News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by tptacek on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:28PM (#1795618)
Wait, what? Capitalism put them in the fucking mine.
Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by pg on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:38PM (#1795665)
There were mines in communist countries too. I think the claim of the article is that without the profit motive there wouldn't also have been the interest in exploring new markets that produced the drill that saved the miners. And they have a point there, because a lot of the technology used in communist countries was copied from capitalist ones. Communist countries would have been even poorer without capitalist ones doing R&D for them.
Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by tptacek on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:44PM (#1795698)
They were mining gold, in a mine that had a history of prior safety accidents.

Also, what does this have to do with "capitalism vs. socialism"? I'm a capitalist, and I think this op-ed is ridiculous.

Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by pg on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:57PM (#1795753)
I don't see what mining gold or dangerous conditions have to do with this. You could have both without capitalism.

The reason I used communist countries as an example is that they're the main recent instance of industrialized societies that didn't have the profit motive to drive innovation, and they support the point made in the editorial.

I'm done with this conversation now. This seems likely to turn into the sort of thread that's more of a lawyerly style debate than a collaborative search for truth, and I have a lot to do today.

Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by ryandvm on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:51PM (#1795727)
Agreed. Technology put them in, and technology got them out.
Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by maxharris on Friday October 15, 2010 @03:05PM (#1795787)
And this technology was developed how? People did it, and they did within a very specific context, without which their achievements would not have been possible. One very important element of that context is the presence of a system of social organization that protects their individual rights, leaving them free to think and act. Without these rights, that technology could not exist.
Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by tptacek on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:53PM (#1795737)
I fully agree with you that this writer's argument is a logical no-op, but I don't think the writer agrees.
Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by spokey on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:59PM (#1795764)
> [A] lot of the technology used in communist countries was copied from capitalist ones. Communist countries would have been even poorer without capitalist ones doing R&D for them.

But the "communist countries" you are talking about were largely economic backwaters to begin with. That's the same as saying "2nd/3rd world countries would have been even poorer without 1st ones doing R&D for them. Look to some of the "social democracies" for counterexamples to "communist == poor" and "communist == not innovative".

Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by kthanx on Friday October 15, 2010 @03:03PM (#1795782)
The article is trying very hard to imply that Obama is an anti-capitalist who, by wanting to shut down all privately owned companies in the US would, if he could, have stopped the innovation needed for the rescue.

It is ridiculous, but that is why he is only alluding to it - if he were to spell it out, the insanity would be too obvious.

(but I did learn a bit about the operation and the technology used in the operation, and for that I am grateful)

Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by wccrawford on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:39PM (#1795673)
Not only that, but there's no proof that those things wouldn't exist if we lacked capitalism... Or that other things wouldn't exist instead.

I like capitalism and think it's the best system yet, but it's foolish to claim to know what would have happened without it.

Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by maxharris on Friday October 15, 2010 @03:10PM (#1795804)
"I like electricity, and I think it's the best way to transmit energy across long distances yet, but it's foolish to claim to know what would happen without it."
Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by pvg on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:58PM (#1795760)
Indeed, by the same logic, capitalism also gleefully murdered all of these folks:

http://www.infoplease.com/world/disasters/fatal-us-mining-ac...

And continues to kill people in less noticed and spectacular ways in all manner mining-related work:

http://www.wvminesafety.org/fatal97.htm

I'd love to see that op-ed, as a person who enjoys both capitalism and gallows humor.

Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by cynicalkane on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:43PM (#1795690)
The miners were put there by one capitalist enterprise and rescued by another.

Let's not turn this thread into yet another parade of ideological comments about the "capitalist system".

Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by tptacek on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:45PM (#1795706)
I'm not a socialist; I think "socialist vs. capitalist" is the narrative this writer wants to create, when the reality is that this exposes a conflict between a regulated free market and an unchecked free market. Chile didn't produce the miracle drill bit; we did.
Re:Capitalism Saved the Miners by cynicalkane on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:48PM (#1795716)
I believe you, but "capitalism vs socialism" and variants on that theme are what threads like this invariably turn into, unless you are careful about qualifying your words.

Edit: it's happening already.