Also, what does this have to do with "capitalism vs. socialism"? I'm a capitalist, and I think this op-ed is ridiculous.
The reason I used communist countries as an example is that they're the main recent instance of industrialized societies that didn't have the profit motive to drive innovation, and they support the point made in the editorial.
I'm done with this conversation now. This seems likely to turn into the sort of thread that's more of a lawyerly style debate than a collaborative search for truth, and I have a lot to do today.
But the "communist countries" you are talking about were largely economic backwaters to begin with. That's the same as saying "2nd/3rd world countries would have been even poorer without 1st ones doing R&D for them. Look to some of the "social democracies" for counterexamples to "communist == poor" and "communist == not innovative".
It is ridiculous, but that is why he is only alluding to it - if he were to spell it out, the insanity would be too obvious.
(but I did learn a bit about the operation and the technology used in the operation, and for that I am grateful)