News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by cthalupa on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @12:30PM (#18016670)
>Proponents of the plan say letting Washington impose more tariffs than Beijing would actually hurt the United States more because tariffs are ultimately paid by consumers and businesses in the countries that levy them.

Well, this is actually the fundamental problem, isn't it? There's no way actual trade evens out, so tariffs are the only real outcome here. Even if we "win", it's not actually winning.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by ThomPete on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @12:57PM (#18016953)
Winning is reaching a better agreement than we have now.

China is still considered a developing country by the WTO, it's very difficult to get into the Chinese market and they don't actually enforce IP rights which is a problem both for the US and EU.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by adventured on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @01:07PM (#18017042)
The EU does indeed have the same issues. The single best move Trump can make, is to resolve NAFTA (looks likely), then strike a deal with the EU (also looks likely), along with Japan (up in the air).

The EU has very openly stated that they have the exact same problems with China as the US does. They couldn't any further telegraph their interest in conspiring with the US to tame China's abuses. Indeed it may be the only way to do it, you need truly immense pressure to get China to change behavior, more than the US can bring to the table by itself.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by ThomPete on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @01:31PM (#18017325)
Which is also why it's absurd the EU goes out of their way to distance them from the US because of Trump.

He is in the right on this one despite his style but sometimes that's what you need.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by debacle on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @01:45PM (#18017482)
Look at what they do, not what they say. What Merkel says at a podium doesn't matter. It's what she says behind closed doors that matters.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by unit91 on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @12:35PM (#18016719)
Not really. That would be true if the tariffs were on all imported goods, from all locations. In this case, it just encourages businesses to look at other cheap markets (Vietnam, Mexico, Bangladesh, etc.), hence China's anxiety.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by Invictus0 on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @12:34PM (#18016714)
The "winning" scenario for the United States is that China agrees to change its IP policies. IP is America's most valuable product, and the Chinese have been stealing it with 0 consequences for decades. A win on this front would see an end (or at least decrease) in cyberattacks and more US friendly IP laws.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by kevin_b_er on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @12:38PM (#18016763)
And the "losing" scenario is a WTO ruling like Antigua and Barbuda where China is directly permitted to ignore US copyrights and patents from trade disputes.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by lovich on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @02:28PM (#18017848)
Aren't they doing that anyway? It was my understanding that most companies didn't send their latest generation products to be built in China due to them bring consistently stolen and china not backing up the IP protections
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by h8liu on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @12:47PM (#18016849)
Like which IP policy? Any specific policy document that you can point out?

China has been having IP laws and protection since around 1980, and China government never said once that stealing IP is okay. It is IP law execution and enforcement in China that is sub-par. Policing is sometimes hard.

Also, I believe the US really wants to treat IP as an "asset" rather than a "product".

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by chelical on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @01:06PM (#18017027)
China has actively promoted and condoned IP theft as a way of catching up to the US. I'm surprised you're unaware of the widespread coordinated Chinese industrial espionage, especially by Chinese students studying abroad in America. The IP laws and protections in China exist primarily so they can claim they're following the rules.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by cuboidGoat on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @06:49PM (#18019978)
Sounds like they are mirroring the behaviour of the US toward Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries.

>Last month, Attorney General Eric Holder announced that the United States was charging members of the Chinese military with economic espionage. Stealing trade secrets from American companies, he said, enabled China to “illegally sabotage” foreign competitors and propel its own companies to “success in the international marketplace.” The United States should know. That’s pretty much how we got our start as a manufacturing power, too.

>The United States emerged as the world’s industrial leader by illicitly appropriating mechanical and scientific innovations from Europe,” the historian Doron Ben-Atar observes in his book “Trade Secrets.” Throughout the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, American industrial spies roamed the British Isles, seeking not just new machines but skilled workers who could run and maintain those machines. One of these artisans was Samuel Slater, often called “the father of the American industrial revolution.” He emigrated here in 1789, posing as a farmhand and bringing with him an intimate knowledge of the Arkwright spinning frames that had transformed textile production in England, and he set up the first water-powered textile mill in the U.S. Two decades later, the American businessman Francis Cabot Lowell talked his way into a number of British mills, and memorized the plans to the Cartwright power loom. When he returned home, he built his own version of the loom, and became the most successful industrialist of his time.

>The American government often encouraged such piracy. Alexander Hamilton, in his 1791 “Report on Manufactures,” called on the country to reward those who brought us “improvements and secrets of extraordinary value” from elsewhere. State governments financed the importation of smuggled machines. And although federal patents were supposed to be granted only to people who came up with original inventions, Ben-Atar shows that, in practice, Americans were receiving patents for technology pirated from abroad.

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/06/09/spy-vs-spy-3

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by ThomPete on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @12:57PM (#18016960)
They don't enforce it it's a major issue both for the US and EU.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by h8liu on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @01:05PM (#18017019)
True, and it is also a major issue for many Chinese companies..

And rather than going to the court for justice, the US place tariffs for a war..

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by JackFr on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @12:52PM (#18016901)
Additionally when we import from China, we pay with dollars. China can either buy US goods with the dollars, or buy US assets (typically Treasury bonds) with the dollars. If you end the trade surplus with China, you end a cheap source of funding for the US government.

Not clear if this is a feature or a bug.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @01:47PM (#18017500)
This is completely backwards. There is a trade deficit with China, not a trade surplus, and the result of that deficit is lost private income which increases the U.S. government deficit as we then pay more benefits to the displaced workers. So trade deficits create budget deficits.

Second, it is impossible for a foreign nation to "fund" the U.S., which is a currency issuer. Rather, because we have open capital markets, we allow foreigners to purchase U.S. assets -- something that most other nations don't allow, including China. What this means is that there is a demand for dollars other than the trade demand, but an asset demand. This allows trade deficits to occur.

If you want to stop trade deficits, then don't impose tariffs, but do what China does and ban capital inflows. With no foreign capital inflows, there are no trade deficits -- the golden rule of international trade is that the changes to the capital account plus the changes to the current account must equal 0. No change to one implies no changes to the other, as a mathematical identity.

The way to understand this mathematical relationship is that when the rest of the world sells a good to the U.S., it gets a dollar, and now it has a choice of using that dollar to buy an asset or using it to buy a good. If it is very hard to buy assets, then you buy a good. In this way, the exchange rate adjusts so that the rest of the world doesn't have a trade deficit or surplus.

The reason why you want balanced trade is that when the foreigner gets a dollar by selling a good, but doesn't spend the dollar on buying an american good, then american economy has 1 dollar less income and it needs to sell off $1 of an asset. Selling assets does not produce income but selling goods does produce income. This is why nations like China basically ban selling assets to foreigners and so it's impossible for them to have trade deficits. There are very few nations that have the open capital markets of the U.S. -- really no nation, and our unique policies on capital are why we have such a uniquely large trade deficit.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by adventured on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @01:14PM (#18017131)
China hasn't net added much to its treasury holdings in 15 years (it hit around $1 trillion back in 2003, it's now at ~$1.2 trillion). In that time they've probably run a $4 trillion trade surplus. Clearly that isn't how it works at this point, they're intentionally avoiding buying more US paper.

In that time US debt has gone from $6.7t to $21t. Their share has gone from 15% or so, to 5.7%. They're no longer a funding source for new US debt, and are no longer a critical funding source of existing debt (although hey, it's nice to have them squatting on that trillion dollars and not liquidating it).

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @01:51PM (#18017536)
The Rest of the World has never been a funding source for the U.S. It's impossible, because to purchase a treasury, the Rest of the World must first obtain dollar from an American, which decreases our income. Then, they purchase the treasury instead of the american. If someone grabs your wallet and then buys a share of stock with the money inside, they aren't funding the stock market and you don't need to be grateful to them.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by gonvaled on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @02:11PM (#18017715)
You are giving the dollars to foreigners, in exchange of goods. Nobody is forcing you to do that. If you feel those products are not worth your dollars, do not buy them.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @02:34PM (#18017891)
Nobody is forcing you, but the forex rate adjusts so that the appropriate amount of goods is bought voluntarily.

If country A bans foreign capital inflows and purchases $10 of foreign assets, then that forces a trade surplus of $10. Yes, that $10 transaction will be voluntary because it's currency will adjust so that the transaction is made. But from the macro point of view, the foreign capital flows drive the "voluntary" transactions.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @02:39PM (#18017947)
This is what a lot of people don't understand. They say thinks like "Country A has nothing that country B wants". Suppose we are in a world with only 2 countries, and country A has only apples to trade and country B has beautiful cars. It may well be that B doesn't want goods from A and A wants goods from B, nevertheless no trade deficit will occur unless there are foreign capital inflows. And if neither side allows foreign capital flows, then either A and B wont trade, or A and B will trade so that goods flow in both directions with no deficit.

So, we have to tease apart the question of "do I want to buy this good" with the question of "why do people on one border consistently buy more goods than those on another". The former is up to individual preferences, but the latter -- the trade deficit -- is really just a matter of policy.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by gonvaled on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @02:38PM (#18017937)
Well, that is how much the dollars are worth then.
Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @02:47PM (#18018025)
The dollars are worth whatever the relative foreign policies set. If China has a policy to depreciate against the dollar, by printing Yuan and buying dollars with them (what happens now) then the dollars end up being "worth" more, but the underlying capacity to produce of the U.S. hasn't increased, indeed it starts to decrease as people start to buy cheaper foreign output.

So it's a bit disingenuous to say "well, people like these cheap goods" -- I mean, of course they do, but the story here is the foreign capital inflows which create an excessively expensive currency leading to a preference for certain types of goods. The whole ground is moving underneath you as a result of international policies and you don't see it, you just see people "choosing" to act.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by gonvaled on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @02:57PM (#18018115)
The US manipulates the currency market in other, more powerful and more fundamental ways, by controlling the global currency.

You do not need to hold foreign reserves, you do not need to pay exchange commissions, you are not blocked to do business with third parties by having capital flows stopped ...

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @04:57PM (#18019056)
I don't think you understand what you are saying here. Yes, the U.S. has the world's reserve currency _because_ it allows unrestricted foreign capital inflows and has a long respect for property rights and rule of law. Try, as a foreigner, buying a house in China. It's illegal. Try, as a foreigner, to buy a house in the U.S. -- no problem. The U.S. opens it's markets to the rest of the world to purchase American assets while the rest of the world closes its markets. If you are a foreigner, you can buy all the corporate and government bonds you want. You can repatriate money out of the U.S. in unlimited amounts. In China, this is illegal. They don't even allow their own citizens to move more than a small amount of money out of their country. There is a great black market of people smuggling money into and out of china because the government restricts cross border capital flows -- like hiding money in your socks or trick suitcases, bribing border guards to let you through stuff.

This is why the U.S. is the reserve currency, and it is also why we have a trade deficit, because as the rest of the world's capital pours into the U.S., that forces our currency to be overvalued enough to have an equal sized trade deficit on the way out.

Whereas you seem to think that that the U.S. "manipulating" it's currency by making U.S. currency more attractive to hold for foreigners -- is somehow a counter or offsets what China is doing, which is making its currency less attractive to hold.

But it's not, these two work together to cause the same distortion and large trade deficits.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by gonvaled on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @10:27PM (#18021185)
Your whole argument comes down to "the dollar is overvalued". What does this mean? Bad things and good things for the US. You are not going to mention the good things, so I will.

For starters, you are using worthless (overvalued) papers to acquire real goods. The American consumer is getting a bargain.

You are also able to buy foreign assets at firesale prices (yes, for all your grandstanding, the US is not the only economy allowing direct foreign investment)

Having the world reserve currency (something the US has allowed / promoted to happen, out of interest) gives the US unfair operative advantages, already mentioned above.

The appetite for the dollar allows the US to be largely independent from the financial markets. It also allows the US to get favourable credit ratings, and financing terms which are unthinkable for other economies. This has been happening for decades, and is continuing until we reach a certain breaking point Incidentally, it is possible that this trade conflict is motivated by that breaking point getting closer.

To summarize: the US has enjoyed unfair, enourmous trade advantages for decades. It has been indulgent with its finances because the market has allowed it to be overspend. And now it wants the world to increase its already existing advantages, by claiming for "fair trade".

It is not going to happen.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @10:56PM (#18021320)
> To summarize: the US has enjoyed unfair, enourmous trade advantages for decades. It has been indulgent with its finances because the market has allowed it to be overspend. And now it wants the world to increase its already existing advantages, by claiming for "fair trade".

No, so this is where you are getting signs confused. An overvalued dollar is the same as having a trade deficit. Arguing to reduce that trade deficit is the same as arguing for a weaker dollar. The argument goes "the dollar is too strong and it should be weaker", not "you are saying the dollar is too strong and then you want it weaker also?? How dare you ask for both!" When you make these types of arguments, it worries me because it makes it sound like you aren't groking that I am advocating for a cure to a disease.

> Your whole argument comes down to "the dollar is overvalued".

Well, I think my argument is explaining _why_ we have a stronger dollar -- because we have open capital markets while our trading partners do not. This creates an asset demand for dollars that increases total demand for dollars beyond that which would be consistent with balanced trade.

> You are not going to mention the good things, so I will.

I guess I'm old school in thinking that any systemic distortion is a net harm. For example, you may not realize this, but the strong dollar doesn't actually allow us to consume more, because it reduces our income and forces government benefit spending to bridge the gap. If you look at patterns of household consumption, they have not gone up -- the big gain in consumption was higher healthcare costs, but that's a price inflation thing. Basically those areas that lose out to globalization end up receiving social security disability dollar for dollar.

Next, the trade deficit is primarily offshoring, so instead of buying a wrench made in the U.S., we are buying an american branded wrench made in China. How many chinese brands can you name? You are buying the same american products, except they are no longer made here.

But, it's the same wrench, and in real terms it costs the same. We are not getting an extra wrench, there is no "extra consumption" -- there is just loss of domestic production followed up with increased foreign purchases as large numbers of formerly productive people drop out of the labor force and rely on government assistance. We just stopped producing something domestically and bought it overseas. It's not extra consumption.

How can we afford to buy it? Well, it's those extra government benefit expenditures to make up for all the income lost, together with lower interest rates from foreign demand for our assets and then we get asset bubbles as a side effect. China, more than anyone else, was responsible for the great recession.

That extra government debt also crowds out public spending on public goods -- take a look at our hollowed out cities. So, on net, we are not enjoying any more consumption, rather the ability of our nation to produce is slowly being dismantled and shipped overseas. That's an unmitigated bad.

It is also destabilizing, politically, as we have large swaths of the country that are being written off and this breeds radicalism. Also, it's sad to turn our backs on our fellow americans who worked in factories that have been shutdown and are now living on food stamps and meager benefit payments in broken down cities.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by gonvaled on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @02:03PM (#18017638)
This is a bug exploited as feature. Pretty sure this happened organically, it was not a dollar design decission, but it has, and is, exploited to the advantage of the US, economically and politically.

If we want fairer international trade, the dollar must be ditched.

Re:China Once Looked Tough on Trade. Now Its Options Are Dwi... by SubiculumCode on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @01:20PM (#18017199)
China's good can be produced in other developing countries, like Vietnam. Inflation might not result, or just be temporary.