News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @01:47PM (#1798395)
I'm not one of the (clearly many) people who automatically believes e-books should cost less than paperbacks. E-books are more useful to me than paper books, not less. Pricing and cost are unrelated except for sorghum and gypsum.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by corysama on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:35PM (#1798514)
You see, the problem is that you are being reasonable. When browsing through consumer goods, people in general often do not reason out the value of the good. They feel it out. One of the major feelings that people have in this situation is justice. "Bits costs less than paper. Therefore bit-books should cost less than paper-books because otherwise they're ripping me off!" It's not reasonable or universal, but it is a big issue in pricing.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by jseliger on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:35PM (#1798930)
The term for this is "anchoring," and some of the most interesting work on it I've read is in Dan Ariely's book _Predictably Irrational_. He shows that a) no one actually knows how much they should pay for anything until b) they get some kind of reference for it, which becomes an anchor.

He tells an entertaining story about running an experiment in some of his classes: he asks one group of classes how much they would pay to hear him read poetry and asks another how much they would pay to not hear him read poetry. Ariely notes that reading poetry is probably, how shall we say, not among his greatest strengths. The classes primed to pay pay; the ones primed not to, don't.

His experiments do, BTW, get more sophisticated than that, but I'm not at home right now.

People have "anchor" prices for books based on hardcover and softcover. Many don't realize that physical printing and distribution costs something like 10 – 15% of a book, and eBooks are not 0% by comparison. So you get lots of stuff like the OP.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by mthoms on Saturday October 16, 2010 @10:15PM (#1799430)
Apple exploits this very effectively. Related HN thread is here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1244967
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by nodata on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:14PM (#1798885)
I think you're undervaluing the value other people put in feeling and owning a physical book.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by corysama on Saturday October 16, 2010 @07:53PM (#1799192)
Paper has a lot of advantages that I know and love. But, what I'm addressing is a narrow issue I see repeated in lots of areas beyond books. That is that the perceived cost of production has a big influence on the emotional reaction to the price of the good even though it has no tangible effect on the utility of that good.

This has a basis in the fact that high-cost goods do require high prices in order to have margins and that competition does push margins closer to costs. But, most people learn about these effects in the checkout line rather than econ classes. From those experiences, the explanation a lot of people have come up with is "If its cheaper to make, charging as much or more for it is mean."

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by wmf on Saturday October 16, 2010 @06:47PM (#1799066)
Bits costs less than paper.

Yes, that's why the ebook is $14 and the paper version is $16. Expecting ebooks to be radically cheaper is where people are going wrong.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by DougWebb on Saturday October 16, 2010 @01:54PM (#1798410)
The manufacturing cost for an ebook clearly should be much less and near-zero per book. Bits are cheaper than paper. However that's just a portion of the cost; there are still distribution and royalty costs and I'd bet those make up the bulk of the price.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by cstross on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:08PM (#1798438)
The manufacturing cost for a paper book is near-zero; a mass market paperback costs on the order of 50 cents to print.

On the other hand, as long as publishers insist on DRM, the cost of setup for the encryption software and serialization of a new encrypted file for download -- including payments to the company that produced the DRM server -- may exceed the cost of that paperback.

For contractual reasons book pricing is set on the basis of the current edition in print (royalty percentages aren't static but vary with the paper edition's binding, the number sold, the discount channel, and so on), and publishers are required to provide transparent accounting to authors if challenged. So their accounting workflow for shipping ebook units has to shadow the workflow for shipping SKUs. Hachette spent roughly 20M euros building a "digital warehouse" for ebook serialization and accounting a few years ago; I'm sure the other big six did likewise. They can't do anything else, unless they renegotiate their contract boilerplate with the authors.

Meanwhile, fixed costs for editing, typesetting, design, proofreading, and marketing are identical for paper books and ebooks.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:17PM (#1798462)
The fixed costs for creating a software title are identical whether you sell the product as a CD or as a download, but in neither case do those costs have anything to do with the price of the title. The title is priced based on perceived value (usually, as perceived by the most lucrative segment of the market it addresses).

This is the second comment here that brought up editing, typesetting, &c. Is it the view of people in the publishing industry that books should be priced at a % markup over total costs? Because that seems crazy.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by cstross on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:41PM (#1798532)
The actual model for book prices is a reverse-auction: prices start high, then drop over time.

However, thanks to the evolution of printing technology, the auction only hits a few (typically 2-3) price points, and they're geared against physical format -- hardcover, A format paperback, C format, and so on. So consumers confuse the reverse auction process with the cost of a physical product.

To make matters worse, between 45% and 75% of the cover price of a physical book in a bookstore goes to the distribution chain -- bookshops and wholesalers (not the publisher or author). The chains do deep discounting for commercial reasons of their own, e.g. price wars with each other, special promotions, need to get rid of old stock to make room for new, and so on.

Thus, the actual price the publisher and author get for a book may bear little or no relationship to the price the consumers are charged for it in the shops or from Amazon.

(EDIT) People in this thread are making the common mistake of assuming the publishing industry is structured this way for some reason. It isn't. Things just happen this way because they're the sum intersecting set of business practices that didn't result in someone going bust at some point in the past 200 years. And they're locked in by contracts, established processes, and custom. This isn't a modern industry like software development: it's an ancient set of practices that have evolved over time, and many of its patterns reflect obsolete constraints that no longer exist.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:52PM (#1798559)
So, Charlie, let's stipulate that the current market for books does a lot of stupid things based on the historical entry costs for new publishers.

Putting that aside, in the brave new future where StrossCorp publishes all Stross-approved titles: do you envision pricing according to a small industrywide set of price points, and, in particular, adhering to a fixed "ebooks cost $9.99" price?

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by cstross on Saturday October 16, 2010 @06:06PM (#1798990)
What I'd like to see tried is to debut ebooks at $20. Then, every month, depreciate them by 5%, down to a floor of $5 or thereabouts. (Maybe even lower.)

Unfortunately for a publisher to try this would require (a) all new contractual boilerplate (which will be a whole barrel of laughs as they try to get the authors and their agents to accept it) and (b) new accounting procedures to calculate royalties based not on the net volume of sales but on the time from publication date of those sales.

And even then, this is only going to work out if customers are willing to wait until the book meets their criteria for affordability rather than going in search of a pirate copy of the text.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by stevenbedrick on Saturday October 16, 2010 @06:24PM (#1799023)
Personally, this would be just about perfect for me- it sort of emulates the way that I already buy books (i.e., a small number of hardcovers [usually bought at their time of release], a larger number of paperbacks, and an even larger number of used books).
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by patrickgzill on Saturday October 16, 2010 @10:04PM (#1799402)
I would encourage you to share even a back of the envelope explanation showing how the costs to distribute even 20,000 copies of an ebook would cost $10,000, given that publishers that are doing this are distributing their fixed costs of hardware and software over some large number of ebooks.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @01:59PM (#1798421)
In a non-commodity market, price is determined by value, not cost. Cost is irrelevant.

There are e-books worth $100. Harris' _Trading and Exchanges_ is a great example (although it's stupidly priced at roughly half that). It is clearly worth more in Kindle format than it is in giant-ass hardcover format. And yet it costs them $0 marginal dollars to make a new copy.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by cromulent on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:14PM (#1798619)
I think you are right, but my mind keeps wandering to the person who can drop 6000 USD on a Kindle title. I hope they get the value out of it they need.

http://www.amazon.com/2SO4-family-K3BiCl6-KH3F4-ebook/dp/B00...

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:17PM (#1798632)
Seriously, I look at this title and have no trouble at all imagining that it generates $6000 worth of value. Look at it, think about why you might need it, and then think about how much it would cost you to generate an alternative to it.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by cromulent on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:35PM (#1798682)
Again, I think you are right. In this case, I would want the hardcopy. I don't think I'm alone.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by joehand on Saturday October 16, 2010 @04:29PM (#1798793)
Why would a digital version NOT be better? This is a 1500 page book that comes with a cd full of data anyways. I guessing something like this would be used as more of a reference. Seems like the ability to search the text would make things a whole lot easier digitally.

Obviously paper books have their benefits. But some books are far better suited to be digital.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by cromulent on Sunday October 17, 2010 @02:59AM (#1799835)
I'm not saying it wouldn't be better.

I'm thinking of the situation when you would buy something like this. I'm guessing most individuals would not buy one, and any corporation or other institution would have some kind of purchasing policy that would affect a purchase of this size.

An institution would probably not want a non-shareable Kindle copy - rather than buy each individual a Kindle copy, they would buy the hardcopy and stick it on the shelf.

Institutions that I am familiar with, anyway.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by Confusion on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:42PM (#1798950)
Having handled books from that series, I can assure you that a Kindle edition with proper search capabilities is definitely worth more than the physical version.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by jamesbritt on Saturday October 16, 2010 @06:52PM (#1799074)
At least one reviewer has an interesting take on it

http://www.amazon.com/review/R1WUN3F61QZD5Y/ref=cm_cr_dp_per...

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by ximeng on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:31PM (#1798671)
The review for that book is entertaining.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by falldowngoboom on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:48PM (#1798960)
And the one-touch purchase button has never been more terrifying.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by thibaut_barrere on Saturday October 16, 2010 @06:44PM (#1799059)
My thoughts exactly :)
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by Confusion on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:39PM (#1798945)
It aren't individuals that purchase such books, but rather universities, companies and research institutions.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by shasta on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:49PM (#1798714)
> In a non-commodity market, price is determined by value, not cost. Cost is irrelevant.

What is the "value" you're talking about here? Certainly not fair market value, when DRM and device lock-in leave little semblance of a free market. Or maybe you mean utility to the purchaser, but that varies wildly.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:57PM (#1798731)
I mean utility to the purchaser.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by shasta on Saturday October 16, 2010 @04:35PM (#1798805)
That's not a single number, it's a distribution, and it's much more complicated than that since the distribution of prices people are willing to pay for any particular item depends on the prices of the other items in the store.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @04:47PM (#1798831)
Yes. Welcome to marketing.

Your last sentence is an instance of price points. Yes, price points are part of what goes into perceived value. If you want to break out of a price point, you have many opportunities to change packaging, promotion, or pricing models to do that.

Clearly, for example, textbooks don't honor book store price points. Neither do magazines or serialized books. Neither do standards documents or technical books (as graphically illustrated upthread by the $6,000 metals book). Neither do graphic novels.

The 250-page bound novel is also an artifact of the book store distribution channel. It may indeed be that to command a $20 price instead of a $9.99 Kindle standard price, authors will need to break out of the straightjacket of 250 page bound novels.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by shasta on Saturday October 16, 2010 @07:25PM (#1799129)
My point was just that there is no simple "value" that determines the price point. One of the factors that determines the price of things is unit cost, commodity or no.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by semanticist on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:09PM (#1798439)
And the costs of producing the text haven't changed - you still need to pay editors, proofreaders, technical editors and reviewers when necessary, people to read the slush pile to decide what to commission next.

That's all beside the point that utility determines price, not cost, although I'm not sure that's strictly true: I think that the perception of utility determines price. Because the perceived utility of an ebook is less for many people, party for practical reasons and partly because they perceive that the cost is less, they perceive that the price should be lower.

It's a beguiling idea. Even realising that production costs for ebooks aren't any lower, I still baulk at ebook pricing.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:14PM (#1798454)
Editors, proofreaders, and reviewers aren't really COGS, anyways, for the same reason that software development is accounted for in SG&A or R&D, and not "cost of sales": it's a sunk cost.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by semanticist on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:35PM (#1798931)
That's true, but in an all-ebook model you'd need to price your product to cover those costs too.

My point was that those costs don't change, but they're frequently not considered when consumers are thinking about the 'cost' of what they're buying and the perceived cost impacts on people's perceived value for some items.

Arguing that pricing your product based on its cost is mad doesn't really change that consumers feel that digital downloads should be priced less than physical media versions, even if the digital download has greater utility.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by mentat on Saturday October 16, 2010 @04:36PM (#1798808)
There's a pretty interesting blog about eBooks and publishing and the link. This entry http://jakonrath.blogspot.com/2010/09/acquisitions-editor.ht... is a more humorous approach to the question of eBook costs.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @04:53PM (#1798842)
This is a great critique of the publisher/author model, but it makes me sad that this writer also believes that his book price should have something to do with the cost of paper.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tzs on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:14PM (#1798453)
Bits are cheaper to manufacture than paper. However, their upkeep can be more. When I put a book on a shelf and ignore it for 20 years, and then try to use it, it works. When I put bits on a shelf and ignore them for 20 years, and then try to use them, it is much more of a crapshoot. It takes a lot more effort to keep my bits working for 20 years.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:22PM (#1798473)
Offsetting that is the fact that bits can be hypertextual, can be marked up without damaging the book, weigh nothing, can be backed up over the short run, support full-text search, can automatically remember your place, can be downloaded instantly instead of shipped, and support skip-to-chapter.

There clearly are ways in which bits are less valuable than ink, but my gut sense is that for most people, that's more than made up for by the ways bits are more valuable.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by ohyes on Saturday October 16, 2010 @07:26PM (#1799130)
From another angle, if I read an e-book and I like it, I can't give it to my friend, because I don't technically own it (for that matter, I can't resell it or donate it to a library either). I just have a personal license for it.

It might be more convenient from a storage perspective, but it turns out you aren't actually buying a 'thing' when you buy an e-book, you are buying a license to a 'thing'.

My automatic assumption was that the crappy paperback version and the ebook version should be about the same price, but thinking about it from a perspective of what I own, the ebook should be significantly less.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by stcredzero on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:32PM (#1798925)
E-books are more useful to me than paper books, not less.

The quality of not taking up space and needing to be physically discarded when they are obsolete is indeed worth something!

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by wwortiz on Saturday October 16, 2010 @10:03PM (#1799400)
There is however an entire market of users like me that publishers could get if they were charging less.

Right now all my purchased books are used, the publisher and author get nothing for them and I buy them because they are 4-7 dollars (mass market-hard cover) at my local bookstore.

My bookstore is however 30 minutes away and if I were to find an ebook version for 4 dollars you can bet your ass I'm buying that copy, but right now my kindle is a project gutenberg ereader. I did buy two books on my kindle when I first got it, but about a month after my kindle gift the publishers decided that 5.99-7.99 for older books and 9.99 for new books was too little and I went back to used.

Edit: Also right now the pirate market for books is growing at an amazing rate because a large amount of users can't justify the 15-20 dollars for some ebooks but still want to use their ereaders.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by cmars232 on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:08PM (#1798601)
Ebooks may be more useful, but they are also much more ephemeral and fragile than a physical copy. They are subject to accidental deletion, file corruption and future obsolescence due to closed formats, DRM and technological innovation over time.

Those bits you paid for, they are rotting. The flash memory that stores them is leaking electrons and decaying. 5-10 years from now, your purchase may well evaporate into entropy unless you take great pains to move it from media to media. That is, if this is even allowed by your locked-down hardware.

How is something so ephemeral actually worth more than a physical artifact?

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:16PM (#1798625)
For you, maybe they're not! Me, I value bits more than the artifacts that carry them. My MP3s are worth far more to me than the CDs I ripped them from; the CDs invariably got scratched or lost, and I was lugging around huge books full of them. Once iTMS came around, I virtually stopped buying them altogether.

I'm not going to argue that there aren't people who value archival formats. There clearly are.

However, it's not the job of a pricing scheme to ensure that everyone buys your product. Almost the sole job of a pricing scheme is to maximize the revenue stream commanded by the product. Literally the first step in designing a pricing scheme is to study the market, segment it by perceived value, and then price the product to attract the largest (Buyer x Price).

So, I humbly suggest: irrational attachment to physical objects as carriers of bits aside, for most people (not you, but most), the value of pure digital forms dwarfs the archival value of ink.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by semanticist on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:54PM (#1798965)
But irrational attachment to physical objects is a major factor in book pricing right now. Putting that aside because it favours your argument is like setting aside irrational attachment to designer labels when discussing the price of clothing.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @06:36PM (#1799042)
I'm happy if we're on the same page about book price anchoring being irrational, regardless of what each of us think the implications are.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by stcredzero on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:38PM (#1798939)
Ebooks may be more useful, but they are also much more ephemeral and fragile than a physical copy.

I just convert the ones I want to keep to ePub and put them into Dropbox. Then they are backed up and instantly available to all my machines as well as being backed up by my computer's normal backup mechanism.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by GHFigs on Saturday October 16, 2010 @04:33PM (#1798800)
In point of fact, all of the book stores mentioned in the article (and iBookstore, unmentioned) allow you redownload your purchases easily.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by mikecane on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:42PM (#1798537)
>>>E-books are more useful to me than paper books

Thing is, most people just read them. They don't need to search through them or even highlight. It's entertainment. It's only when we enter the realm of non-fiction -- and specialized non-fiction, at that -- can you make some sort of case for that argument. But even then, try arguing with someone that a pop star biography should be priced higher than other pop fiction books because they can "search" in it and be met with blank stares. Which I would agree with!

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by tptacek on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:53PM (#1798563)
They weigh virtually nothing.

They automatically remember your place.

You can get a new one by clicking a button.

Those are bigger advantages than the CD had over casette tapes.

In a lot of ways, many of them relevant to my mom, paper books suck compared to e-books.

Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by jasonlotito on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:00PM (#1798582)
You can resize the text. Books offer that as well, but you have to buy an entirely new book for that. Larger type usually means larger books that aren't as easy to read comfortably for the people that need the larger type. I know this first hand, as my mother-in-law has to deal with this.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by angstrom on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:50PM (#1798554)
At the same time that person could search a digital textbook to avoid wasteful hours of page flipping. I think there are cases where it makes more sense to charge more. I could take a larger course load if the difficulty of finding the information in my textbooks were removed.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by mattmaroon on Saturday October 16, 2010 @05:06PM (#1798865)
I was just coming here to say that myself. I'd much rather have a book on Kindle than paper. The DRM is the only reason I ever buy any book on paper at all, and that is limited to the rare one I think I will read multiple times.
Re:EBook Pricing Goes Outright Insane by jasonlotito on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:58PM (#1798577)
In this case, the author is only telling you have the story. The kindle version IS cheaper than the currently available book. The paperback isn't available until March of 2011.