence to show this? Or are you just making an assumption based on your dislike for the gambling industry?